Saphroneth
Colonel
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2017
Unless Schofield had 30,000 Effectives and 30,000 other troops just driving wagon trains he'd change the ratio for the worse. It's a men-to-wagons ratio issue - historically he had about 800 wagons per corps, so Schofield would need another 1,500 wagons and 10,000 horse.As to your point #2. I'm sure Schofield had wagon trains as well. That would be added to Sherman's total, and he could have waited a bit for more as well. With a serious confederate presence in front of him i don't think he would have tried it without adequate supplies.
Sherman also couldn't wait too long, or the amount of forage he'd get would drop unacceptably. There's simply no feasible way to take enough fodder for over 20,000 pack animals - it'd be 125 tons a day per 10,000 animals, for 5,000 tons for the existing animals for a 20-day journey (thus about one and a half tons of fodder per wagon).
My understanding is that at that time the longest single process in the farm calendar was threshing the grain, before mechanical means of threshing came in.Yes, much of the food was collected already. I would expect much of it shipped off to CSA quartermasters. Let's not be naive, cavalry was shadowing Sherman and knew of the pillaging and foraging, they were doing some of that themselves. I would expect much of it as possible was kept out of Federal hands.
As to point #3. Nah, Sherman would just have done a series of flanking movements. Than again, Hood probably would have rashly attacked him on several occasions. Regardless, it could have been interesting.
Just the need to be closed up enough to manoeuvre (Hood's force being about the size of two of Sherman's columns) would slow Sherman down and reduce the area he could sweep. The goal here would be slowing Sherman down, not stopping him - it's Fabian tactics, and if the commander conducting it is skilled enough it almost doesn't matter who the victim is. Fabian himself was able to use this tactic on no less a commander than Hannibal.
Whether Hood was temperamentally suited to the Fabian role is another matter, it's a hard thing to do.