Native American weaponry

The bow as used by the Kiowa, Commanche, Lakota etc was greatly different than the European Long Bow. Those who ised it grew up using it. It is well known that by age 12 Lakota boys were shooting grasshoppers w/ their bows. The bow was silent and capable of considerably more rapid fire than pretty much any weapon available to White Folks prior to the various repeaters. What it lacked was penetration when compared to the rifle. It is telling that many a Lakota preffered to keep their bows & lances when offered muzzleloaders. The Lakota & Cheyenne in particular preffered to shorten their captured arms to a more manageable size... eye to eye combat. A difference in tactics and style o warfare.

The average Lakota may or may not have been aware of how to maintain & care for his muzzleloader. Which is part of the reason Indians didn't have a rep for being stellar shots. Doesn't take long to clean a muzzleloader, figure 15-20 minutes. Making ball is a little more involved but if you're using a smoothbore a few rocks will do.
 
Not if he couldn't feel reasonably confident in having powder and ball. And how long would it take to make bullets (assuming lead and the tools) and gunpowder (assuming resources and tools)?

That seems to be a whole lot of assuming....

reminds me of the old saw... "If we had some bacon, we could have some bacon and eggs, if we had some eggs"

Did they have either or access to a readily available supply of either?
 
Bama: That's my point. It wouldn't be too hard to keep supplied with arrows. And we've heard it takes half an hour to make an arrow which might be reusable (not very good odds, but not impossible). How much effort would it take to keep supplied with bullets and gunpowder without reliable access to (outside) supplies?

I'm assuming access to those tools and resources because otherwise the time is "forever" - in other words, its impossible.
 
Bama: That's my point. It wouldn't be too hard to keep supplied with arrows. And we've heard it takes half an hour to make an arrow which might be reusable (not very good odds, but not impossible). How much effort would it take to keep supplied with bullets and gunpowder without reliable access to (outside) supplies?

I'm assuming access to those tools and resources because otherwise the time is "forever" - in other words, its impossible.

It ain't that easy. The arrow shafts have to be dried. The wood for the bows must be split from a tree at least eight inches in diameter, then dried and worked down to one growth ring on the back of the bow, otherwise it would break. Violate the growth ring and the bow will break.

Many people think the bow and arrow as some backwards primitive technology. The physics of the atlatl is beyond comprehension of most modern humans.

Humans 10,000 years ago were much more intelligent than we are today. We don't need intelligence to survive today. If we are unable to reproduce, science has figured out how someone abnormal, can carry on their defective genes.

I'm sorry, I just get frustrated at modern humans and our arrogance.

Sincerely,
dvrmte
 
It ain't that easy. The arrow shafts have to be dried. The wood for the bows must be split from a tree at least eight inches in diameter, then dried and worked down to one growth ring on the back of the bow, otherwise it would break. Violate the growth ring and the bow will break.

Many people think the bow and arrow as some backwards primitive technology. The physics of the atlatl is beyond comprehension of most modern humans.

Well, its easy enough. Its not like making a gun by hand was a matter of slapping something together. As for the atlatl...we don't need them to survive, so of course we've forgotten the skills. That's sort of like saying zeppelins are beyond our ken.

Humans 10,000 years ago were much more intelligent than we are today. We don't need intelligence to survive today. If we are unable to reproduce, science has figured out how someone abnormal, can carry on their defective genes.

I'm sorry, I just get frustrated at modern humans and our arrogance.

Sincerely,
dvrmte

I'm afraid to ask what kind of arrogance you have in mind. I have a feeling the comment on defective genes will lead places that won't end well. Not saying you're targeting anyone, just sounds like a seriously angry rant.
 
My last nerve is tingling. We've been treated with "an arrow can be made in a half-hour." That was supposing that the shaft was there and the knapping was done and the glue was made. One arrow was the result of weeks of work. Two might be included in those weeks. Make just one and then get back to me how much fun it was. And how easy.

Ole
 
Easy enough to allow armies all over the world to use archers by the hundreds and thousands without having to have a "total war footing". That's easy enough for me to consider it relatively easy.

I wouldn't want to make a couple dozen arrows and a good bow, but its not a feat to rival any of Hercules, either.
 
You really don't get it. Do you? We have grups and we disagree, almost all the time. And we do that in a grup spirit. Nemmine.
 
You really don't get it. Do you? We have grups and we disagree, almost all the time. And we do that in a grup spirit. Nemmine.

I misplaced my grup. Where can I get another? The Nemmine was out of them.

I understand that arrow making was winter or quiet time work. The shafts , etc would be gathered up and maybe as many as a hundred assembled over a week or so. Doing each step en masse was much more efficient. Didn't they use arrows with blunt ends for birds, so as to not damage the flesh.
 
I misplaced my grup. Where can I get another? The Nemmine was out of them.

I understand that arrow making was winter or quiet time work. The shafts , etc would be gathered up and maybe as many as a hundred assembled over a week or so. Doing each step en masse was much more efficient. Didn't they use arrows with blunt ends for birds, so as to not damage the flesh.

Most all intact quivers found of primitive man contain more blunts than those with stone tips. Small game was encountered more often than big game.

dvrmte
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top