Native American weaponry

Since he was involved at Pea Ridge, I'm sure that he must have been under cannon fire by the Union artillery before capturing it. And I've never noticed it Larry, but one of your wife or grandkid's ancestors was with the 15th AL. So he was one of the Confederates that constantly charged Little Round Top?

Actually two of her ancestors were there. Pvt. Hershel Glenn attacked the 20th Maine with the 15th AL. He was paroled at Appamatox. Cpl. James Whaley with the 51st GA was captured at the Devil's Den on July 2. He spent the remainder of the war at Ft. Delaware. My ancestor Pvt. John Rouse with the 48th VA attacked Culp's Hill.
 
The strength and power of an arrow comes from the person who's actually pulling the string. It doesn't rely on a propellant like a gun. So if you get hit by an arrow fired from a big burly man it's gonna hurt. But from someone who's scrawny? Not as bad.
Golly, Duke. I get to disagree with you for a change. The propellant is all in the bow. If a scrawny man can pull the string, the result is the same. While it is true that a bow with a stronger pull will propel an arrow with greater force, and that a burly man might have a more powerful bow, it remains that the power is in the bow. And whoever can draw it back.

Ole
 
Longbows make a good example of the potential effectiveness of archery, though, so I think its a fair example. Maybe guns are better, but bows can still be quite nasty.
And it was taken that way -- as an example of archery in war. We were, however, talking about Native American weaponry, which is far from the long bow or the recurve carried by the golden horde. Compared to them, the Indian bow was primitive, but for sending pointy things down range, it worked well enough.
 
This is a tad out of context, but interesting, to me at least. During archaeology digs in then 1970s in the area around Jamestown, Virginia they unearthed a couple of sets of European armor which was worn by early settlers (1620s) who took on the Pamunkey sharpshooters with, yes, bows and arrows. The long rifles that the Englishmen carried were so heavy the had to rest on a forked stick for support. If the barrel dipped below horizontal, the ball simply rolled out the end of the barrel since there was no chamber. Studies by the idiots in Virginia who worry about such things determined that a competent warrior could propel at least 14 deadly arrows in the time it took to reload the weapon. (Probably not a "rifle", more likely smooth bore.) White folks have never been really smart when it comes to war. (Current equipment excepted. If you see a drone over your head, duck, if your head is still connected.)
 
Another minor factor, Larry, was that the thunderstick was very scary. Imagine, if you will, sneaking up on a small body of armored soldiers and one of them touches off a round in your general direction. Chances are the round hit no one, but the noise and the smoke would have been a one-time-only experience.
 
I keep thinking of that scene in Raiders of the Lost Ark where Indy shoots the fancy sword-wielding fella.
 
Up until around the development of the minie ball, I'd rather have good archers than musketeers. The sound and stink of the musket aside, a good bow in a good archer's hands was a better weapon.

I'm not sure about the bows of the Confederate Indians. Making a good bow is a craft.
 
Up until around the development of the minie ball, I'd rather have good archers than musketeers. The sound and stink of the musket aside, a good bow in a good archer's hands was a better weapon.

I'm not sure about the bows of the Confederate Indians. Making a good bow is a craft.

I consider myself a bowyer as I've made several primitive bows. I can't see indians with only a bow and a war club making a sustained attack against infantry. They could only carry 20 - 30 arrows at best and where would they get their resupply? The indians made excellent bows. The Penobscot invented a double bow that could be called a compound bow.

English archers were successful because of civilian support. The entire country was employed to keep the archers armed, similiarly to
Confederate women making ammo for the army. I haven't seen any evidence that they had that support so I assume they made their own arrows. IMO there is no way bow and arrows had any large effect other than a novelty in the ACW.

Stand Watie was successful making raids and that type warfare suited the Cherokee. They were used to close in fighting and were appalled that men would line up to shoot at each other. Indian type warfare was suited for guerilla tactics.

Just some thoughts,
dvrmte
 
I consider myself a bowyer as I've made several primitive bows. I can't see indians with only a bow and a war club making a sustained attack against infantry. They could only carry 20 - 30 arrows at best and where would they get their resupply? The indians made excellent bows. The Penobscot invented a double bow that could be called a compound bow.

Same as the original source. Arrows aren't that hard to make. As for carrying only 20-30? Lots of ways to carry more. Put quivers (plural intended) on horses and carry them.

English archers were successful because of civilian support. The entire country was employed to keep the archers armed, similiarly to
Confederate women making ammo for the army. I haven't seen any evidence that they had that support so I assume they made their own arrows. IMO there is no way bow and arrows had any large effect other than a novelty in the ACW.

Agreed except on the civilian support issue (not saying there wasn't a fair amount of that, but it wasn't necessary). But that doesn't make the bow a bad weapon.

Stand Watie was successful making raids and that type warfare suited the Cherokee. They were used to close in fighting and were appalled that men would line up to shoot at each other. Indian type warfare was suited for guerilla tactics.

Just some thoughts,
dvrmte

Well founded and much appreciated.
 
I can't see indians with only a bow and a war club making a sustained attack against infantry.
They didn't. The brave was willing to die counting coup, but one thing they never did was risk substantial losses -- that could damage the entire tribe. One or two, here and there, now and then was tolerable, but losing 10 or 20 was not.

Exception: When their families were in danger (King Phillip's War, Little Big Horn). they'd fight to the last man.

Other than that, it was the raid. Sneak in, kill a few, and run away. Come back again later. No offensive pitched battles.
 
Ever made one?

No. But if they were hard to make, having large numbers of men armed with bow and arrow would not have been practical. The fact that such was practiced up until bows were replaced with guns seems to indicate it was practical enough. Between that and hunting, obviously a fair number of people in the old days could make an arrow or a bow. Was it "easy"? Maybe not. But it wasn't some exotic skill requiring more effort than equiping a man with say, mail armor.

Meanwhile, the main disadvantage of the longbowman (looking there because of the use of great numbers of archers - relative the size of any given Indian tribe, that is) was the length of time it took to train an archer, not the difficulty of keeping him supplied.
 
The bow was their life. There was no practicality about it. You made your bow and you made your arrows (or gave someone your daughter to do it for you), or you starved or got clubbed by the first guy that came by and wanted your wife. Couldn't trade beaver skins at the local arrow store.
 
I'm don't claim to be an expert but I can make a suitable arrow from a previously selected and dried shaft in about half an hour. If green shafts were selected, accuracy would have been terrible.

The basic technology for survival is the ability to make twine. How many on this forum know how to make twine, naked in the wilderness?

I know from bow hunting that arrows are lethal but the ability to sustain an attack during the ACW against musketry, I can't imagine. Possible in certain situations but not on a typical civil war battlefield.

dvrmte
 
I don't even know how to be naked in the wilderness, much less make twine in such a condition. Or an arrow. Or a minie ball. I do know that given a choice between a rifle and a bow and arrow, I'll take the rifle, thanks. I'm probably not alone in that.
 
I'm don't claim to be an expert but I can make a suitable arrow from a previously selected and dried shaft in about half an hour. If green shafts were selected, accuracy would have been terrible.

The basic technology for survival is the ability to make twine. How many on this forum know how to make twine, naked in the wilderness?

Not me. But I imagine those who had to do it or perish had it down.

I'm know from bow hunting that arrows are lethal but the ability to sustain an attack during the ACW against musketry, I can't imagine. Possible in certain situations but not on a typical civil war battlefield.

dvrmte

Not any harder than keeping a regiment supplied with cartridges. The Indians may not have the set up for it, but that's a weakness on their part, not of bows vs. guns.

Beyond that, I'm not sure. Civil war rifles were slower to fire than a bow might be but otherwise superior.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top