Native American weaponry

Not me. But I imagine those who had to do it or perish had it down.



Not any harder than keeping a regiment supplied with cartridges. The Indians may not have the set up for it, but that's a weakness on their part, not of bows vs. guns.

Beyond that, I'm not sure. Civil war rifles were slower to fire than a bow might be but otherwise superior.

You notice the slow progress west until the invention of repeating weapons.

dvrmte
 
You notice the slow progress west until the invention of repeating weapons.

dvrmte

It would be interesting to see how much of that was for other reasons and how much had to do with guns vs. bows.

Moving out west, even without any but imaginary threats from Indians, was a seriouns undertaking. But by the end of the 1860s, it became a lot easier.
 
I'm don't claim to be an expert but I can make a suitable arrow from a previously selected and dried shaft in about half an hour. If green shafts were selected, accuracy would have been terrible.

The basic technology for survival is the ability to make twine. How many on this forum know how to make twine, naked in the wilderness?

I know from bow hunting that arrows are lethal but the ability to sustain an attack during the ACW against musketry, I can't imagine. Possible in certain situations but not on a typical civil war battlefield.

dvrmte

AHA!!!!! I'm finally able to be superior to at least a few folks.....not only can I make an arrowhead from scratch (sorry for the Betty Crocker terminology), but I can also make my own twine and fishing net from lechuguilla and a ****ed good basket from sotol leaves, thank you very much. I can also attach the arrowhead to the shaft. Catching a bird for the feathers would take longer, but I can also make an atlatl. The things teachers do in summer Gifted and Talented workshops!!!!! (If left to fend for myself along the Pecos river, I can also feed and clothe myself). Now....it will take me a while, so whatever I want to hunt will be extinct by the time I actually put the equipment together.....
 
I don't even know how to be naked in the wilderness, much less make twine in such a condition. Or an arrow. Or a minie ball. I do know that given a choice between a rifle and a bow and arrow, I'll take the rifle, thanks. I'm probably not alone in that.

I kinda missed this post before I added the previous one. Uh....I was not naked at the workshop (remembering the other folks at the workshop, all I can say is Thank God.) My point in all this is not that a bow and arrow is superior to a gun--otherwise, Indians wouldn't have traded in the bow and arrow for guns. It's that a bow and arrow is quite deadly, painful, and many people succumbed to this weaponry because it was both silent and deadly. Regarding the size of the man, Ole is quite right. I was reading several accounts last night of "scrawny Indians" killing perfectly tough frontiersmen. Squaws often picked up a bow and arrow to join in the fight, so sheer size and weight was pretty unimportant. Children were given tiny bows and arrows and taught to make them from toddlerhood (I can just imagine walking through a camp with a bunch of little kids firing away at you....ouch), so it was second nature. Most male Indians spent their time hunting, talking, raiding or making arrows while the women did the heavy labor, so there was plenty of time to put together a plethora of arrows. And again....I was NOT naked at the teacher workshop.
 
Nate, glad to hear that you've learned survival skills. My dad made us bows when we were kids. We made arrows of river cane with duct tape for fletching. I learned to shoot instinctive. I shoot an arrow like I throw a ball. I look at what I want to hit and let the arrow go letting my subconscious mind deal with trajectory, wind, etc.

My brother took the opposite path and bought compound bows, you know, the ones with training wheels. He uses range finders, carbon arrows, trigger releases and lighted pendulum sights.

At the indoor target range he smokes my butt, often doing a Robin Hood (splitting an arrow with another). But on my wooded range, especially where I want let him use his rangefinder, I wear him out.

My cousin taught me the basics of knapping projectile points but I learned how to make a proper primitive bow and arrows from info on the internet. I use deer sinew to fasten the feathers and points to the shafts. I use yucca twine for my wet weather hunting as the sinew comes apart in the rain. Milkweed makes excellent fiber but generally not strong enough for bow strings so I make them of sinew or yucca.

Twine is most essential for snares. Indians usually carried mostly blunt arrows with them on hunts indicating mostly small game hunting. This is based on the few quivers found intact.

dvrmte
 
Do you ever watch Man vs. Wild with Bear Grylls? He's always finding a reason to take off his shirt in every episode.

I like Survivorman better. He doesn't take along the support staff that Bear does. He got totally naked in the last episode I watched. He was in the Altamaha swamps of Georgia.

dvrmte
 
I like Survivorman better. He doesn't take along the support staff that Bear does. He got totally naked in the last episode I watched. He was in the Altamaha swamps of Georgia.
I like Les better too!! Bear is always doing stuff that looks so unnecessary and like it would get you killed if you tried to imitate his example. And you know it was found out that he stays in hotels at night. Plus, whatever daring death-defying deeds he's doing, I always remember that there's another guy doing the same deeds, only that guy's doing them while walking backwards and carrying 80lbs of camera gear.

Les is more genuine -- you look at the show's credits and there are about seven jobs listed, and Les does about five of them. He doesn't rush around crazily and jump off cliffs. That is the guy I'd want to have around in a survival situation. I saw that Georgia episode, too.
 
Are we quite finished with talk about naked dvrmte?

Sheesh. Go to bed and there are 20 more posts.

A half-hour dvr? Are you forgetting the time it takes to find and season a shaft? Can you find and knap a head in a half-hour? How far away was the store where you bought the thongs to tie the head to the shaft?

Ooooh. Sounds like I'm picking on you. Not intentional. Just trying to illustrate that making arrows was a big deal. Those who could make really good arrows were likely quite wealthy and ate very well. We, today, tend to forget that an arrow was complex. There was the head, the binding, the seasoned shaft, the fletching and the glue. Might cost a horse or a daughter to get a quiver-full. And you can bet that they retrieved every single one of them shot.

Spect I could make one as well. What boggles is finding the shaft. And seasoning it. Have no idea how that was done. Point is that much of an Indian male's life was devoted to making or buying arrows. And much of a boy's life was dedicated to learning how to shoot them effectively. The arrow was meat. Simple as that.

Ole
 
I like Les better too!! Bear is always doing stuff that looks so unnecessary and like it would get you killed if you tried to imitate his example. And you know it was found out that he stays in hotels at night. Plus, whatever daring death-defying deeds he's doing, I always remember that there's another guy doing the same deeds, only that guy's doing them while walking backwards and carrying 80lbs of camera gear.

Les is more genuine -- you look at the show's credits and there are about seven jobs listed, and Les does about five of them. He doesn't rush around crazily and jump off cliffs. That is the guy I'd want to have around in a survival situation. I saw that Georgia episode, too.

Les doesn't always succeed either. He's had to leave earlier and stay later than expected. Both of them need to work on their fishing skills, though.

Les was in the Georgia swamps at the best time possible for survival. It looked to be late winter or early spring. Survival in that swamp would be extremely tough in mid summer.

dvrmte
 
As I recall, Les actually did break his ankle in one episode. Don't recall which one. He also plays a mean harmonica.
 
On the pretense of returning to the subject: Do we know how many of the Indians using bows and spears attempted to get guns to replace them?

And how any such efforts worked out.

The far west was well removed from any strong source of supply for those, but trees are (well, virtually) anywhere.
 
The Indian was not stupid. Of couse he'd rather get a rifle and ammo. A musket, some powder and a ball or three were vastly superior to sitting around all day making arrows.

Time lines.

Before the white eyes moved in. The arrow was all there was. When the mountain men and the traders moved in, they got exposed to metal pots and hatchets and guns and whiskey. And they became caught between two worlds ... the old one and the new one.

It is quite romantic to think of them as rugged individualists, but it is only romantic. When people came with plows and railroads and seed, the nomadic plains tribes were finished. It's not a pretty story, but that's the way it shook out.
 
The Indian was not stupid. Of couse he'd rather get a rifle and ammo. A musket, some powder and a ball or three were vastly superior to sitting around all day making arrows.

Not if he couldn't feel reasonably confident in having powder and ball. And how long would it take to make bullets (assuming lead and the tools) and gunpowder (assuming resources and tools)?
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top