I wouldn't think so. Firstly, the same conditions that inhibit mobile warfare during the winter would impede maneuvers. Second, conducting training maneuvers in a theater of operations is liable to be mistaken by the enemy for the real deal with who knows what consequences. Thirdly, the field armies may not be able to spare the formations from operational duties so they could conduct maneuvers. Fourthly, the field armies may not be able to support such training exercises without compromising operational logistics. And fifthly, there is simply no tradition or understanding (let alone capability) in the US Army of the necessity to exercise formations so I highly doubt the Confederates would eitherThe ANV had failures on the battlefield was any consideration given to large scale winter maneuvers to polish up Corp and Division command ability to handle their commands in the field.
What could be done to improve combat readiness during the downtime of winter.I wouldn't think so. Firstly, the same conditions that inhibit mobile warfare during the winter would impede maneuvers. Second, conducting training maneuvers in a theater of operations is liable to be mistaken by the enemy for the real deal with who knows what consequences. Thirdly, the field armies may not be able to spare the formations from operational duties so they could conduct maneuvers. Fourthly, the field armies may not be able to support such training exercises without compromising operational logistics. And fifthly, there is simply no tradition or understanding (let alone capability) in the US Army of the necessity to exercise formations so I highly doubt the Confederates would either
In fact, even the British with their much larger army, only began training exercises at brigade level in the Home Isles on the very eve of the Crimean War (at least one field maneuver involving about 10,00 troops took place in about 1852 in India). The United States Army wouldn't conduct its first field maneuver (about 5,000 troops) until 1902, and the first peacetime training exercise with a provisional division didn't happen until 1911. Prussia, by contrast, had been doing field maneuvers at a division and corps level since the Napoleonic Wars.
I think field maneuvers and a proper training program would have benefited both armies but it simply wasn't possible for the Confederacy.
Among other things, getting as much rest as possible to make up for the exertion and stress of the campaign season. The horses and mules expecially would need to build up their strength.What could be done to improve combat readiness during the downtime of winter.
To be honest, I am not really certain. About all I can think of offhand is that some elementary instruction in marksmanship couldn't hurt.What could be done to improve combat readiness during the downtime of winter.
Drill I would think. A well drilled unit would be more combat effective though a 'green' unit would likely be poor in its first engagement either way. It really depends on the unit, the winter, and the location. A regiment in the ANV in December of 1864 needs very different things than an AotP regiment in January of 1862.What could be done to improve combat readiness during the downtime of winter.
As I recall, Napoleon didn't do so well against the Russians in November and December of 1812. The Russians didn't do so well either, but they retained control of Russia. Would winter maneuvers have helped to prepare either side for what actually took place? If Napoleon had started in May would he still have had a difficult winter? Would winter maneuvers help prepare an army in the northern latitudes for winter or summer conflicts or was the climate just too much for large scale military conflicts using 19th century technology?I'm certainly no expert on any of this but if I remember correctly the Great Frederick conducted what is considered by some a classic battle of maneuver at Lethem on December 5th. 1757 that lead to a victory against the Austrians.
Similarly, Napoleon faced off in a very bloody battle against the Russians on February 7th. and 8 th., 1807 at Eylau.
Believe me no criticism of our gallant lads, North or South, is intended, however if the Europeans could fight battles in it...................
John
It is my impression that in 1803 or 1804 a very large military camp was established by the French Army under Napoleon at Boulogne. If I'm not mistaken maneuvering by very large formations, Divisions and even Corps was practised there.
John
Eylau is perhaps the ultimate example of why you don't campaign in the winter.I'm certainly no expert on any of this but if I remember correctly the Great Frederick conducted what is considered by some a classic battle of maneuver at Lethem on December 5th. 1757 that lead to a victory against the Austrians.
Similarly, Napoleon faced off in a very bloody battle against the Russians on February 7th. and 8 th., 1807 at Eylau.
Believe me no criticism of our gallant lads, North or South, is intended, however if the Europeans could fight battles in it...................
John
I'm not so sure the imposing geography is quite as critical a difference, because it's not like European winter warfare took place entirely in plains with good infrastructure. That said, I would agree with you if what you meant specifically was low population density, because that really is a pretty major difference - Switzerland in 1800 (hardly an especially flat and fertile region of Europe!) had about 100 people per square mile across the whole area, while Virginia (with about the same population in 1860 as Switzerland had in 1800) had four times the land area of Switzerland and thus a quarter the population density.There are three fundamental, critical differences between the American Civil War and the heyday of European winter warfare; the size of armies, the professionalism of armies, and America's imposing geography, criss-crossing major rivers, and the poor infrastructure of the American South.
'Geography' is indeed vague, and Europe isn't a monolith - the campaigns of Gustavus alone ranged from Livonia to Germany. But there are a lot of factors tied up in the land itself that sometimes apply and sometimes don't, with population density being the one that is basically always consistently applicable that make winter campaigning in the ACW a lot more difficult than in most examples of successful winter campaigning that come to mind for me.I'm not so sure the imposing geography is quite as critical a difference, because it's not like European winter warfare took place entirely in plains with good infrastructure. That said, I would agree with you if what you meant specifically was low population density, because that really is a pretty major difference - Switzerland in 1800 (hardly an especially flat and fertile region of Europe!) had about 100 people per square mile across the whole area, while Virginia (with about the same population in 1860 as Switzerland had in 1800) had four times the land area of Switzerland and thus a quarter the population density.
This matters because armies on campaign do so by taking food from the locals. If there are a quarter as many locals, there is a quarter as much food.
There are some places where it can be considered to apply, but for the most part I think the main campaigns take place in farmland areas - the AoP and AoNV spend their entire existence campaigning over good farmland except for more or less just The Wilderness and a few fights over mountain passes. Rosecrans going over the mountains to get to Chattanooga is a bit more high-elevation and dealing with Big Geography, though I suspect we could find comparable instances of dealing with tough mountains in Europe - the question being if the Alps or Pyrenees are more correct."America has a lot of forests and rivers" tends to be somewhat exaggerated as a factor making the Civil War unique, considering that Napoleon campaigned across imposing rivers, mountains, forests, etc., and indeed coordinated vastly disparate actions in both 1809 and in the simultaneous wars in Spain and Russia, something that is occasionally attributed as a new innovation to Grant. But I do feel that the sense that American geography being more hostile than that typical of Europe is an overly general exaggeration of something that has a kernel of merit, though that is for now more vibes than something I have dug deeply into to substantiate in a more concrete way.