HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I rank Mannix first ,then Cannon and last Barnaby Jones. Of course the Rockford Files may be the best of all.

I think, overall, "Lookwell" with Adam West is the best... An actor who starred in a Quinn-Martin style detective show in the '70s who moonlights as an actual Private Detective... Only one episode of 22 min. But classic!

Mr. West was in some Westerns too in his time. He was an army officer in Geronimo with Chuck Connors. Also in the Three Stooges last movie, "The Outlaws is Coming!" (1965).

1737320821120.png


Also in 1959 he played Doc Holliday on TV twice on ABC productions, in an episode of "Lawman" and another of "Sugarfoot." And was in an episode of Gunsmoke shortly after.
 
I think, overall, "Lookwell" with Adam West is the best... An actor who starred in a Quinn-Martin style detective show in the '70s who moonlights as an actual Private Detective... Only one episode of 22 min. But classic!

Mr. West was in some Westerns too in his time. He was an army officer in Geronimo with Chuck Connors. Also in the Three Stooges last movie, "The Outlaws is Coming!" (1965).

View attachment 535923

Also in 1959 he played Doc Holliday on TV twice on ABC productions, in an episode of "Lawman" and another of "Sugarfoot." And was in an episode of Gunsmoke shortly after.
I am so old I remember the themes and stars of both Lawman and Sugarfoot from when the first aired.
 
My father complains that his tv channels only show the later episodes of Gunsmoke in color. He says they don't show the first 11 or 12 seasons in B/W for some reason.

William Conrad was the voice of Marshal Dillon on the radio for a long time. Later better known to TV audiences as "Cannon" and from "Jake and the Fatman." Conrad also directed episodes of a few different TV Westerns.

Here's Conrad as Matt Dillon in a promo for the Gunsmoke radio show...

View attachment 535886

Conrad on Matt Dillon:

Of all the Quinn-Martin style detective shows of the 60s to 80s, I liked Cannon the best as a crumb cruncher (I watched it in syndication). Perhaps too in part as he narrated the opening of the intro to Buck Rogers!

I met Conrad once and he was cordial, if distant. I mentioned that I was happy to meet the original Matt Dillon and he was not at all pleased or flattered. It was clear he didn't want to be reminded of that. I would have been better off if I had mentioned Rocky & Bullwinkle instead.
 
Agreed. It was sort of like the Andy Griffith show. It fell off once it got to color (and lost Barney).
I agree; it was never the same once it went to an hour and then to color, although there were some great episodes during all those years. Arness wanted more time off, so they began bringing in guest stars and building stories around the other characters. I also never liked Ken Curtis's Festus shtick, although he was a lot better when he was the main character in the story. The 2-part color episode with him and Strother Martin was excellent. I think Dennis Weaver's Chester was more believable and Weaver was a lot better actor. In the last few years, they still had some great episodes, but you could see that age was catching up to Arness and really all of them. Amanda Blake was fired before the final season (some say she deliberately made so many unreasonable demands that she wanted to be fired, but couldn't bring herself to quit). It was still a phenomenal twenty-year run of excellence and I still rate it among the top 3 or 4 series westerns. I put The Virginian pretty high up there and Deadwood was the modern iteration of Gunsmoke. I also liked The Lawman and think it was underrated, and Have Gun, Will Travel.
 
Just watched California as well. Not the biggest fan, including of the music, but there are much worse. Interestingly the changed German titles create several faux connections to more famous films, a quite common theme, one being Der Mann aus Virginia (connecting to The Virginian) and one being Spiel das Lied von Kalifornien (connecting to Once Upon a Time in the West). Meanwhile it is always nice to see Raimund Harmstorf.
 
Agreed. It was sort of like the Andy Griffith show. It fell off once it got to color (and lost Barney).
One thing about Gunsmoke that I can't get over is how similar it is to Andy Griffith Show. Both Matt Dillon and Andy are calm sheriffs (well in Gunsmoke's case marshall) that try and make the right desicions, both shows are set in a small town, and both have some comical deputy. In addition, once they got to color, both shows weren't as good.
 
One thing about Gunsmoke that I can't get over is how similar it is to Andy Griffith Show. Both Matt Dillon and Andy are calm sheriffs (well in Gunsmoke's case marshall) that try and make the right desicions, both shows are set in a small town, and both have some comical deputy. In addition, once they got to color, both shows weren't as good.

Marshal Dillon wracked up a HUGE body count during the course of the show Gunsmoke!

According to one accounting, During the 20-year span of CBS's Gunsmoke series, Marshal Dillon shot 138 men and seven women at least, and up to 303 people, as many times its not clear if they were finished off. If you add in the ones Marshal Dillon shot in the five made-for-TV movies in the 1980s (1987-1994), he shot something like 407 people.

Paul Sassone, however, reviewed all of the black and white seasons, 1-11, and found a total of 211 kills by the Marshal before the color seasons.

1737592224706.png


According to a count by Marshall Trimble, the vice president of the Wild West History Association, Marshal Matt Dillon was shot at least 56 times, knocked unconscious 29 times, stabbed three times, and poisoned once.
Actor James Arness, who played the Marshal, did some fancy pistol work here and there on the show...
Andy Griffith on his show, never actually fired a gun.

James Arness, who played Matt Dillon for so long, was a veteran of the US Army in World War II, serving with the 3rd Infantry Division in the Battle of Anzio, where he was seriously wounded in action on February 1, 1944. He had been enrolled in college, but wrote his local draft board to put his name at the top of the list! He was inducted at Fort Snelling, Minnesota, trained at Camp Wheeler, Georgia, and ended up in action at Anzio with the second platoon, Easy Company, 2nd Battalion, 7th US Infantry Regiment (The "Cottonbalers.")
1737593835704.png


In his memoir, Mr. Arness says his first REAL gunfight at Anzio was on a night patrol, when fired upon by a hidden German 20mm Anti-aircraft gun... one of the tracers came awful close, and he says if a couple veterans hadn't held him down, he'd have unnecessarily exposed himself to get out of there! He had a belly full of fighting thereafter, and quickly learned in a gunfight to lay down and spread out. On the night of Feb. 1 he was shot through the leg from ambush while walking point, and he noted the Germans' machine gun fire was raking about 18 inches off the ground, pinning him down while they threw grenades at him. The wound splintered the bones of his right leg, for which he had to have several surgeries in future years.

Though still fit, Mr. Arness was still pained by the injuries,

1737593073326.png


...and in the later years a double was kept on hand on set to let him rest some.

1737592951292.png
 
Last edited:
One thing about Gunsmoke that I can't get over is how similar it is to Andy Griffith Show. Both Matt Dillon and Andy are calm sheriffs (well in Gunsmoke's case marshall) that try and make the right desicions, both shows are set in a small town, and both have some comical deputy. In addition, once they got to color, both shows weren't as good.
The actual history of Dodge City is very different from the series. It was very violent but there were many law officers in the town including Masterson and Earp.That was later in the 1870s when Dodge had grown. It was a bit crazy to think Matt could leave town and put Chester in charge. Also the timeline was really off. In 1873 ,which the series is largely set in , Dodge was some buildings and still had tents set up. There were references in the series to Dodge up to 20 years earlier when there was absolutely no town there. There were several other historical issues but I still enjoyed the show up until the last few seasons.
 
One thing about Gunsmoke that I can't get over is how similar it is to Andy Griffith Show. Both Matt Dillon and Andy are calm sheriffs (well in Gunsmoke's case marshall) that try and make the right desicions, both shows are set in a small town, and both have some comical deputy. In addition, once they got to color, both shows weren't as good.
 
I bought my dad a TNT Westerns DVD for Christmas so I've now seen Last Stand at Saber River, Conagher, Monte Walsh (Selleck version), and You Know My Name. TNT's reputation as "the best movie studio on television" still holds up.

Reviews:
  • LSASR was good, but there were too many endings; like three. Since it's ACW-related should it be counted as part of the Turnerverse (G&G, Gettysburg, Andersonville, etc.)? Forrest's role in Fort Pillow is debatable, but it's just a movie.
  • Conagher was no good. It didn't go anywhere and it ended predictably. Basically Hondo but more boring (both Louis L'Amour).
  • Monte Walsh was the best one, definitely one of the greatest Death of the West movies. I saw half the Lee Marvin version earlier last year before YT yanked it off.
  • YKMN has a dirty, authentic feel, and is entertaining all the way around. Sam Elliot made an excellent Bill Tilghman. Only problem was the guy playing Wiley Lynn totally overdid it. It was more like watching the Joker, which is fine in Batman stuff but not a Western, much less a historical, biographical one.
Overall good fun, minus Conagher.
 
James Arness in the first season of Gunsmoke compared to the last:

Image 2-6-25 at 8.01 PM.jpeg
Image 2-6-25 at 7.59 PM.jpeg


Sources:
 
James Arness in the first season of Gunsmoke compared to the last:

View attachment 538104 View attachment 538105

Sources:

Here he is in his last adventure, "Gunsmoke: One Man's Justice" which aired on CBS in February, 1994.

1738894076371.png
 
John Wayne in his first movie compared with the last:

John Wayne in the Big Trail
How John Wayne's Western Movie Career Ended With a Bang

The Big Trail (1930) ...................The Shootest (1976)

It's hard to believe the man acted for so long (46 years).

Sources:
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top