HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
We greatly underestimate the Native Americans, and we are just beginning to see the entire picture. In his book The First Frontier The History of Struggle, Savagery, and Endurance in Early America, writer Scott Weidensaul presents evidence that Portuguese fishing fleets were interacting with Native Americans for decades or longer as the fishing fleets salting facilities have been identified along the coasts of New England and Nova Scotia. He also claims that a woman's tomb found in a Viking graveyard on Greenland is that of a Native American woman, buried in a fashion reserved for that of a Viking queen, Care to speculate on how this came to be?
Obviously there was earlier contact than what our common history books claim.
The ancient Canadian Indian village of Mantle was uncovered some years ago along the northern shores of Lake Ontario;
"Occupied between roughly A.D. 1500 and 1530, the so-called Mantle site was settled by the Wendat (Huron). Excavations at the site, between 2003 and 2005, have uncovered its 98 longhouses, a palisade of three rows (a fence made of heavy wooden stakes and used for defense) and about 200,000 artifacts" Scientists estimate between 1,500 and 1,800 individuals inhabited the site, whose fields encompassed a Manhattan-size area. To clothe themselves they would have needed 7,000 deer hides annually, something that would have required hunting about 26 miles (40 km) in every direction from the site."
One of the items found is a silver axe head, a Basque axe head. How did a Basque sliver axe head make it's way to Canada nobody has an answer.

So I have a question, if the Native People or American Indian, or First Nations People, were as primitive as the "Indian" is portrayed in popular history and movies and TV, how come the Natives so quickly learned English, French, Spanish, Portuguese and dialects of other native languages?
Cheeshahteaumuck, born on Martha's Vineyard @ 1644, ever hear of him? He graduated for Harvard in 1661. Sadly he died of TB a few months later, but this is an example IMO that the Native American was as intelligent and capable as any European, given the opportunity.
They were technologically primitive at first contact but certainly not mentally inferior. Extensive trade networks existed centuries earlier with copper from the upper Great Lakes and wampum beads made from bivalves on the east coast to name a few. According to the sagas the Viking settlers in the New World came out second best in their conflicts with the indigenous peoples. Many tribes had complex political systems and were extremely successful at growing crops . Sadly many thousands were killed by European diseases. I absolutely agree with your assessment . There was also intertribal warfare and all that goes with that. They were afterall humans , like the Europeans , and experienced all the good and bad that being human encompasses.
 
As far as clothing, I tend to think in reality before trade contact Indians went naked or mostly naked in warmer weather. Hollywood for most part couldn't depict them so, so invented the prevalence of buckskin.

Why they persisted in the depiction in eras when cloth trade goods had become readily available and is seen in historical photos and sketches is just stereotyped I reckon.

See same with like early African depictions, where we know tribes went naked alot. Nudity persisted in some African and South American tribes till rather recently historically.

Leather seems to have limitations as practical clothing. It can shrink in heat or wet, I read one early pioneer account where he noted they would have to try to stretch their pants back to correct size.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of clothing, I forget if the scene was from "100 Rifles" or "Bandolero" with Raquel Welch form fitting her pants by sitting in a horse trough. Heck,it may not even been her at all, but it was some leading lady in tight pants, which I don't think were worn at all back then. Daniel Boone (Fess Parker) maybe but not the ladies.
 
As far as clothing, I tend to think in reality before trade contact Indians went naked or mostly naked in warmer weather. Hollywood for most part couldn't depict them so, so invented the prevalence of buckskin.

Why they persisted in the depiction in eras when cloth trade goods had become readily available and is seen in historical photos and sketches is just stereotyped I reckon.

See same with like early African depictions, where we know tribes went naked alot. Nudity persisted in some African and South American tribes till rather recently historically.

Leather seems to have limitations as practical clothing. It can shrink in heat or wet, I read one early pioneer account where he noted they would have to try to stretch their pants back to correct size.
I am more familiar with tribes of the Great Lakes and eastern woodlands. The earliest European accounts mention the men wearing breechclouts ( loincloths ). I would think it makes sense in those areas considering the environment and biting insects .
 
I seriously doubt complete nudity was meant in the above posts when nudity was mentioned.A few bouts with the mosquitoes and they would learn to cover up some of the "tender parts" real quick.
 
I seriously doubt complete nudity was meant in the above posts when nudity was mentioned.A few bouts with the mosquitoes and they would learn to cover up some of the "tender parts" real quick.
But when westerns started, doubt loose breechcloths or topless women, while historical, would flew in film and TV.

It is hypothesized "buck naked" originated from slaves and natives that went......well buck naked:bounce:
 
One the things that amazed me is Indian schools sometimes took before and after pictures. The differences between not being exposed to sun and elements all the time was rather dramatic.

1000000644.jpg
 
My wife asked me why the Mexican peons or villagers wore white in westerns like the Magnificent Seven. I replied that they weren't really white just undyed any color. So it was more of an "off white". Was that a good explanation?
 
My wife asked me why the Mexican peons or villagers wore white in westerns like the Magnificent Seven. I replied that they weren't really white just undyed any color. So it was more of an "off white". Was that a good explanation?
Not sure but lighter colored clothing tends to keep you cooler. It could be a Hollywood thing though.
 
I'm not sure how @Claude Bauer feels about westerns, but this theme from The Outlaw Josey Wales is right down his alley. I was playing a disc of western themes in the car last night on the way home from work when this came up. At first, I thought they'd pulled another track from Glory. Apparently, the real name for the fife tune is Old 1812.

 
I'm not sure how @Claude Bauer feels about westerns, but this theme from The Outlaw Josey Wales is right down his alley. I was playing a disc of western themes in the car last night on the way home from work when this came up. At first, I thought they'd pulled another track from Glory. Apparently, the real name for the fife tune is Old 1812.

Yes that tune is featured in Glory. I often play the soundtracks to Glory , Gettysburg and Last of the Mohicans while I paint miniatures. I also throw in a little Baroque as well.
 
They were technologically primitive at first contact but certainly not mentally inferior. Extensive trade networks existed centuries earlier with copper from the upper Great Lakes and wampum beads made from bivalves on the east coast to name a few. According to the sagas the Viking settlers in the New World came out second best in their conflicts with the indigenous peoples. Many tribes had complex political systems and were extremely successful at growing crops . Sadly many thousands were killed by European diseases. I absolutely agree with your assessment . There was also intertribal warfare and all that goes with that. They were afterall humans , like the Europeans , and experienced all the good and bad that being human encompasses.
The Cherokee were an advanced society, a lot of good it did them. It is an over looked fact of history that even after being forced to leave their traditional homeland and walk the Trail of Tears only to settle in Oklahoma (then the Indian Territory until white decided to take that land as well) they had every reason to distrust whites, so what was overlooked?
The Cherokee Trail, which connected Fort Smith, Ark to the Oregon Trail rendezvousing with the OT at Ft. Bridger, Wyoming was an joint venture undertaken by white Arkansas residents and Cherokees in Oklahoma.

 
The Cherokee were an advanced society, a lot of good it did them. It is an over looked fact of history that even after being forced to leave their traditional homeland and walk the Trail of Tears only to settle in Oklahoma (then the Indian Territory until white decided to take that land as well) they had every reason to distrust whites, so what was overlooked?
The Cherokee Trail, which connected Fort Smith, Ark to the Oregon Trail rendezvousing with the OT at Ft. Bridger, Wyoming was an joint venture undertaken by white Arkansas residents and Cherokees in Oklahoma.

The Cherokee had that common problem that many shared. They had land that others wanted and no matter what they did or how they complied their land was outright taken. Thanks Andrew Jackson. Then they were sent to "Indian Territory " that already had tribes , sometimes hostile , occupying it. The same thing happened to others. I always thought of those relocated Great Lakes tribes raised in a culture of maple sugar making , fishing , canoe building and existing in a world of forests and lakes and rivers. Then you get relocated to Indian Territory. Your whole culture must adapt and you may be fighting traditional enemies again. Luckily some , especially the Chippewa , were able to stay in their traditional homeland though on much smaller parcels of land.
 
The Cherokee had that common problem that many shared. They had land that others wanted and no matter what they did or how they complied their land was outright taken. Thanks Andrew Jackson. Then they were sent to "Indian Territory " that already had tribes , sometimes hostile , occupying it. The same thing happened to others. I always thought of those relocated Great Lakes tribes raised in a culture of maple sugar making , fishing , canoe building and existing in a world of forests and lakes and rivers. Then you get relocated to Indian Territory. Your whole culture must adapt and you may be fighting traditional enemies again. Luckily some , especially the Chippewa , were able to stay in their traditional homeland though on much smaller parcels of land.
The Shawnee shared the same fate, an eastern forest tribe sent to the plains.
 
I'm not sure how @Claude Bauer feels about westerns, but this theme from The Outlaw Josey Wales is right down his alley. I was playing a disc of western themes in the car last night on the way home from work when this came up. At first, I thought they'd pulled another track from Glory. Apparently, the real name for the fife tune is Old 1812.

Yes that tune is featured in Glory. I often play the soundtracks to Glory , Gettysburg and Last of the Mohicans while I paint miniatures. I also throw in a little Baroque as well.
I've long wanted to know what it was called.
 
About them forgotten Westerns, it's mainly a point of view to the general audience, some of the films presented here are considered in France as huge "classics", at a point that some may be on the other hand overestimated...
For example, I had waited for years to see Raoul Walsh's "Pursued" , it hadn't been hosted on TV since the 80's , no dvd was available...
I finally saw it, and was a bit disapointed.
 
I have seen several of Walsh's other movies like "the Tall Men" and another Clark Gable film "Band of Angels". I thought "the Tall Men" was pretty good but have not seen it in years.Funny how much an opinion of a western can change as we get older.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top