HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I have seen some chatter about Aussie Westerns, called "meat pie Westerns" here and just saw a very good one yesterday called Sweet Country. There is a lot of r*****t content and it is important while viewing this film to NOT see it as a metaphor for such behavior elsewhere. It is a tough film, best (opinion) seen without wife and kids, but then I don't know your wife and kids, so . . . . ......
 
"The tall men" isn't as good as it could have been...good cast like often in that time (Robert Ryan, Clark Gable, Jane Russell...), I guess the snow scenes with the Sioux attack are the best part of the movie, I'll look at it again soon.
What western wasn't ? A person would be hard pressed to name one that couldn't stand "a little improvement."
 
As far as clothing, I tend to think in reality before trade contact Indians went naked or mostly naked in warmer weather. Hollywood for most part couldn't depict them so, so invented the prevalence of buckskin.
I am pretty sure that somewhere in my home I have a book of drawings of native Americans made by the first European contact folks, but can't find it. However, on a similar but different book, in "What people wore" (another book I could find) I discovered the sentence, "In Greek and Roman costume the influence of pagan ethics and a bland climate is still apparent: thus there is considerable nakedness." I also seem to recall that the original Olympics were mostly conducted in the nude.
 
I am pretty sure that somewhere in my home I have a book of drawings of native Americans made by the first European contact folks, but can't find it. However, on a similar but different book, in "What people wore" (another book I could find) I discovered the sentence, "In Greek and Roman costume the influence of pagan ethics and a bland climate is still apparent: thus there is considerable nakedness." I also seem to recall that the original Olympics were mostly conducted in the nude.
John White made paintings of Indians in the late 1580s. They depict both men and women wearing a large breechcloth . That is all either sex wears.
 
What's the end-year on a Western? Do modern-day tales of life in the great West count?
*No Country for Old Men -- heart-poundingly intense (also with the great Tommy Lee Jones)
*Hell and High Water -- great cast, terrific story
Or the TV series Longmire?
 
What's the end-year on a Western? Do modern-day tales of life in the great West count?
*No Country for Old Men -- heart-poundingly intense (also with the great Tommy Lee Jones)
*Hell and High Water -- great cast, terrific story
Those are "Modern Westerns", including (but not limited to) The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia, Death Wish, etc...
 
I haven't seen Longmire, but I think the two films I mentioned are excellent tales of life in the modern (South)west. Every time I watch No Country for Old Men I yell at Josh Brolin to throw the beeper thingie out the window!! He never does, go figure.
 
I haven't seen Longmire, but I think the two films I mentioned are excellent tales of life in the modern (South)west. Every time I watch No Country for Old Men I yell at Josh Brolin to throw the beeper thingie out the window!! He never does, go figure.
Longmire is an interesting modern western that follows a sheriff and his staff and friends. It features a lot of indigenous actors representing mainly Crow and Cheyenne. It doesn't cover up the problems on reservations.
According to Wikipedia the Western movies cover 1849 to 1890 " but may include times before and after that period ." What we consider modern westerns would not be included in that definition .
 
Longmire is an interesting modern western that follows a sheriff and his staff and friends. It features a lot of indigenous actors representing mainly Crow and Cheyenne. It doesn't cover up the problems on reservations.
According to Wikipedia the Western movies cover 1849 to 1890 " but may include times before and after that period ." What we consider modern westerns would not be included in that definition .
The one exception is Revolution-set Drums Along the Mohawk.
tSX2kkwyivYiw9kL5sUOHsSLWXx.jpg
 
What's the end-year on a Western? Do modern-day tales of life in the great West count?
*No Country for Old Men -- heart-poundingly intense (also with the great Tommy Lee Jones)
*Hell and High Water -- great cast, terrific story
Both those films show up in the list at the wikipedia article "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_Western" So, yes. they are considered to be westerns (by some).
 
Longmire is an interesting modern western that follows a sheriff and his staff and friends. It features a lot of indigenous actors representing mainly Crow and Cheyenne. It doesn't cover up the problems on reservations.

When I was living in New Mexico Longmire was being filmed in not-too-far-away Los Vegas, NM. A friend of mine's son really wanted to be an extra or walk-on, so they took a day off from school (she was a teacher, he a student) and drove over to LV on a casting day. They turned him down but asked her to be an extra. Life. It is not always what is expected.
 
Didn't Drums Along The Mohawk take place in Pennsylvania? If so I'm not sure how they could possibly consider that a western. I'd call it an eastern myself but to each his own I guess.

John
 
Ever notice on westerns when nighttime or an "Indian night attack" is shown that you can still see the shadows. Makes you kind of think it was filmed in broad daylight and a filter was used to darken things.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top