HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I loved this scene from Open Range, a very realistic gun fight;

I did like the movie but did I count 8 or 9 shots from Costner's fanned revolver ? Also wasn't someone shot with a shotgun by Duvall and go flying several feet through the air? Other than that I do like the realism of so many shots fired that missed or wounded. The gunfights are chaotic as they should be.
 
I love how Kev just blows him away instantly!

This was always one of my favorite modern Westerns, after the remakes of 3:10 to Yuma and True Grit.

Modern Westerns are usually faster and more realistic. I still might prefer a classic like Rio Bravo, though:wink:
Definitely agree that these are all great modern westerns.
 
I did like the movie but did I count 8 or 9 shots from Costner's fanned revolver ? Also wasn't someone shot with a shotgun by Duvall and go flying several feet through the air? Other than that I do like the realism of so many shots fired that missed or wounded. The gunfights are chaotic as they should be.
Witness twenty shots from two guns:
 
I love how Kev just blows him away instantly!

This was always one of my favorite modern Westerns, after the remakes of 3:10 to Yuma and True Grit.

Modern Westerns are usually faster and more realistic. I still might prefer a classic like Rio Bravo, though:wink:
I think it would be cool to so a modern in black and white,
 
Another I'm not crazy about is Forsaken from 2015. It was meant to be soley a vehicle for the two Sutherlands, Donald and Keifer. Donald is the most natural actor I know of, but he could not fix this. It essentially copies Shane, The Shootist, and Unforgiven and makes a big cliched soup. Let's see: evil landgrabber; gunslinger dealing with the reprecussions of his past; dummy who tries to prove he's faster; awkward married-woman relationship; father-son conflict; a faux version of Val Kilmer's Doc Holiday; guy kills everyone and rides away. It even has a stand-in for Bruce Dern:

fake dern.jpg

Skip this one.
 
Another I'm not crazy about is Forsaken from 2015. It was meant to be soley a vehicle for the two Sutherlands, Donald and Keifer. Donald is the most natural actor I know of, but he could not fix this. It essentially copies Shane, The Shootist, and Unforgiven and makes a big cliched soup. Let's see: evil landgrabber; gunslinger dealing with the reprecussions of his past; dummy who tries to prove he's faster; awkward married-woman relationship; father-son conflict; a faux version of Val Kilmer's Doc Holiday; guy kills everyone and rides away. It even has a stand-in for Bruce Dern:

View attachment 496349
Skip this one.
I caught the last 20 minutes of it and pretty much figured out the plot from that. Donald has had a very long career.
 
I've never shot a guy or witnessed one being shot but I seriously have my doubts about someone flying through the air or doing a backflip when getting hit with a large caliber.Granted there would more than likely be some sort of "sledge hammer" effect from a shotgun or even a rifle or maybe even a large caliber handgun but I would bet their feet never leave the ground until they topple over. As far as more than 6 shots from an "six-shooter", I am at a loss to explain why a director would insult someone's intelligence that way.
 
I've never shot a guy or witnessed one being shot but I seriously have my doubts about someone flying through the air or doing a backflip when getting hit with a large caliber.Granted there would more than likely be some sort of "sledge hammer" effect from a shotgun or even a rifle or maybe even a large caliber handgun but I would bet their feet never leave the ground until they topple over. As far as more than 6 shots from an "six-shooter", I am at a loss to explain why a director would insult someone's intelligence that way.
Those of us who have hunted deer can say that a large living creature doesn't fly back several feet when shot. If shot properly it may simply drop immediately. A large buck can weigh as much as an adult human. Too much Hollywood in some gunfights. I watch a British detective series called Midsomer Murders. The writers have no clue about firearms or ballistics and some of the murders are very farfetched when done with a firearm. It really doesn't seem to me that it would be that hard to get it right.
 
Speaking of directors ever since some "student directors" saw Howard Hawks do that kinetic energy /flip thing with John Wayne and George Plimpton back in 1970 (Rio Lobo) they seem to think it's the norm. Sort of like "If it's good enough for Hawks , it good enough for me and simply must be written into the script".I don't recall that flying or flipping thing in westerns pre-1970 Rio Lobo.Has anyone else witnessed it earlier?
 
Last edited:
I find claims to realism to Hollywood gunfights, whether old or new curious.

Majority of shots in movies are fatal........take Northfield gunfight in 1876. Clell Miller is killed with a fatal shot, only after having took two shotgun blasts previously, of the three Youngers, Cole was hit 11 times, Jim 5, and Bob 4 and all 3 survived.

In historical accounts, it seems not unusual to it took multiple shots to kill, if they killed them at all.

Emmitt Dalton took multiple shots and survived, as well Broadwell took multiple shots and rode two miles before dying. I find the typical one shot/hit and bad guy is done in movies rather suspect.

Will say as far as movies, Long Riders did depict them receiving/surviving multiple wounds.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of directors ever since some "student director" saw Howard Hawks do that kinetic energy /flip thing with John Wayne and George Plimpton back in 1970 (Rio Lobo) they seem to think it's the norm. Sort of like "If it's good enough for Hawks , it good enough for me and simply must be written into the script".I don't recall that flying or flipping thing in westerns pre-1970 Rio Lobo.Has anyone else witnessed it earlier?
Good point ! I don't recall that in any older westerns.
 
I did like the movie but did I count 8 or 9 shots from Costner's fanned revolver ? Also wasn't someone shot with a shotgun by Duvall and go flying several feet through the air? Other than that I do like the realism of so many shots fired that missed or wounded. The gunfights are chaotic as they should be.
Open Range is top five in my book. And best gunfight of them all.

So I was inclined to offer some defense of the shotgun scene….. maybe he fired both barrels….. maybe some load considerably heavier than birdshot.

Blah…blah … blah. No excuse for the ridiculous "blown thru the air for a good six feet". To add insult- appears Costner shoots him thru a closed barn door.

Still a great film. But no pardons for that gaffe.
 
If you want to see a ridiculous "blown thru the air"scene watch Gene Hackman at the end of "The Quick and the Dead." He not only gets knocked backwards but does a complete flip and then sees the sun shining through the bullet hole in his chest. A science fiction writer would be hard pressed to come up with something to match that ridiculous scene.
 
That "flag-in-the-barrel" is bound to mean something like breaking a sword in half or tearing off rank insignias. It's got me scratching my head.
Yes that doesn't make sense . It would be a great dishonor to lose a flag or guidon much less shoving one down a cannon barrel.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top