Saphroneth
Colonel
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2017
What nonsense. The only Florida units at Stones River were in Preston's Brigade, and:The Florida Brigade were issued a couple of wagon loads of rejects. Many of the men had to carry the hammer in their pockets. Because there weren't enough bits & pieces to put together a musket for every man, second ranks were told to cut sticks & pick up fallen muskets during their attack on the Round Forrest. The unit took 80% casualties, no M.I.A.'s.
Preston's Brigade as a whole suffered 8 1/3 % casualties on the 31st, followed by a more swingeing 19 1/3 % casualties on the 1st. Out of their total casualties, there were:
KIA 4+54 (58)
WIA 28+356 (384)
MIA 4+93 (97)
So 18% of the casualties suffered by Preston's Bde were MIA.
But we can go further.
This is the tabular statement of loss. The 4th Florida (with smoothbores) suffered 34 killed, 129 wounded and 31 missing, while the 1st/3rd Florida (with Enfields) suffered 7 killed, 88 wounded and 43 missing.
And the 4th Florida took 458 into action, suffering 194 casualties of any kind over two days - about 42% for both days combined. Swingeing, but not 80% casualties and not "no MIA".
