Repeaters

Except Q3 of 1863 is when Lincoln took some interest in the weapon and I think units in the Cumberland Army had success when armed with Spencers. It took some extra money some additional well equipped shops in New England to increase production. My recollection is that originally Spencers were produced in a piano factory.
In which case that would very much be the US going against their normal procurement system! Normally the US handled procurement by letting out contracts, rather than paying for weapons in advance; companies with a contract could borrow against future profits, as I understand it, which could give them capital, but if the Union government in 1861 had paid for weapons in advance then it would have paid over ten million dollars in the first year of the war for rifles that were never delivered - and that (ca. 650,000 unfulfilled contracts) is just the historical total, not the total that could have been expected if rifles were effectively paid for in advance.

(Witness as one example the Marsh, a BL conversion for the Springfield. 25,000 ordered, 0 delivered - that would have made the inventor a cool half million dollars if paid for in advance...)


So yeah, the US could have made more repeaters if they'd completely gone against their historical mode of production. They also could have made a lot more breechloaders if they'd built a factory to manufacture the Dreyse under license two decades ago. Countries generally don't go against their structural methods on a design without really good reason.
 
In which case that would very much be the US going against their normal procurement system! Normally the US handled procurement by letting out contracts, rather than paying for weapons in advance; companies with a contract could borrow against future profits, as I understand it, which could give them capital, but if the Union government in 1861 had paid for weapons in advance then it would have paid over ten million dollars in the first year of the war for rifles that were never delivered - and that (ca. 650,000 unfulfilled contracts) is just the historical total, not the total that could have been expected if rifles were effectively paid for in advance.

(Witness as one example the Marsh, a BL conversion for the Springfield. 25,000 ordered, 0 delivered - that would have made the inventor a cool half million dollars if paid for in advance...)


So yeah, the US could have made more repeaters if they'd completely gone against their historical mode of production. They also could have made a lot more breechloaders if they'd built a factory to manufacture the Dreyse under license two decades ago. Countries generally don't go against their structural methods on a design without really good reason.
I think there were investors in Boston that helped in increase production. As you say, the US government did not pay in advance, and often paid with warrants that were sold at a discount to investors.
 
In which case that would very much be the US going against their normal procurement system! Normally the US handled procurement by letting out contracts, rather than paying for weapons in advance; companies with a contract could borrow against future profits, as I understand it, which could give them capital, but if the Union government in 1861 had paid for weapons in advance then it would have paid over ten million dollars in the first year of the war for rifles that were never delivered - and that (ca. 650,000 unfulfilled contracts) is just the historical total, not the total that could have been expected if rifles were effectively paid for in advance.

(Witness as one example the Marsh, a BL conversion for the Springfield. 25,000 ordered, 0 delivered - that would have made the inventor a cool half million dollars if paid for in advance...)


So yeah, the US could have made more repeaters if they'd completely gone against their historical mode of production. They also could have made a lot more breechloaders if they'd built a factory to manufacture the Dreyse under license two decades ago. Countries generally don't go against their structural methods on a design without really good reason.
They were a brief episode in the development of military rifles for reasons that could be better explained by an expert on the subject.
 
They were a brief episode in the development of military rifles for reasons that could be better explained by an expert on the subject.
That takes all the fun out of this site. BTW - there are some folk who can explain things far better than any expert. They see things from a completely different angle - as this thread has shown.
Remember Barnes Wallis's comment when 'the experts' said his bouncing bomb would not work - " ... 'ex' is a has-been; 'spert' is a drip under pressure."

BTW - I remember the 'upgrade' from SLR (L1A1) and SMG (L2A3) to SA-80 (L85). I would hardly call it 'beneficial' or 'revolutionary'.
 
They were a brief episode in the development of military rifles for reasons that could be better explained by an expert on the subject.
You mean repeaters? My understanding (based on the British trials which compared them to full power breechloaders) is that a full power breechloader fires just as rapidly (faster than the Spencer, actually) and that the more complex mechanism of the repeater can impair reliability, while of course they have lower power.

When you get magazine rifles they tend to develop out of full power single shot breechloaders - and given the conditions of convergence in the 1850s-1870s, the fact nobody adopted a repeater as their primary military arm suggests the tradeoffs were considered unacceptable then.
 
You mean repeaters? My understanding (based on the British trials which compared them to full power breechloaders) is that a full power breechloader fires just as rapidly (faster than the Spencer, actually) and that the more complex mechanism of the repeater can impair reliability, while of course they have lower power.

When you get magazine rifles they tend to develop out of full power single shot breechloaders - and given the conditions of convergence in the 1850s-1870s, the fact nobody adopted a repeater as their primary military arm suggests the tradeoffs were considered unacceptable then.
it was always a matter of needs must. The BIG upset was the sudden introduction of a smaller caliber (8mm, 30cal) and smokeless powder round introduced by the French in 1886 and the Lebel with it's 8-round tube magazine with no forewarning or publishing of trials.

Mannlicher took 2 years to change its 'old tech' M1886 (11mm 5-round mag) - introduced just before the Lebel - to the M1888 - the same design but for 8mm. Many others were replaced by new designs, like the Germans who had already upgraded the Mauser M1871 (11mm) to an 8-round tube magazine (M1871/84) and adopted the M1888, a committee designed 8mm 5-rd box mag. It was about the same time, 1888, that the Lee-Medford was introduced into British service as a 303, BP, bolt-action with an 8-round box mag.(later upgraded to a .303 smokeless round and an, unaltered, 10-round mag). *Most of the early magazine rifles had a cut-off to enable single round loading.
The USA was still using the 50cal Springfield Trapdoor in 1886. The 'new' weapons emerged in 1892 as the Army's 30-40 M1892 Krag - a Norwegian design - and the Navy's 6mm M1895 Lee (not the same action as the Lee-Enfield). THAT's how long it takes.

*The old SMLE (1903) still retained it but it was removed around 1916 (MkIII*) to simplify manufacture, however, it was reintroduced after the war. The replacement No4 rifle (1943) never had one)
 
You mean repeaters? My understanding (based on the British trials which compared them to full power breechloaders) is that a full power breechloader fires just as rapidly (faster than the Spencer, actually) and that the more complex mechanism of the repeater can impair reliability, while of course they have lower power.
As the Brits found out with the Martini-Henry (c 20 rounds per minute), when you use rapid fire, the barrel gets VERY hot and makes the hold and thus aiming difficult - especially if you are using powerful field ammunition designed to travel some distance. So much so, that the Martini carbines used less powerful rounds to reduce recoil as well as overheating, although they were safe with standard ammo.
 
BTW - I remember the 'upgrade' from SLR (L1A1) and SMG (L2A3) to SA-80 (L85). I would hardly call it 'beneficial' or 'revolutionary'.

Yet the SA-80 system was a much better weapons system, more suited to combat in Europe. Simply doubling the ammunition carried alone was a huge factor, and the SUSAT increased the hitting rate so much that the APWT standards needed to be revived upwards. Yes, the weapon had some issues, especially before the magazine catch got a shroud. The major one was the change in cartridge from the original U.S. to the more poweful Belgian NATO standard 5.56 altered the extraction mechanics such that about 1% of the time the ejected cartridge case bounced back in and caused a stoppage. We all know this took about 2 seconds to clear (pull out the case and forward assist) but the SLR didn't do that...

The major problem we had was that no-one knew how to employ the LSW. It was treated as a "long silly rifle" rather than the capable section weapon that it was. It was meant to be employed like the old LMG (Bren) with a two man team (with 12 magazines each), but it wasn't, and a section with two properly employed LSW's was far more effective than one with a GPMG, but with less daka...

I will tell you that both at CIC and Brecon they didn't teach the correct use of the LSW as laid out in the pam.
 
Yet the SA-80 system was a much better weapons system, more suited to combat in Europe. Simply doubling the ammunition carried alone was a huge factor, and the SUSAT increased the hitting rate so much that the APWT standards needed to be revived upwards. Yes, the weapon had some issues, especially before the magazine catch got a shroud. The major one was the change in cartridge from the original U.S. to the more poweful Belgian NATO standard 5.56 altered the extraction mechanics such that about 1% of the time the ejected cartridge case bounced back in and caused a stoppage. We all know this took about 2 seconds to clear (pull out the case and forward assist) but the SLR didn't do that...

The major problem we had was that no-one knew how to employ the LSW. It was treated as a "long silly rifle" rather than the capable section weapon that it was. It was meant to be employed like the old LMG (Bren) with a two man team (with 12 magazines each), but it wasn't, and a section with two properly employed LSW's was far more effective than one with a GPMG, but with less daka...

I will tell you that both at CIC and Brecon they didn't teach the correct use of the LSW as laid out in the pam.
Having used the rifles mentioned, it was only issued with iron sights to those who had been armed with SMG. Most of the 'benefits' were associated with the ammunition. Although nicely balanced for shooting, and pleasant to shoot on the range (apart from the fact the breech was next to your ear), it was a nightmare on a battle range and in the field - still is. It handles appaulingly, requiring a sling at all times and you could not 'play' it like the SLR and, of course, only shoot it right-handed. It was never adopted by 'special services' for that reason. It was developed from a suspect system (AR-180) and for use by soldiers in APCs by some folk who did not think like real soldiers, but was adopted throughout the armed forces. When do British sailors or marines travel in an APC?

There was not that problem with the Civil War repeaters - but there were plenty of others, many based on the ammunition and supply.
 
There is a consistent "fault-finding" with new weapons, even when the weapon is absolutely an improvement. Take the Armstrong guns, which were a huge leap in effective firepower, demolishing fortifications at unheard of ranges. The breech mechanism was more complicated than a muzzloader, and there were initially minor issues with the vent pieces (solved with a few years of adoption by improved materials). However, this was a worthwhile trade-off for a massive increase in effective battle range and effect.

With ACW era repeaters, there's a question about were they actually worth it. Whilst at close range they certainly did have a greater effect on target, the trade-off was an anemic bullet not much better than a pistol round and a lack of reliability. When breechloading rifles like the Snider and Trapdoor became available, the repeaters advantages disappeared, because their rate-of-fire was not greater than these weapons. Hence it was a "no-brainer" to abandon them in the late 1860's as obselescent. With the first full power bolt-action rifle (the Lebel) it had the same problem, because rounds were loaded individually.

Oddly, the US Navy's Model 1885 Remington-Lee rifle really pointed the way forward, with detachable box magazines...
 
There is a consistent "fault-finding" with new weapons, even when the weapon is absolutely an improvement. Take the Armstrong guns, which were a huge leap in effective firepower, demolishing fortifications at unheard of ranges. The breech mechanism was more complicated than a muzzloader, and there were initially minor issues with the vent pieces (solved with a few years of adoption by improved materials). However, this was a worthwhile trade-off for a massive increase in effective battle range and effect.

With ACW era repeaters, there's a question about were they actually worth it. Whilst at close range they certainly did have a greater effect on target, the trade-off was an anemic bullet not much better than a pistol round and a lack of reliability. When breechloading rifles like the Snider and Trapdoor became available, the repeaters advantages disappeared, because their rate-of-fire was not greater than these weapons. Hence it was a "no-brainer" to abandon them in the late 1860's as obselescent. With the first full power bolt-action rifle (the Lebel) it had the same problem, because rounds were loaded individually.

Oddly, the US Navy's Model 1885 Remington-Lee rifle really pointed the way forward, with detachable box magazines...
I keep seeing this commentary from you... have you ever managed to actually fire one of the weapons you are criticizing, handle one? Any period arm for that matter? There is a very real difference between reading something in a book or website and actually using it. A big difference between the range and the field.
 
I keep seeing this commentary from you... have you ever managed to actually fire one of the weapons you are criticizing, handle one? Any period arm for that matter? There is a very real difference between reading something in a book or website and actually using it. A big difference between the range and the field.

Indeed, it is the same Porky Pies every time.
 
Last edited:
You mean repeaters? My understanding (based on the British trials which compared them to full power breechloaders) is that a full power breechloader fires just as rapidly (faster than the Spencer, actually) and that the more complex mechanism of the repeater can impair reliability, while of course they have lower power.

When you get magazine rifles they tend to develop out of full power single shot breechloaders - and given the conditions of convergence in the 1850s-1870s, the fact nobody adopted a repeater as their primary military arm suggests the tradeoffs were considered unacceptable then.
Precisely. The adoption of center fire rounds and the much stronger barrel provided by a bolt action rifle extended range.
 
The 89 Enrolled Missouri Militia regiments:
Standard 1,000 man regiments (unlikely): 890,000 muskets
500 man regiments (more likely): 445,000 muskets
250 man regiments (probably more than a bit small): 222,500 muskets
Its only one state and its still at least several hundreds of thousands of muskets, which is precisely what I wrote.
I'm not sure if you noticed this, but for 89 enrolled regiments at 1,000 men per regiment to use 890,000 muskets they would have to be issued ten muskets each.

If they were issued at one musket each then 1,000 men per regiment is 89,000 muskets - and the 500 men per regiment you consider is more likely is 44,500.

Not "hundreds of thousands".
 
I'm not sure if you noticed this, but for 89 enrolled regiments at 1,000 men per regiment to use 890,000 muskets they would have to be issued ten muskets each.

If they were issued at one musket each then 1,000 men per regiment is 89,000 muskets - and the 500 men per regiment you consider is more likely is 44,500.

Not "hundreds of thousands".
I apprciate the effort but I think your math might be off. Regardless I understand your point and I think it is somewhat legitimate. IMO you should do a little more research ....keep on with education and you will be fine...Best regards
 
I apprciate the effort but I think your math might be off. Regardless I understand your point and I think it is somewhat legitimate. IMO you should do a little more research ....keep on with education and you will be fine...Best regards
...excuse me? In what way have I made a maths error here?
 
Yup. my math was off by a decimal place. I hate it when I'm dyslexic. However, 89k, 44.5K, or 22.25K in only one state is a substantial number of weapons. The other Northern states also built armed militias which were largely armed with 3rd and 4th class weapons.
It's a pretty big assumption that they were all armed with weapons provided by the Federal government since the opening of the war, though - remember, the issue is that 1.1 million weapons surplus to those required by the troops in the field had been either possessed by the Federal Government at the opening of the war or purchased since, as of 30 June 1864.

If the argument is that the overwhelming number of those were not breakages or losses, then they all must have gone somewhere - and if an under-threat state like Missouri accounts for a couple of tens of thousands of them, that leaves 95% or so of them unaccounted for.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top