POW Myth?

My Great Grandfather was captured at Dandridge TN and went as a POW to Castle Thunder to Belle Isle to Andersonville to Savannah and then to Millen, before being exchanged in Nov 1864 from Savannah, I think in an "invalid prisoner" exchange.
After arrival at Andersonville he suffered from typhoid pneumonia and was nursed back to health by a friend from his cavalry troop, George Wall. Because he had some knowledge of pharmaceuticals from apprenticing with chemist/pharmacists in Philadelphia, he was assigned to work in the gangrene ward at Andersonville. Soon after he moved out from the general population to work on that ward, George Wall was carried out dead.

"After the cold of Belle Island and the confinement of the life there, the sun at Andersonville brought on my own misfortune. As we stood up in line one morning to be divided into squads I fell over on my face in a faint, and then and there laid down with the commencement of typhoid pneumonia. It seemed like a billet for the other world under the existing conditions – no hospital, no shelter, no food, no medicine, on the ground, inclement March and April ahead. Could conditions be more adverse?...

...I can recall no special suffering or distress from my own illness, except the misery of it all and the knowledge that I saw my comrade thought I was to be the first to respond to the hereafter call. I was spared. After three months I commenced to mend and get about. Having some knowledge of medicine, I had charge, with another prisoner, of some of the gangrene patients – not a very healthful occupation under the circumstances. George Wall had me transferred and he remained inside. I had not been out long – about July 1st​ – when poor George was carried out a corpse, having died away from me. It saddened my life, as we had been close "bunkies" ever since our capture in December – slept together, shared our small rations, comforted and cheered each other as best we could. He nursed me from March 10th​, for three months, like a mother, cooking what little I required and nestling close to me in the long, cold nights, to keep me warm."

After he was exchanged, he was at Camp Comfort in Parole (Annapolis), MD but soon after arrival was given leave to return home to Philadelphia for about a month. He then returned to Annapolis until mustered out, I believe. On his return to Philadelphia, he may have continued to work for the pharmacists Bullock & Crenshaw as a clerk, then attended law school in 1867, passing the bar in 1869, and continued at Bullock & Crenshaw as an accountant and lawyer at least until 1881. When the pharmacists Smith & Kline were incorporated in 1888, he was listed as the Secretary of the Board. He continued in that role when, after an acquisition, it became Smith, Kline & French in 1891 (we now know it as the company Glaxo Smith Kline or GSK). He died in 1904. Based on letters with his wife and children, as well as newspaper articles, it appears he had medical issues throughout his life and often traveled to places that were supposed to be good for his health, both in the US and Europe. He died at home after a regular day of work and his Certificate of Death listed cause as myocarditis with a contributing factor of acute gastritis. He was 62. His wife, 6 years younger, lived till 1923, dying at the age of 74.
I did a quick search of a number different databases and couldn't find a record of your great grandfather at Andersonville or Millen. That doesn't mean he wasn't there but that I haven't found any documentation for him.
 
Why is it assumed that POWs who survived died shortly after they returned home? I am looking for honest opinions NOT comments about which side treated their prisoners worst. I would also appreciate citations to articles or books that address this issue.

Thanks.
Interesting topic. I don't have any "citations or books" I can quote - all I can go by are the personal experiences of my great-grandfather, but I do have to say I think the "survival of the fittest" theory may seem to make the most sense. I have always wondered how Great-granddad managed to survive to the ripe old age of 84 - after having previously been wounded and captured at the age of 38 in battle on October 7, 1863. Maybe the fact that he had previously fought in the Seminole Indian Wars had something to do with it? During those earlier years he more than likely had been exposed to bad sanitary conditions and various diseases as well, which may have contributed to his future ability to survive the abysmal conditions of a northern prison - or maybe he was just lucky - who knows?

His pension application papers state that during a cavalry battle his head was "fractured by a piece of shell" and that he also suffered a "gunshot wound to the neck/jaw". After spending 5 weeks in Military Prison in Louisville, he was sent on to Camp Morton, Indiana as a POW where, from everything I've read about the place, he endured some pretty poor conditions until the end of Feb. 1865 when he was finally among a group of prisoners chosen to be released for exchange back to the south. Apparently the Union powers-that-be went through the prison and selected a few men to be released who they felt were too old or decrepit to do them any further harm (Ggrandpa ended up getting the last laugh, tho - after somehow walking all the way back home to Alabama, he opted to take up arms once again for the south, fighting in one of the very last battles of the civil war at Spanish Fort).

Anyway, although I know that he must have suffered at least some physical after-effects relating from his debilitating POW experience, apparently it didn't damage Great granddad too badly as he went on after that to father THIRTEEN children - my grandmother being number 10 of the lot (she was born when he was 70 yrs. old - and he had FOUR more children after her - his last being born in 1901!!!). I guess any ill-effects he may have suffered in prison only served to strengthen him and build up his stamina for later in life in life🤗. A doctor stated on his 1899 pension application that all that was wrong with him was that he suffered from "General debility with a slight pulmonary development". I guess "general debility" could mean pretty much anything? And I suppose a pulmonary condition *could* be blamed on his prison years - but I suspect it more than likely had something to do with smoking or the like. Following the war years he attempted to make his living as a farmer - not very successfully tho - times were very hard in south Alabama during those years, according to my grandmother.

Regardless, somehow the family managed to survive and continue. Other than two kids dying young in a tragic accidents, all of his children lived fairly long lives ranging from 49-89 years. Ironically, after all he had been thru and survived, Great Granddad finally went to meet his maker at the ripe old age of 84 in 1908 - after succumbing from the consequences of an infected big toe, of all things!
 
I've never heard of this assumption that POWs died shortly after returning home. An individual's death is much more complex. Several factors, such as the prison conditions before release, the location of the prison versus the individual's home, the health condition at the time of release, the date when the individual was released, and more, would have to be considered with any assumption. On top of this material, the complete health history of the person's family would have to be analyzed. The current and previous living conditions and locations would also play a factor. Prior diseases with dates and any complications would need further research. Mental health would also play a primary role in the person's physical health. My point is that so many different components would/could/do lead to a person's death. I've researched many POWs transported to various hospitals in poor condition, where they later died. During my studies, I found that most POWs released in fair to good condition survived many years. What I would like to know pertains to the POWs but in a slightly different manner. I want to know the exact numbers of confederate POWs released versus union POWs released. If anyone has access to this information or knows a good reliable source, please let me know.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top