{⋆★⋆} MG Lovell, Mansfield

Mansfield Lovell

:CSA1stNat:
Lovell.jpg


Born: October 20, 1822

Birthplace: Washington, D.C.

Father: Surgeon General Joseph Lovell 1788 – 1836
(Buried: Congressional Cemetery, Washington, D.C.)​

Mother: Margaret Eliza Mansfield 1788 – 1836
(Buried: Congressional Cemetery, Washington, D.C.)​

Wife: Emily Maria Plympton 1825 – 1890
(Buried: Woodlawn Cemetery, Bronx, New York)​

Children:

Joseph M. Lovell 1847 – 1897​
Mansfield Lovell Jr. 1854 – 1918​
(Buried: Cypress Lawn Memorial Cemetery, Colma, California)​
Cornelia L. Lovell 1857 -​
Joseph Ruggles Lovell 1852 -​

Education:

1842: Graduated from West Point Military Academy – (9th in class)​

Occupation before War:

1842 – 1847: 2nd Lt. United States Army, 4th Artillery​
1847 – 1854: 1st Lt. United States Army, 4th Artillery​
1854: Resigned from United States Army on September 18th
Served in the Expedition of General John A. Quitman to Cuba​
1854 – 1858: Merchant in New York City, New York​
1858: New York City Superintendent of Street Improvements​
1858 – 1861: Deputy Street Commissioner for New York City, New York​
1859 – 1861: Captain in New York State Militia​

Civil War Career:

1861 – 1865: Major General in the Confederate States Army​
1861 – 1863: Confederate Commander of New Orleans, Louisiana​
1863: Found innocent of any charges by a board​

Occupation after War:

1866 – 1867: Rice Plantation Farmer in Savannah, Georgia​
1868 – 1884: Civil Engineer & Surveyor in New York City, New York​

Died: June 1, 1884

Place of Death: New York City, New York

Age at time of Death: 61 years old

Burial Place: Woodlawn Cemetery, Bronx, New York
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It was Lovell who relieved General Twiggs from command in Texas. His first major assignment was the defense of New Orleans, but he was left with a insufficient force. Most of his units were sent to Cornith for the buildup prior to Shiloh. This left him with a small force of green troops. But he was blamed when yhe city fell in April of 1862. A court of inquiry did absolve him of blame the following year. Until found innocent he led a division at Corinth and temporarily a Corps at Vicksburg. He was then relieved of duty to await orders until March 1865 when he was ordered to join Joseph Johnston in North Carolina. But Johnston surrendered before Lovell could be assigned a command.
 
Mansfield Lovell:
:CSA1stNat:
Born: October 20, 1822View attachment 378378
Birthplace: District of Columbia
Father: Surgeon General Joseph Lovell 1788 – 1836
(Buried: Congressional Cemetery Washington D.C.)
Mother: Margaret Eliza Mansfield 1788 – 1836
(Buried: Congressional Cemetery Washington D.C.)
Wife: Emily Maria Plympton 1825 – 1890
(Buried: Woodlawn Cemetery Bronx New York)
Children:
Joseph M. Lovell 1847 – 1897
Mansfield Lovell Jr. 1854 – 1918
(Buried: Cypress Lawn Memorial Cemetery Colma California)
Cornelia L. Lovell 1857 -
Joseph Ruggles Lovell 1852 -

Education:
1842: Graduated from West Point Military Academy – (9th​ in class)

Occupation before War:
1842 – 1847: 2nd​ Lt. United States Army 4th​ Artillery
1847 – 1854: 1st​ Lt. United States Army 4th​ Artillery
1854: Resigned from United States Army on September 18th​
Served in the Expedition of General John A. Quitman to Cuba
1854 – 1858: Merchant in New York City New York
1858: New York City Superintendent of Street Improvements
1858 – 1861: Deputy Street Commissioner for New York City N.Y.
1859 – 1861: Captain in New York State Militia

Civil War Career:
1861 – 1865: Major General in the Confederate States Army
1861 – 1863: Confederate Commander of New Orleans Louisiana
1863: Found innocent of any charges by a board

Occupation after War:
1866 – 1867: Rice Plantation Farmer in Savannah Georgia
1868 – 1884: Civil Engineer & Surveyor in New York City New York


Died:
June 1, 1884
Place of Death: New York City New York
Age at time of Death: 61 years old
Burial Place: Woodlawn Cemetery Bronx New York
According to Chastel in Decision in the West, Joe Johnston intially wanted Lovell as a Corps commander to command 2nd Corps, given to Hood; then to command the Third Corps after Polk's death, before that was given to A. P. Stewart.
Not sure exactly why he considered him for such a high position, other than his relative rank and the fact he wasn't doing much at that time.
 
Has there ever been a reason given as to why he was sidelined for much of the war? I wonder if the fact that he was a New Yorker played a role in it.

Ryan
I believe it was because he was still blamed for his loss at New Orleans, in addition to his northern birth.
I mean, he was exonerated for it, but that doesn't mean people just forgot it.
 
4/30/62 Tangipahoa, La-Lovell to Van Dorn-[just five days after New Orleans had fallen, he informed Major Gen Van Dorn of his intention to arm & occupy Vicksburg.]
Just returned from New Orleans. The men at forts refused to hold out longer, & Duncan had to surrender. The enemy will therefore occupy the city under his guns. All seems quiet & orderly, & I think there will be no trouble for citizens & families. The only fear is a scarcity of provisions. I shall occupy Vicksburg, & support Beauregard with all the men I can organize & arm.

6/25/62 Jackson, MS-Lovell to A Gen Cooper-I have been relieved by Van Dorn. Have no orders.-Would prefer to be sent to the field of immediate action. Will I be allowed a change of position to put an end to unfounded popular clamors?
After my supersession I repaired to Richmond, with Gen Van Dorn's permission, & urged the convening of the Court of Inquiry. Interview with the President, on 7/18

9/8/62 Van Dorn's Spec Orders Dist of Miss, Jackson-
I. Maj Gen M. Lovell having reported for duty with this army is assigned to the command of a Div composed of the Bgde of Brig Gen J. B. Villepigue & other Bgdes to be organized. [At this time, he is probably thinking of one or more POW Bgdes for Lovell]

II. Gen Rust having reported for duty in this command will report to Maj Gen J. C. Breckinridge.

9/20/62 Jackson- Lovell to wife- I saw the pieces in the paper that you sent me-the news about Smith & Bragg. If the latter succeeds in his present campaign it will all be overlooked; if not they will haunt him to death.

There seems to be little doubt that the step I am taking in going with Van Dorn is just the thing-I could not have arranged it better if I had been allowed to fix it for myself. [When Lovell was relieved in Dec 62, there was mention that Van Dorn had assigned him to duty without going thru the War Dept]

Every one of my friends seems to think I have done a first rate thing in getting into position in this manner without any help from the War Dept

Van Dorn & Price will join forces to which will be added 8-10,000 returned prisoners in a short time, giving us as large an army as Johnston & Beauregard had at Shiloh of which I shall be the second officer in rank & my relations with Van Dorn will be just what you indicated in your letter before last.

12/10/62 Gen Lovell wrote from Jackson, to the A.G. in Richmond:* * Gen Lovell's letter-book, p. 134.​ "Arriving in Grenada in charge of the rearguard of our army on a long & tedious retreat, I found myself relieved from the command of my Corps, because I had not been assigned to duty here by the War Dept. This is a very mortifying result to me, Gen, after the severe labors of the last three months. Under the orders of Gen Van Dorn I had organized, clothed, equipped, & provided as fine a Corps as any in the army, consisting of 13,000 present at Abbeville & 1,500 at Port Hudson. They had been with me in battle & on the march, & I have no hesitation in saying that officers & men had become attached to me, & placed entire confidence in me as a cdr. I beg leave to say, with deference, that I do not see the difference between my assignment to duty here, & that of Gen Van Dorn. I was in command of the Dept & was superseded by him, & he in turn by Gen Pemberton, & both have remained here on duty, under the same conditions. When in Richmond I requested the President to relieve me from duty in this Dept, & he replied that 'he did not see why I could not serve under Gen Van Dorn.'

I asked Gen Bragg then in command of this section of the country for assignment under him, & he telegraphed me, that probably Gen Van Dorn could give me a position. The Court of Inquiry having been postponed until further orders, he gave me a command, & I can refer to his written reports to show that I have done my duty. With regard to my conduct at Corinth, on the retreat thence to Holly Springs, & from there to Grenada, I am willing to be judged by the officers & soldiers of my command. Their opinion, as universally expressed, is one of entire satisfaction & confidence; & much regret was manifested by them at my removal. I hope that the President will see fit to place me again on active duty, as I greatly dislike remaining idle while there is so much to be done."

6/23/63 Jackson, J Johnston to AG Cooper-desires for Lovell to be assigned to his Dept

6/28/63 Jackson, Gen Johnston to Gen Cooper-If as I am informed the court …Has reported favorably to Gen Lovell, I request that he be assigned to duty in this Dept

-Jan 64 Gen Jo Johnston requested Lovell as Corps cdr
--Johnston had asked for Chase Whiting or Lovell to command Breckenridge's old Corps. Davis refused & gave him Hood instead
-served as a volunteer on Gen Joseph E. Johnston's staff that summer; apparently in response to a further request

1/16/64 Dalton, Johnston to Gen Cooper-Judging from the published reports of the court of inquiry in Maj-Gen Lovell's case that he is now available for duty, I respectfully renew my application for his assignment to my command.

I wish to divide this army into three parts. It is now composed of two Corps, one of four Div's under Lt-Gen Hardee, the other of three under Maj-Gen Hindman. I propose to have three Corps, one of three Div's under Lt-Gen Hardee, another of two under Maj-Gen Lovell, & the third of two under Maj-Gen Hindman. This organization will be more convenient in every respect than the present, & the size of the Corps more appropriate to the rank of their cdrs, & the army could be handled more readily & maneuvered more rapidly. I beg leave to suggest to the War Dept that in this difficult & responsible command I have not had such advantages as my predecessor, who assisted in the nomination of many of the principal officers of his army. It is important to me to have near me some officers of high rank whose military qualities I know, as I feel I do those of Maj-Gen Lovell. I therefore respectfully urge my claim to his assistance.

The reason for Johnston's support of Lovell is very much the same as the reason for Johnston's support of G.W. Smith early in the war. Johnston, Smith & Lovell were, with McClellan, very close pre-war friends & Johnston was someone who always looked out for his friends. From a web forum

1/27/64 Richmond, Lovell to Gen Cooper-Learning from Gen Johnston cdg Army of Tenn that he has applied for my assignment to duty with his command I ask for orders to that effect

2/5/64 Richmond, Lovell to A&IGO-His application for assignment to the Army of Tenn having failed will return to Columbia, SC, & there await orders-repeats his request to be assigned to any position in which he can be useful

7/3/64 Johnston to Bragg-Stewart's Div requires a cdr immediately. It will be useless unless one is assigned. I again urge, most respectfully, the assignment of Maj-Gen Lovell to it.

July 64 Gen Hood requested Lovell as Corps cdr

Dec 64-Hardee applied to assign Lovell to some command at Savannah. But as everyone before him including Johnston & Hood, this was declined.

12/24/64 Gen Lovell, at Columbia, SC, wrote to the SC Gov: "The occupation of Savannah by the enemy in large force renders the invasion of this State quite probable. Under these circumstances, as I am unemployed in my official position, I beg leave to say that, if, in this emergency, I can render any service, or render you any assistance in military matters, I will do so most cheerfully. My sole desire is to contribute to the utmost of my ability to the success of the common cause."
† Gen Lovell's Letter Book, p. 142.​

3/23/65 Johnston made another request for Lovell & Lovell was ordered to report to Gen Lee for assignment.

3/24/65 Breckinridge as Sec of War to Lee-Your dispatch of this date in regard to Maj-Gen Lovell has been received & he has been ordered to report to you.

4/7/65 Near Smithfield NC, Maj Gen Lovell is assigned to command in the State of SC. By command of Gen Johnston

4/21/65 Beauregard at Greensboro to Lovell-"Gen Lee has assuredly capitulated & the paroled men of his Army must be permitted to pass to their homes as prescribed in their passports."

4/26/65 Lovell was included in Johnston's surrender on 4/26, but his personal parole has never been located

5/5/65 Salisbury-J E. Johnston to Maj-Gen Lovell, Columbia: Understanding between Gen Sherman & myself, one- seventh of arms taken home by troops-These used to keep country quiet or disposed of by U. S. local cdr. Field transportation & subsistence stores taken by troops for men distributed for farming when troops reach home. Any military property not required by troops goes to US.
 
My favorite trivia concerning Lovell appeared several years ago in an article in Civil War Times. It seems that after the war when Lovell was again working as Chief Engineer for the City of New York his home seems to have been a favorite venue for visiting former Confederate generals; it seems many of them wound up at the photo studio of Matthew Brady to have their likenesses taken. Since the war had been over by then for a few years, none of them had with them their uniforms as former generals, so they borrowed Mansfields! P.G.T. Beauregard below, Edmund Kirby Smith, and a few others are obviously wearing in their most famous photographs the same garment with its distinctively shaped double-breasted button pattern and oversized collar insignia:

PGTBo.jpg
 
4/30/62 Tangipahoa, La-Lovell to Van Dorn-[just five days after New Orleans had fallen, he informed Major Gen Van Dorn of his intention to arm & occupy Vicksburg.]

Location of Camp Moore, LA, where many Louisiana regiments were trained.
General van Dorn launched his attack on Baton Rouge(6 Aug 1862) from here.
 
It was Lovell who relieved General Twiggs from command in Texas. His first major assignment was the defense of New Orleans, but he was left with a insufficient force. Most of his units were sent to Cornith for the buildup prior to Shiloh. This left him with a small force of green troops. But he was blamed when yhe city fell in April of 1862. A court of inquiry did absolve him of blame the following year. Until found innocent he led a division at Corinth and temporarily a Corps at Vicksburg. He was then relieved of duty to await orders until March 1865 when he was ordered to join Joseph Johnston in North Carolina. But Johnston surrendered before Lovell could be assigned a command.
Oops, I stand corrected Twiggs was relieved in New Orleans,La. not San Antonio , Texas. Twiggs was asked to be replaced due to health issues, he was already 70+ years old.
 
Oops, I stand corrected Twiggs was relieved in New Orleans,La. not San Antonio , Texas. Twiggs was asked to be replaced due to health issues, he was already 70+ years old.
Fortunately for him, Twiggs only lived a short time afterward - he would've certainly been a likely candidate for trial for treason postwar! Even had that not happened (as it did not even in the case of another possible, former Secretary of War John Floyd) Twiggs would've likely been motivated to flee to avoid prosecution, a difficulty for someone in advanced age and bad health.
 
I don't think Lovell was as bad or incompetent as public opinion made him out to be. Not in the defense of New Orleans anyway. In other instances he very well may have shown questionable leadership but not in this one. He had a job to do, but Richmond (and other authorities)
somehow did of recognize the importancy or urgency of protecting New Orleans. Troops were siphoned off and sent elsewhere but not by Lovell.He did have the troops to defend N.O. at one time but they were kind of "borrowed".
 
I was reading the official records it show on March 25th 1865, Lovell was ordered to report to Lee for a unknown reason. I belive this could be Lovell getting a command but he did not get to Richmond before its fall.

Dec 64-Hardee applied to assign Lovell to some command at Savannah. But as everyone before him including Johnston & Hood, this was declined

12/24/64 Gen Lovell, at Columbia, SC, wrote to the SC Gov: "The occupation of Savannah by the enemy in large force renders the invasion of this State quite probable. Under these circumstances, as I am unemployed in my official position, I beg leave to say that, if, in this emergency, I can render any service, or render you any assistance in military matters, I will do so most cheerfully. My sole desire is to contribute to the utmost of my ability to the success of the common cause."

3/23/65 Johnston made another request for Lovell, & Lovell was ordered to report to Gen Lee for assignment.

3/24/65 Breckinridge as Sec of War to Lee-Your dispatch of this date in regard to Maj-Gen Lovell has been received & he has been ordered to report to you.

3/25 Richmond, XIII Maj Gen Mansfield Lovell, Prov. Army, CSA, will immediately report by letter to Gen Lee, cdg CS Army. By command of the Sec of War:

3/25 Richmond, to Maj Gen M. Lovell: (Care Gen Johnston, Raleigh)-You will report immediately by letter to Gen Lee.

4/7/65 Near Smithfield NC, Maj Gen Lovell is assigned to command in the State of SC. By command of Gen Johnston

5/2/65 Greensboro, A Anderson AAG to Maj Gen P. M. B. Young, Augusta-The military convention includes the whole of Gen Johnston's command. You are immediately under Maj- Gen Lovell & should receive instructions from him.

5/3/65 Aiken, (Received 12:20) P. M. B. Young, Maj-Gen to Gen McLaws: In my absence Gen Lovell has given orders to my troops. I have directed them to be surrendered; they will obey orders, but I am told most of the Regts have disorganized & are going home without authority. I hear most of them are going by Washington, Ga. I hear the Regts could not be kept together on account of no rations & no forage. Men & horses are suffering immensely. I am very unwell. Will report to Gen Lovell in Columbia when my leave of absence expires

5/11/65 Charlotte, J Johnston to Maj-Gen McLaws: Thinking it necessary to explain to the Southern people the state of things which compelled me to put an end to the war, as far as I could, I prepared the enclosed paper for that purpose* I beg you to have it published as widely in Ga as you can. A copy is sent to Gen Lovell with the same request.
 
While Lovell worked in New York his work was supervised by former Union General John Newton, a West Point classmate (1842). Newton was serving with the Corps of Engineers at the time.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top