Looking For Information About This Image.

Robert Gray

Sergeant Major
Joined
Jul 24, 2012
In 1981 The National Historical Society published a six volume set of books entitled THE IMAGE OF WAR: 1861-1865. In volume 1, SHADOWS OF THE STORM, there appeared this illustration of a young Union volunteer. I was intrigued by the image as I had never seen it before. It was credited to Robert McDonald. Is there any information about the history of the photograph? I presume it's either an ambrotype or tintype.

lf24.jpg
 
Bob McDonald has replied: "It is a sixth-plate tintype, and was in my collection in the late '70s and early '80s. There was no identification or provenance before that time. In addition to the NHS publication, the image also appears, albeit briefly, in the Ken Burns series film. I believe that it is now at the LOC."
 
In 1981 The National Historical Society published a six volume set of books entitled THE IMAGE OF WAR: 1861-1865. In volume 1, SHADOWS OF THE STORM, there appeared this illustration of a young Union volunteer. I was intrigued by the image as I had never seen it before. It was credited to Robert McDonald. Is there any information about the history of the photograph? I presume it's either an ambrotype or tintype.

View attachment 457853
every item of clothing seems to be ill fitting? how was clothing issued? any one know? just courious?
 
every item of clothing seems to be ill fitting? how was clothing issued? any one know? just courious?
They came in 2 sizes, too big and too small 😀 Seriously I believe they made 4 sizes. Certainly not tailor fit. Looking at a lot of period photos of guys in the field their clothing rarely looked like a perfect fit.
 
thank you. for a moment I thought about the time that I was in the ARMY back in 1961. thank you for the information.
 
every item of clothing seems to be ill fitting? how was clothing issued? any one know? just courious?
One thing Col. Fremantle noted in his book was that the average Confederate uniform, though non-standard in color, fit the soldier much better than the uniforms of the Union soldiers he observed.
 
What interests me about this photo is the angle. The photographer was either on elevated ground or a structure, possibly the second or third floor of a house or building. Makes me think the boy was on guard duty and the photographer stepped out on a deck or veranda and said, "Hold that pose!" Looking at it again, he's not so high up, so maybe on a front porch.
 
One thing Col. Fremantle noted in his book was that the average Confederate uniform, though non-standard in color, fit the soldier much better than the uniforms of the Union soldiers he observed.
Most CSA uniforms were made by family members or local seamstresses. It's a lot easier to fit something when you have seen the person who will wear it!
 
What interests me about this photo is the angle. The photographer was either on elevated ground or a structure, possibly the second or third floor of a house or building. Makes me think the boy was on guard duty and the photographer stepped out on a deck or veranda and said, "Hold that pose!" Looking at it again, he's not so high up, so maybe on a front porch.
veranda, now that is a seldom word used any more. I grew up with it in the 1950's. and porch & stoop! now they are called deck's!
 
i always use settee or sofa but as the mrs says "your old fashioned", and as i reply "well i feel it"...
also childrens names all fancy now... but what about the old uns? my auntys long gone now bless them were Maud, Ethel, Florrie, Cynthia, Brenda... but all is not lost, i was waiting in the doctors surgery for a blood test, and there was a young mother with a 1yr old to see the nurse and the baby was called Mable...it made me smile, and thats alway a good thing...
 
Most CSA uniforms were made by family members or local seamstresses. It's a lot easier to fit something when you have seen the person who will wear it!
Yes, someone told Fremantle that his soldiers preferred to wear homespun over issued uniforms. I think that was at Shelbyville, but don't remember. Fremanttle wrote that only the officers were uniformly in gray.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top