Drew
Major
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2012
I yield to no one in my admiration of, respect for, and yes, love for Professor Robertson. But his status does not make him immune to criticism by others. While I disagree with some of what Kevin says, I also agree with some of his criticisms.
I trust those who believe Kevin Levin isn't in a position to criticize what Professor Robertson said because he hasn't reached Professor Robertson's status as a historian will in the future never criticize another historian, including Kevin Levin, unless they've reached a comparative status. Kevin has a Master's Degree in History and is about to publish his third book, with a fourth book in the works. He's also published several articles in historical journals. So anyone of those folks claiming he has no status to criticize Professor Robertson then will refrain from criticizing Kevin until they get at least a Master's Degree in History and have published at least two books as well as articles in historical journals.
Thank you for posting.
I believe I have earned a B.S. in CivilWarTalk, as have you.
However, I do not believe a modern blogger with a modern agenda rises to the level of Bud Robertson, though I appreciate your respect for the latter.
There are times to talk and times to shut up and go away. This is one of those times.

