HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I consider Bronson's appearance in "Drum Beat" a very good one.
I think that one of his best scenes in the movie is the one where he dispaches the Colts among the killers in order to kill the peace comitee.

View attachment 534244

I was certainly memorable. i saw this movie on TV as a child, and the "peace committee" scene I distinctly recall. This was long before I knew of the Modoc War.
 
Pet peeve: when The Treasure of the Sierra Madre is referred to as a Western. It is set in 1925, way too late!

If a movie's western setting somehow makes it a Horse Opera, is Last Man Standing? Is Giant? Is Dillinger? How about Napoleon Dynamite?
 
Napoleon Dynamite is most definitely a western. This scene sealed it:

Napoleon Dynamite has a time machine, a Llama, is not Wild Wild West and voted for Pedro - so it clearly is a Steampunk Western. :D
"Over there in that pigpen I found a couple of Shoshone arrowheads."

I love NP. My favorite indie movie. My favorite line:

 
Napoleon Dynamite is a indeed a western. Recall in the end he rides out of the hills to the rescue (saving the wedding party from Kip's strange wedding song) on the "Honeymoon Stallion" he had just completed training...



Napoleon Dynamite's climactic ride, is reminiscent of Sheb Wooley's ride at the beginning of High Noon!

1736563561629.png
1736563593869.png
 
It's been a long time since I hadn't see "Run of the arrow"...I didn't change my mind about it : it should have been better.

1: it's in fact a low budget film (at least for it's USCW part)...don't get fooled by the huge Sioux attack in the end, half of the money must have been spend there. The meeting at Appomatox is so cheap...Grant and Lee have only a one man "escort" each over, that's why it could be so easy for O'Meara to kill Grant...(there are no guards and only a few meters between him and the meeting)...

2: there are some strange elements in the movie I still can't explain, some funny, like the huge "U.S" marquings on the horse's side (I've never saw that anywhere), the scout's fake hair is funny too...and somes completely "derouting"...why Brian Keith character's dies so soon in the film ? It's my favorite US officer in the staff, with a good role (he's an engineer's in charge of buildind a fort).

3: some good points on the other hand, the U.S cavalry is well depicted, Bronson sounds good as an indian leader, they permit the survivors to leave the field safe after the battle, Keith as a good conversation with Steiger, trying to get him back among white people, the battle scene is a good one, the romance with the indian girl is credible...

MV5BMmZjNzE1ZjgtOTM5Zi00ZDg4LTllMTktNjNjNDlkYzY0MWJhXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyOTI2MjI5MQ@@._V1_FMjpg_UX1...jpg
 
Last edited:
It's been a long time since I hadn't see "Run of the arrow"...I didn't change my mind about it : it should have been better.

1: it's in fact a low budget film (at least for it's USCW part)...don't get fooled by the huge Sioux attack in the end, half of the money must have been spend there. The meeting at Appomatox is so cheap...Grant and Lee have only a one man "escort" each over, that's why it could be so easy for O'Meara to kill Grant...(there are no guards and only a few meters between him and the meeting)...

2: there are some strange elements in the movie I still can't explain, some funny, like the huge "U.S" marquings on the horse's side (I've never saw that anywhere), the scout's fake hair is funny too...and somes completely "derouting"...why Brian Keith character's dies so soon in the film ? It's my favorite US officer in the staff, with a good role (he's an engineer's in charge of buildind a fort).

3: some good points on the other hand, the U.S cavalry is well depicted, Bronson sounds good as an indian leader, they permit the survivors to leave the field safe after the battle, Keith as a good conversation with Steiger, trying to get him back among white people, the battle scene is a good one, the romance with the indian girl is credible...

Run of the Arrow was a low budget picture. In 1990 "Dances With Wolves" was much more successful... with similar plot, etc.
 
Napoleon Dynamite is a indeed a western. Recall in the end he rides out of the hills to the rescue (saving the wedding party from Kip's strange wedding song) on the "Honeymoon Stallion" he had just completed training...



Napoleon Dynamite's climactic ride, is reminiscent of Sheb Wooley's ride at the beginning of High Noon!

View attachment 535001View attachment 535002
Ah yes, I completely forgot about that scene! Very nice memory @RedRover . This scene is hilarious to me because his riding form is so laughable. He's holding on for dear life, and he's kind of at an angle with his head back. The wedding scene is also pretty funny, but I don't want to spoil it for anyone who hasn't seen it. Anyways, after the wedding, he makes Lafawnduh (I'm pretty sure that's wrong, but that's how Kip spelled it :biggrin:) get on the horse in front of him, which is the opposite way they should've been sitting with him in front. Just a great movie THAT IS A CLASSIC WESTERN.

Napoleon Dynamite- Kip meets Lafawnduh ...
 
Continuing to stretch the genre a good bit we have two really sunny examples of interesting films in Kings of the Sun (1963, starring Yul Brynner), about a Maya tribe migrating north of the Gulf, and The Royal Hunt of the Sun (1969, starring Christopher Plummer and Robert Shaw), about Pizarro and the Incas.
 
Ah yes, I completely forgot about that scene! Very nice memory @RedRover . This scene is hilarious to me because his riding form is so laughable. He's holding on for dear life, and he's kind of at an angle with his head back. The wedding scene is also pretty funny, but I don't want to spoil it for anyone who hasn't seen it. Anyways, after the wedding, he makes Lafawnduh (I'm pretty sure that's wrong, but that's how Kip spelled it :biggrin:) get on the horse in front of him, which is the opposite way they should've been sitting with him in front. Just a great movie THAT IS A CLASSIC WESTERN.

Napoleon struggles to get along with his early 21st Century society, in the west, throughout the movie... especially employing his parents and grandparents' old tech (Beta max tapes! Walkman!) or even modern interpretive dance, etc. Yet he has all along the requisite skills of an old west hero which he thinks he has no use for. After two hours of angst we learn training stallions is no big deal!

Just another "Death of the old west" flick, but instead of dealing with auto-mobiles, airplaines, machine guns, etc. Napoleon Dynamite wrestles with teen alienation in comedic fashion.
 
Ah yes, I completely forgot about that scene! Very nice memory @RedRover . This scene is hilarious to me because his riding form is so laughable. He's holding on for dear life, and he's kind of at an angle with his head back. The wedding scene is also pretty funny, but I don't want to spoil it for anyone who hasn't seen it. Anyways, after the wedding, he makes Lafawnduh (I'm pretty sure that's wrong, but that's how Kip spelled it :biggrin:) get on the horse in front of him, which is the opposite way they should've been sitting with him in front. Just a great movie THAT IS A CLASSIC WESTERN.

View attachment 535057
Napoleon struggles to get along with his early 21st Century society, in the west, throughout the movie... especially employing his parents and grandparents' old tech (Beta max tapes! Walkman!) or even modern interpretive dance, etc. Yet he has all along the requisite skills of an old west hero which he thinks he has no use for. After two hours of angst we learn training stallions is no big deal!

Just another "Death of the old west" flick, but instead of dealing with auto-mobiles, airplaines, machine guns, etc. Napoleon Dynamite wrestles with teen alienation in comedic fashion.
Also Napoleon tames a Western town controlled by evil (Summer) against overwhelming odds.

 
On a more serious note, as promised, I watched Rooster Cogburn last night, and I thought it was pretty good. Eula reminded me of Mattie Ross in True Grit, and I actually thought that she was going to annoy him, which she did, but it wasn't nearly as much as Mattie. I will say the guy running the ferry boat I found extremely funny. "Been around the horn! Sailed the Seven Seas! Seen everything! Done everything! That's how I figured out people are so miserable!" On the other side of things, I thought the outlaws were a bit less scary and foreboding than some in previous movies. (I actually thought the battle at the beginning was a Civil War battle, but I quickly realized that Hawk and his gang were most definitely not Confederates :D) I thought it was a decent movie overall. It was certainly different from a lot of other westerns I've seen. I honestly don't think it makes my Top 5 Westerns list. There are just other movies that I liked better. I would love to hear what you guys think about the movie.

 
It's been a long time since I hadn't see "Run of the arrow"...I didn't change my mind about it : it should have been better.

1: it's in fact a low budget film (at least for it's USCW part)...don't get fooled by the huge Sioux attack in the end, half of the money must have been spend there. The meeting at Appomatox is so cheap...Grant and Lee have only a one man "escort" each over, that's why it could be so easy for O'Meara to kill Grant...(there are no guards and only a few meters between him and the meeting)...

2: there are some strange elements in the movie I still can't explain, some funny, like the huge "U.S" marquings on the horse's side (I've never saw that anywhere), the scout's fake hair is funny too...and somes completely "derouting"...why Brian Keith character's dies so soon in the film ? It's my favorite US officer in the staff, with a good role (he's an engineer's in charge of buildind a fort).

3: some good points on the other hand, the U.S cavalry is well depicted, Bronson sounds good as an indian leader, they permit the survivors to leave the field safe after the battle, Keith as a good conversation with Steiger, trying to get him back among white people, the battle scene is a good one, the romance with the indian girl is credible...

View attachment 535018
I always wondered how they looked so fit in these movies when they lived off the land.

p4482_i_h10_aa.jpg
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top