I prefer Unforgiven to Tombstone, personally.
I've seen interviews with some of the
Tombstone cast who admit some surprise at the continued enthusiasm for their film, now entering its fourth decade. Many evidently felt the production was rather troubled and rushed. But it is lots of fun. While Unforgiven is a slow burn, and somewhat "nihilistic" say some.
Regardless of preferences I heard expressed between Unforgiven or Tombstone, back in 1993, or to today, I have yet to hear anyone express a preference of Costner's
Wyatt Earp over either.
Unadjusted for inflation, Costner's
Dances with Wolves is the number 2 top grossing western genre motion picture, at 424 million 1990 dollars. Django Unchained number 1 with 449 million 2012 dollars.
However, adjusted for inflation/devaluation of the dollar over time by a common inflation calculator,
Dances with Wolves is still number one as the most profitable western picture. It's 424 million 1990 bucks being worth way more than the 449 million 2012 ones of Django.
Dances made big money in 1990 and swept the Oscars in 1991. It really kick started the early '90s western renewal. But I enjoyed the Young Guns movies too. They were not super successful, but they kept westerns in the box office after Pale Rider & Silverado (June-July, 1985) and before Dances with Wolves at the close of 1990.