HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Y'all are gonna kill me...

I actually loved McKenna's Gold. Sure it was wacky and lame, but in a good way! The effects were the biggest flaw, however.
Someone recently tried to explain that it was impossible for horses to keep up with how fast the shadow of the needle was moving across the desert. That shadow would have moved across the desert faster than a horse can run.I'm referring to MacKenna's Gold.
 
Last edited:
Enjoy it! Never heard of it until now.

the Modoc War!

the Modocs were dug into the lava beds like modern entrenchments. US troops laid siege, etc.

1735797103148.png



the movie "Drum Beat" stars Charles Bronson as Modoc leader Captain Jack...

1735796906211.png
1735796965841.png
 
It's a very good Western, despite it's "average" reputation (for a Delmer Dave's film), Bronson is terrific, Ladd is as good as usually, there's a very good action scene with US cavalry (they fight dismounted), and also good scenes with Ulysses Grant.
Let's say the Modocs are depicted as Apaches, they look like them.
Interesting fact, it's the first time Bronson used the name "Bronson" on film credits.
DB 54.jpg
 
Unforgiven preceded Tombstone. It was in theaters in the summer of 1992, and was a big success, and won best picture in March, 1993. Tombstone's production commenced a couple months later in May, 1993 and was released in theaters in December, 1993. Costner's "Wyatt Earp" several months later.

Tombstone's domestic gross box office receipts were 56 million. Unforgiven the year before was over 101 million. It has been interesting to see the popularity of Tombstone continue, and even expand over time.

Costner's Wyatt Earp squeaked out about 25 million in the summer of '94.
Young Guns preceded both by a few years, would think a case could be made it helped revitalize interest in westerns and certainly Billy the Kid.
 
Young Guns preceded both by a few years, would think a case could be made it helped revitalize interest in westerns and certainly Billy the Kid.

Certainly didn't hurt! Young Guns, 1988, was a success at 45 million. And Young Guns 2, 1990, grossed 44 million. Part of their draw at the time was the "brat pack" cast. But Dances with Wolves, 1990 made over ten times the money.

Dances production commenced in 1986, a year after Costner's turn in the less successful Silverado, with him consulting with the screenwriter Michael Blake. Blake published the story as a novel at Costner's suggestion to develop interest, which worked. Then in 1988 Costner formed Tig Productions to make Dances with Wolves, raising about 15 million to film in 1989. I would suppose the success of Young Guns in '88 was an impetus for investors, etc.

Tom Cruise appears in a cameo in Young Guns, among the casualties in the final shootout.

1735826802847.png
 
Someone recently tried to explain that it was impossible for horses to keep up with how fast the shadow of the needle was moving across the desert. That shadow would have moved across the desert faster than a horse can run.I'm referring to MacKenna's Gold.
That makes sense. I should've noticed that. But it's not like it was exactly a realistic film.
 
the Modoc War!

the Modocs were dug into the lava beds like modern entrenchments. US troops laid siege, etc.

View attachment 534096


the movie "Drum Beat" stars Charles Bronson as Modoc leader Captain Jack...

View attachment 534094View attachment 534095
I recently read about the Modocs in The Earth is Weeping, but Bronson as Capt. Jack sounds laughable. Also love the new avatar!

Young Guns preceded both by a few years, would think a case could be made it helped revitalize interest in westerns and certainly Billy the Kid.
I've still never seen Young Guns. Any good?
 
Ml5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNDQxMzQyMQ@@._V1_FMjpg_UX1000_.jpg


I've been watching Hidalgo. It's been good so far. I've liked all of the Modern Westerns I've seen made by major studios. Forsaken was not, and I hated it.

J.K. Simmons was an excellent Buffalo Bill, albeit briefly.

hidalgos-hardware-2.jpg
 
I recently read about the Modocs in The Earth is Weeping, but Bronson as Capt. Jack sounds laughable. Also love the new avatar!

Perhaps basketball star and actor extraordinaire Chuck Connors as Geronimo might be more convincing...

1735925317697.png



I've still never seen Young Guns. Any good?


Yes. Young guns is kind of fun, 1980s style, and somewhat silly. Estevez's maniacal take on Billy the Kid is amusing. Jack Palance chews some scenery to shreds as the evil Mr. Murphy.

Young Guns 2 is an interesting contrast. All the youthful exuberance, bombast and silliness of the first falls away, and the result is rather more bleak. In the first they were out for justice, at least initially; in the second they've given up any such pretense and turned outlaw. Looking back on it, the second movie really surprised me, and was a great theatrical experience, given what use it made of the characters of the first picture.

Both pictures have some cameos/callbacks to other previous westerns. Brian Keith's as "Buckshot" Roberts stood out in Young Guns.

Speaking of Palance, I just reminded of his turn in "The Mercenary" (1968).

 
Perhaps basketball star and actor extraordinaire Chuck Connors as Geronimo might be more convincing...

View attachment 534230





Yes. Young guns is kind of fun, 1980s style, and somewhat silly. Estevez's maniacal take on Billy the Kid is amusing. Jack Palance chews some scenery to shreds as the evil Mr. Murphy.

Young Guns 2 is an interesting contrast. All the youthful exuberance, bombast and silliness of the first falls away, and the result is rather more bleak. In the first they were out for justice, at least initially; in the second they've given up any such pretense and turned outlaw. Looking back on it, the second movie really surprised me, and was a great theatrical experience, given what use it made of the characters of the first picture.

Both pictures have some cameos/callbacks to other previous westerns. Brian Keith's as "Buckshot" Roberts stood out in Young Guns.

Speaking of Palance, I just reminded of his turn in "The Mercenary" (1968).

Palance even played Dracula once.
 
"Bone Tomahawk". Kurt Russell, Patrick Wilson, Matthew Fox, David Arquette, Lili Simmons, plus a host of others. Dark, different. bloody thought provoking western. Not for everyone but a pretty good rating. Watch it if you dare. From 2015.
I personally don't love horror stuff, so probably not my cup of tea. But thanks for sharing, for others!
 
I personally don't love horror stuff, so probably not my cup of tea. But thanks for sharing, for others!
Same. I like nice relaxing movies with no suspense or thrill at all—oh wait, I forgot, we're talking about Westerns. You know, the kind where everyone has a 12-minute staring contest before the gunfight that will somehow determine who owns the whole town. Totally low-key.
 
Still can't beat "High Noon" for its time. I saw it at the Lancaster PA. drive in when it first came out. It was raining that night. I'm 79.
"High Noon". What a classic name for a film. I just picture in my mind a gunfight... in the middle of Main Street between the sheriff and his rival. Budweiser made an advertisement like that I think a few years back, but I can't seem to find it. Anyways, here's a classic scene from "Once Upon a Time in the West" that is sort of like what I'm trying to say:
(Jack Elam's in this one. He was in Rio Lobo as well.)
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top