HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Being a young man born an old f**t, I love the original, but the emotions and the stakes are much higher in the remake. Also more historically accurate.

The superior part of the original is the "drought" theme, with the dry desert.
I think it's called "having an old heart " It means you appreciate things from the past despite your age. Speaking as an official old guy it's a good thing.
 
View attachment 493869

I wanted to start a big ol' thread for all Western fans, to talk about movies, TV shows, video games, etc. (This is CW-related, since the majority of Westerns involve it in some way.)

I'll start by listing my favorite Western movies, and why.

The 2007 remake of 3:10 to Yuma is probably my favorite Western. I'm a big fan of the orignial, but this one blew my mind. It's not only exhilirating, but emotionally effective and surprising. The original goes on my favorite list too.

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is literally perfect, and it can only be justified by a viewing.

The Good the Bad and the Ugly is the only Leone film I like. I was never crazy about his lengthy art-farts.

Unforgiven is still a masterpiece, one of the most authentic period pieces ever made.

The Gunfighter is a good obscure, black-and-white one, where Gregory Peck plays an aging gunfighter trying to reunite with his wife. Unforgiven but less sad, but still sad.

The Searchers needs no introduction.

Nor Lonesome Dove.

The Ox-Bow Incident screws with the mind!

Nevada Smith is a forgotten vehicle, very long but effective. Probably the only thing by Henry Hathaway I consider masterful.

You next!
How about High Noon?
 
Nobody's talked about Peckinpah Westerns yet. I've only seen Ride the High Country.
  • Ride the High Country
  • Major Dundee
  • The Wild Bunch
  • The Ballad of Cable Hogue
  • Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid
@Desert Kid I know you love him!
Peckinpah directed some of the "Rifleman" episodes as well, didn't he? Ida Lupino directed some of the earliest ones. She was the "4th star" in 4 star productions after Joel Macrea dropped out.I think it was 4 Star that produced that show.
 
Peckinpah directed some of the "Rifleman" episodes as well, didn't he? Ida Lupino directed some of the earliest ones. She was the "4th star" in 4 star productions after Joel Macrea dropped out.I think it was 4 Star that produced that show.
Yeah. Considering the G-rated tone of the series, it seems like a joke he directed a few episodes, since Peckinpah's MO was cynical sex and violence.
 
Being a young man born an old f**t, I love the original, but the emotions and the stakes are much higher in the remake. Also more historically accurate.

The superior part of the original is the "drought" theme, with the dry desert.
They are both good films and good westerns. but I guess one of the things I enjoy about the first one is that it is painted on a smaller canvass, we don't need to be concerned with what the Chinese and the other factors that we're presented with on the larger canvas.
 
The Big Country has great theme music.
When I was a kid we had the soundtrack in the family's record collection so I grew up with it. I have a wonderful version of the theme song by Bela Fleck & the Flecktones, as well as versions on "Best Of The West: Original MGM Motion Picture Soundtracks" and "The Wild West: The Essential Western Film Music Collection."
 
When I was a kid we had the soundtrack in the family's record collection so I grew up with it. I have a wonderful version of the theme song by Bela Fleck & the Flecktones, as well as versions on "Best Of The West: Original MGM Motion Picture Soundtracks" and "The Wild West: The Essential Western Film Music Collection."
How the West was Won was not a favorite movie but I did like the theme music.
 
Yeah. Considering the G-rated tone of the series, it seems like a joke he directed a few episodes, since Peckinpah's MO was cynical sex and violence.
I recently watched "Ride the High Country" and was surprised by the mostly absence of these typical Peckinpah themes, although it was early in his directing career and the ideas were never far from the surface and, like a good ice berg, did show some above the waterline.
 
"How the West was Won" had a cast like one would not believe. There were uncredited extras like John Carradine (I think)
and Walter Burke as silent poker players and had no spoken words. Lee Van Cleef was one of Walter Brennsn's "river pirates". Many don't even know it was Spencer Tracy narrating.One would have to do alot of research to find out the complete cast.
 
"How the West was Won" had a cast like one would not believe. There were uncredited extras like John Carradine (I think)
and Walter Burke as silent poker players and had no spoken words. Lee Van Cleef was one of Walter Brennsn's "river pirates". Many don't even know it was Spencer Tracy narrating.One would have to do alot of research to find out the complete cast.
My grandparents took me to the theater to see it when I was a kid. I remember there was an intermission.
 
"How the West was Won" had a cast like one would not believe. There were uncredited extras like John Carradine (I think)
and Walter Burke as silent poker players and had no spoken words. Lee Van Cleef was one of Walter Brennsn's "river pirates". Many don't even know it was Spencer Tracy narrating.One would have to do alot of research to find out the complete cast.
I looked on IMDB are there are a lot of actors who are not credited . Most I never heard of but ones I have are Lee Van Cleef , Stanley Livingston (My Three Sons) , Dub Taylor , Ken Curtis , Jay C. Flippen , Claude Akins and Harry Dean Stanton. Yvonne De Carlo"a husband was a stuntman who was seriously injured in the train sequence.
 
"How the West was Won" had a cast like one would not believe. There were uncredited extras like John Carradine (I think)
and Walter Burke as silent poker players and had no spoken words. Lee Van Cleef was one of Walter Brennsn's "river pirates". Many don't even know it was Spencer Tracy narrating.One would have to do alot of research to find out the complete cast.
Probably not complete, but here is what wikipedia has:

Cast[edit]

Introduced in "The Rivers"
Introduced in "The Plains"
Introduced in "The Civil War"
Introduced in "The Railroad"
Introduced in "The Outlaws"
 
My grandparents took me to the theater to see it when I was a kid. I remember there was an intermission.
My family and I were passing through London when i film came out and the only seat available were in the middle of the front row. So the whole movie was spent with me going about 180 degrees from side to side while looking almost straight up. It was an adventure.
 
Some honorable mentions for my list:

The Rio Bravo Trilogy, High Plains Drifter, The Proud Rebel, My Darling Clementine, and The Undefeated.
My Darling Clementine definitely had the mood right , just not very accurate. Sometimes you just don't worry so much about accuracy and enjoy a movie anyhow.
 
My Darling Clementine definitely had the mood right , just not very accurate. Sometimes you just don't worry so much about accuracy and enjoy a movie anyhow.
I personally like it better than Tombstone.

Everyone:
f9ebae26499648648c5aab658df97e46.gif
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top