It is a curse and I suffer from it too.Sometimes I think it may be a curse knowing which weapon did or didn't belong in a certain time period.Many a "good" western has been ruined by my pointing it out. My wife thinks it's a curse, for her anyway.
It is available free on YouTube.@donna Not the two you are interested in but I saw Paleface in about 1954. I loved it as a kid. Saw in on TCM not too long ago and enjoyed it again. Guess I'm just easily amused. I think Paleface may be available on dvd.
John
I don't think Bob Hope won it but that song "Buttons and Bows"won an Academy Award for Best Original Song.@Polloco Well, it takes place in the west in the cowboy and Indian days. I would call it a western comedy maybe? But you are correct, it kinda defies description I guess. I remember it being very popular when I saw it as a kid.
@donna By the way, Hope sings the very popular song Buttons And Bows in the movie.
John
Another issue is basic errors in filming. Arizona Ghostriders on YouTube today covered it briefly. There are cars visible in the background in Shane , The Searchers and Fort Apache. There is an a/c unit on a building in High Noon.Sometimes I think it may be a curse knowing which weapon did or didn't belong in a certain time period.Many a "good" western has been ruined by my pointing it out. My wife thinks it's a curse, for her anyway.
I was in the library book store today and found (and got) "The Over the Hill Gang" which I thought was one of the films you mentioned. It turned out not to be but I imagine that it is a pretty close fit.For kids I have to mention the Westerns:
"The Apple Dumpling Gang" and "The Shakiest Gun In the West".
My grandkids recently watched these and enjoyed them. The Apple Dumpling Gang is a Disney film. The Shakiest Gun is with Don Knotts. It is based on an earlier (1948) film Paleface with Bob Hope.
Have any of you seen these. I have in younger days and did enjoy them.
I like learning about film score writers and figures off the bat that Marco Beltrami was an Italian brought over to give the film a spaghetti western flavor but, as is often the case, I was completely off. He's an American who has scored many films, "has become firmly entrenched as a composer of choice for the horror/thriller and action genre," (wikipedia) movies sort of out of my usual viewing scope. He did garner an Oscar nomination for the 3:10 soundtrack, so you are not alone in liking the score.I always liked the 3:10 remake's soundtrack.
Not my favorite Western score but one of my favorites. My favorite is probably something Bernstein or Morricone.I like learning about film score writers and figures off the bat that Marco Beltrami was an Italian brought over to give the film a spaghetti western flavor but, as is often the case, I was completely off. He's an American who has scored many films, "has become firmly entrenched as a composer of choice for the horror/thriller and action genre," (wikipedia) movies sort of out of my usual viewing scope. He did garner an Oscar nomination for the 3:10 soundtrack, so you are not alone in liking the score.