HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
To each his own, any member who bothers to reply is certainly entitled to their opinion and this thread is filled with such. but I got to disagree on a remark. I"m paraphrasing, a few posts back a member stated how John Wayne was "perfect" in his role as Crockett along with Richard Widmark's Bowie and Laurence Harvey's Travis. Except for Harvey as the arrogant Travis (which was pretty good) my opinion is that it was a very bad instance of typecasting. You can throw in Richard Boone as Sam Houston,too. My opinion is that Wayne was next to laughable as Crockett, but it was still a fair movie.
 
To each his own, any member who bothers to reply is certainly entitled to their opinion and this thread is filled with such. but I got to disagree on a remark. I"m paraphrasing, a few posts back a member stated how John Wayne was "perfect" in his role as Crockett along with Richard Widmark's Bowie and Laurence Harvey's Travis. Except for Harvey as the arrogant Travis (which was pretty good) my opinion is that it was a very bad instance of typecasting. You can throw in Richard Boone as Sam Houston,too. My opinion is that Wayne was next to laughable as Crockett, but it was still a fair movie.
I've got to agree on Wayne's Crockett. There are lots of issues with They Died with Their Boots On historically , but it was entertaining if you don't take it too seriously.
 
Hollywood seems to be very "copycat" in its operation. When a successful movie like "Shane" came out with a child actor (Brandon deWilde) as a costar others followed. I could give examples like Tommy Rettig in "River of No Return" , Lee Aaker in "Hondo" or Tommy Kirk in "Old Yeller". Lee Aaker was also that boy Rusty in the "Adventures of Rin Tin Tin." Maybe it started back with Margaret O'Brian in "Bad Bascomb" with Wallace Berry (good movie, by the way). But there did seem to be quite a few westerns with a boy (or a girl) in them back in the 50s
 
Last edited:
The prologue of "Vera Cruz" talks about the end of the USCW, and most of the american characters are former soldiers, except for sure Joe Erin (Burt Lancaster), that we can't imagine beeing ordered anything under any flag. These veterans of both camps join Maximilian's troops in order to assure the safety of a "Countess"(Denise Darcel), and a wagon loaded with gold...
Great Western, possibly a forerunner (means precursor ?) to the italian wave.
The only disappointment with this film might be the final battle scene (assault of Juaristas on the city of Vera Cruz), it seems Robert Aldrich was bored with it and shoot it quickly.

Poster - Vera Cruz (1954)_10.jpg


36.jpg


34.jpg


35.jpg
 
"How the West was won"...is despite many things a very good Western. It was co-directed (Ford/Hathaway/Marshall), that's possibly why there is no particular "style" that emerge from the film ; the Civil War chapter (directed by John Ford) is maybe the most renowed part of the movie.
The epic final , with it's aerial view of San Francisco (of 1962) is just great, it drives you to think that the next step will be to reach the Moon (what it was for real a few years later).
I've seen it many times through years, actually, my favorite character is Andy Devine, as a Union soldier.

Z1.jpg


Z3.jpg


Z4.jpg


Z5.jpg
 
It often puzzled and it still puzzles me why a director would (deliberately?)put some of the wrong equipment in his movie. Afterall it has his signature on it. The public is either going to be laughing about it or praising your work.The old saying "If you're going to do something ,do it right" should have come into play. Many westerns were "ruined" because some director chose to go the cheap or fast route instead of listening to his technical advisor.Was it ignorance or arrogance?
 
It often puzzled and it still puzzles me why a director would (deliberately?)put some of the wrong equipment in his movie. Afterall it has his signature on it. The public is either going to be laughing about it or praising your work.The old saying "If you're going to do something ,do it right" should have come into play. Many westerns were "ruined" because some director chose to go the cheap or fast route instead of listening to his technical advisor.Was it ignorance or arrogance?
Think that it's entertainment and most the public either won't know or doesn't care is primary reason.

As a kid I enjoyed WWII movies as well as westerns, of which how many made any effort at all to make german tanks actually look like historical panzers......? Think for most knowing something is supposed to represent this in entertainment is sufficient, whether the something is actually this.
 
Same as blackface in early entertainment, doubt point was to convince audience the actor was actually black, but merely to convey that's the role being depicted.
 
In that movie, they seem to use correct weapons, "Major Dundee" (#8) , might have been one of the best Westerns ever, but it was really mistreated by its montage, and some lacks in its scenario (still don't understand why the hell Amos Dundee installs himself with a hooker (?) in a cantina...leaving his command in a difficult situation), despite all these, it remains a very interesting civil war film , with great performances of Charlton Heston, Richard Harris, and James Coburn as the chief scout, same for the Peckinpah's usual actors team.

D3.jpg


D6.jpg


D4.jpg


D1.jpg
 
It often puzzled and it still puzzles me why a director would (deliberately?)put some of the wrong equipment in his movie. Afterall it has his signature on it. The public is either going to be laughing about it or praising your work.The old saying "If you're going to do something ,do it right" should have come into play. Many westerns were "ruined" because some director chose to go the cheap or fast route instead of listening to his technical advisor.Was it ignorance or arrogance?
I would guess that most people have no idea what the right gun would be at just about any moment in a historical movie. They're watching the people, not the weapons.
 
Also directed by Sam Peckinpah, there's the nostalgic "Ride the high country" (or "Guns in the afternoon"), starring two great stars of the genre, Joel Mc Crea and Randolph Scott , it's touching mostly because it's their last film to each other, and it may be seen as the tribute of the "young" generation to it's elders.

V30.jpg
 
A rare Western this time (in France anyway, I've waited 40 years to finally see it !) "The last command", it's a 1955 film starring Sterling Hayden as Jim Bowie and Arthur Hunnicut as Davy Crockett , it depicts the siege and fall of the Alamo, the main battle is great, and Crockett dies like in the John Wayne version, blowing himself with barrel of powder.
Don't jump of your seats at viewing the BRD cover, they use weapons of the era, and a correct flag.

63.jpg


ZZ1.jpg
 
I've got to agree on Wayne's Crockett. There are lots of issues with They Died with Their Boots On historically , but it was entertaining if you don't take it too seriously.
That's how I feel about Ford's My Darling Clementine. It's so good and so much a genre-setter that you ignore that it has so little relation to reality it's plagiaristic.

In Ford's defense, I read the book on Texas Comanche captives, The Captured by Scott Zesch, last year, and The Searchers and Two Rode Together hold up remarkably well in accuracy. In fact, the real Ethan Edwards was an ex-slave. Should he have been played by Woody Strode? :)
 
A rare Western this time (in France anyway, I've waited 40 years to finally see it !) "The last command", it's a 1955 film starring Sterling Hayden as Jim Bowie and Arthur Hunnicut as Davy Crockett , it depicts the siege and fall of the Alamo, the main battle is great, and Crockett dies like in the John Wayne version, blowing himself with barrel of powder.
Don't jump of your seats at viewing the BRD cover, they use weapons of the era, and a correct flag.

View attachment 496859

View attachment 496860
Anything Arthur Hunnicutt is worth watching.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top