HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
You all were talking about racial casting? How about the Native-American Woody Strode:

Woody-Strode-as-Stone-Calf-unhappy-that-Quanah-Parker-is-negotiating-with-the-whites-in-Two-Ro...jpg
 
In that movie, they seem to use correct weapons, "Major Dundee" (#8) , might have been one of the best Westerns ever, but it was really mistreated by its montage, and some lacks in its scenario (still don't understand why the hell Amos Dundee installs himself with a hooker (?) in a cantina...leaving his command in a difficult situation), despite all these, it remains a very interesting civil war film , with great performances of Charlton Heston, Richard Harris, and James Coburn as the chief scout, same for the Peckinpah's usual actors team.

View attachment 496852

View attachment 496853

View attachment 496855

View attachment 496856
Yes it would have been a better movie if they had eliminated the cantina/ abandoning his command part. It didn't really fit the movie .
 
Fr
In that movie, they seem to use correct weapons, "Major Dundee" (#8) , might have been one of the best Westerns ever, but it was really mistreated by its montage, and some lacks in its scenario (still don't understand why the hell Amos Dundee installs himself with a hooker (?) in a cantina...leaving his command in a difficult situation), despite all these, it remains a very interesting civil war film , with great performances of Charlton Heston, Richard Harris, and James Coburn as the chief scout, same for the Peckinpah's usual actors team.

View attachment 496852

View attachment 496853

View attachment 496855

View attachment 496856
Great movie.
 
I kind of enjoyed "The Last Command" but it's hard to picture a 6'5"Jim Bowie.
Than you may also appreciate Alan Ladd in "The Iron Mistress" (Gordon Douglas 1952) (and #11), some might say it's not completely a Western, but it is for many (after all, Jim Bowie was at the Alamo, and the Alamo's movies are considered to be Westerns...), the duels here are made with knives, and the greatest part of the film is in Louisiana, my favorite scene is the one where the Bowie Knife is created. The only thing that disturbs me in that wonderful film, is that Bowie throws the knife down the Mississippi ,interesting scene for sure, but this happens some years before his action at the Alamo, so we must suppose the "original" Bowie Knife wasn't there at the time.

ZZZ1.jpg
 
Awhile back, there was interest expressed in the movie Drums Along the Mohawk. This movie was based on a book. There are plenty of copies available at modest prices as it has been reprinted over the years.

This is a fairly recent publisher's description.

This is the original Kirkus review from 1936 (which accounts for some of the language).

For those who enjoyed watching the Longmire series on TV, there are a ton of books that came first. The audiobooks, both CD and on Hoopla and Libby/Overdrive (digital services that may be available through your library) are voiced by George Guidall. It's a joy to listen to him. If you haven't seen the series, it is available on DVD, so check your local library!

 
Last edited:
I read that the rifle that Henry Fonda carried in "Drums Along the Mohawk" is the the same rifle that John Wayne carried in "The Fighting Kentuckian". And that same article states that others like Gary Cooper, Fess Parker, Charleton Heston, and possibly Fred McMurray also used it. And that John Wayne again used it in "The Alamo". If that is true, that gun belongs in a museum.But then just because you read it on Wikipedia, don't mean it's true.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of Henry Fonda, "Fort Apache"(1948), from John Ford's renowed cavalry triology, it concerns clearly the LBH and Custer (Fonda's character), and somehow maybe Benteen (George O'Brien character of Capt.Colingwood).
One of the last scenes is without ambiguity linking the real events (that occured in the film) and the myth, through artists that were at work very soon, John Wayne character is asked by a journalist if "he has see the painting".

24.jpg
 
In a top 50, there are necessarily some outcasts...#13 is Marlon Brando's "One Eyed Jacks"(1961), a classic vengeance story, but presented on a "baroque" way, it shows us very rare scenes of the Ocean (for a Western anyway), the cast is just perfect and everyone sounds well.
The film is supposed to have been butchered by it's producers, maybe perhaps they wanted S.Kubrick to realise it, it lasted at first 4/5 hours (!), and Brando wasn't completely satisfied in the end, but what remain today is a great classic.

ZZ55.jpg
 
Speaking of guns, the cut down rifle , the "Mare's Leg", carried by Josh Randall (Steve McQueen) in "Wanted Dead or Alive"was a 44-40. Same caliber as the Rifleman's. But he carried 45-70 ammo in his belt. The director or producer thought it would be more "visually impressive" for the camera. I think this one too wound up in Gene Autry's collection.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of guns, the cut down rifle , the "Mare's Leg", carried by Josh Randall (Steve McQueen) in "Wanted Dead or Alive"was a 44-40. Same caliber as the Rifleman's. But he carried 45-70 ammo in his belt. The director or producer thought it would be more "visually impressive" for the camera. I think this one too wound up in Gene Autry's collection.
Can you imagine accurately trying to shoot such a gun. Also cut down like that it wouldn't hold many cartridges
 
Can you imagine accurately trying to shoot such a gun. Also cut down like that it wouldn't hold many cartridges
There are at least 2 companies marketing copies. But you're right, they must be terribly inaccurate and can't hold too many rounds. I would probably take one if they gave it to me but to pay hundreds for one. Why?
 
Watched cowboys and aliens tonight......was a little better then I expected, but had low expectations :D

Still have no idea what the hummingbird was about though........
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top