HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
So far we have named a few that should be on the "Best" western list. How about some that you think are the "Worst" westerns. I don't have my movie list handy but I would put The Big Valley on the worst TV list.
The worst by far is Guns of the Magnificent Seven, the third of the Quadrilogy. It completely copies the first film, even though the others do not. A boring plot about the Mexican Revolution, and it was supposedly was trying to copy the Spaghetti Zapata Westerns. Also George Kennedy plays Chris. That's right.

George-Kennedy-as-Chris-Adams-forming-a-new-seven-in-Guns-of-the-Magnificent-Seven-1969.jpg


Also the dumb, bigoted Confederate cliche.
 
Last edited:
The worst by far in Guns of the Magnificent Seven, the third of the Quadrilogy. It completely copies the first film, even though the others do not. A boring plot about the Mexican Revolution, and it was supposedly was trying to copy the Spaghetti Zapata Westerns. Also George Kennedy plays Chris. That's right.

View attachment 496100

Also the dumb, bigoted Confederate cliche.
George Kennedy made a good heavy or bad guy in numerous westerns but he was no "Chris". Chris, wasn't that the name of the character played by Ben Johnson in Shane"?
 
So here's a scene we've all seen depicted (or very similar)-

"Joe" is gonna embark on a dangerous task. His friend "Frank" feels he should go instead…… perhaps to save Joe's life for the benefit of his beautiful fiancé."

So Frank does the noble thing- whacks Joe on the base of his skull with a Colt Peacemaker- ya' know, to knock him out.

Joe comes to a few minutes later- rubs his head- and watches as Frank rides to his forthcoming death.

Are you kidding me here? It's a wonder we didn't all brain each other with heavy instruments.😳
 
So here's a scene we've all seen depicted (or very similar)-

"Joe" is gonna embark on a dangerous task. His friend "Frank" feels he should go instead…… perhaps to save Joe's life for the benefit of his beautiful fiancé."

So Frank does the noble thing- whacks Joe on the base of his skull with a Colt Peacemaker- ya' know, to knock him out.

Joe comes to a few minutes later- rubs his head- and watches as Frank rides to his forthcoming death.

Are you kidding me here? It's a wonder we didn't all brain each other with heavy instruments.😳
Yes , everyone seemed to recover just fine after being wacked in the head. It's kind of like getting hit in the arm or shoulder by a . 45 slug and it being a minor wound. As many times as Matt Dillon was hit in the arm or shoulder he should have been a double amputee.
I did read that Wyatt Earp often used his revolver to knock out a troublemaker. I don't know if any of them suffered permanent damage.
 
That whack on the head with a Peacemaker is a common theme. There must have been alot of bent (or loose) barrels and damaged brains back then.
I wouldn't risk possible damage to the weapon , but it didn't bother Earp. I think I read an account by Bat Masterson who mentioned it.
 
I wouldn't risk possible damage to the weapon , but it didn't bother Earp. I think I read an account by Bat Masterson who mentioned it.
At least Bat Masterson had enough sense to use his cane, I read that's where the nickname "Bat"came from . He "batted" them around.
Talk about a damaged gun. I don't recall which movie it was but there was a scene that made me cringe. There was a guy (a deputy , I think) hammering small nails with the butt up his gun. He was putting up wanted posters or some kind of posters. But I have read some people actually did that because once in while you come across old revolvers wth damaged butts. Plus it seems like a good way to shoot yourself.
 
Last edited:
Yes , everyone seemed to recover just fine after being wacked in the head. It's kind of like getting hit in the arm or shoulder by a . 45 slug and it being a minor wound. As many times as Matt Dillon was hit in the arm or shoulder he should have been a double amputee.
I did read that Wyatt Earp often used his revolver to knock out a troublemaker. I don't know if any of them suffered permanent damage.
Artistic license and time constraints. But then, CPR doesn't work anywhere near as well as medical shows would have you believe, either. You do not quickly bounce back like nothing happened. There tends to be some degree of brain damage - if you come back at all.
 
Artistic license and time constraints. But then, CPR doesn't work anywhere near as well as medical shows would have you believe, either. You do not quickly bounce back like nothing happened. There tends to be some degree of brain damage - if you come back at all.
Understood. Just one of those things that irritated me even as a youngster. I knew that if someone was shot in the shoulder it would not be a good thing and you wouldn't heal up by wearing a sling for a few days.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top