HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Earlier I made the remark that John Wayne's "Commancheros" was laughable. In using that movie as an example who is to blame? The director, the producer, screenwriter, the star, the guy who wrote the novel, etc? One can't really blame the star , John Wayne in this instance, or can he be blamed? He did some of the directing. I personally think he did his career a big disservice by agreeing to star in such a movie. But like the film critic wrote "there is not a moment of seriousness in it, not a detail that isn't performed with a surge of exaggeration, not a character that is credible."It wasn't intended to be a western comedy was it?
The director and the editor, that is who I blame.
It doesn't matter how well a script is written if the director doesn't follow it, and it doesn't matter what the actors do if the editor removes scenes, sentences, etc.
When anyone can pick up the book a movie is based on and it differs greatly from the film, blame the director, the studio (for allowing the script to be messed with) and the editor.
Many times entire scenes are removed due to time restraints; here is an example from one of my favorite flicks;
 
So was Chuck Connors
Connors was also a pro basketball player, played pro baseball, and was a very tall man!
He lived in Palm Springs, one day my dad stopped at a butcher shop, we went inside and Chuck Connors was right ahead of us, I didn't notice him. My dad was in his marshals uniform, when Mr. Connors turned around he said something like, "hello officer" and right away I knew the voice.
I'll never forget he was wearing pants with red and white stripes, made him look even taller than he was!
 
Last edited:
While we talk about "westerns" what about movies about the mountain men?
They were active in the west during the same time frame, movies such as The Mountain Men, with Charleston Heston and Brian Keith, great flick, Jerimiah Johnson, another great movie set in the west after the Civil War.
 
While we talk about "westerns" what about movies about the mountain men?
They were active in the west during the same time frame, movies such as The Mountain Men, with Charleston Heston and Brian Keith, great flick, Jerimiah Johnson, another great movie set in the west after the Civil War.
That one of the movies screw ups. In "Jeremiah Johnson" the mountain men are trapping beaver after the Mexican/American and not the Civil War. The fur trade was already pretty much over way before the Civil War even started.
 
Last edited:
Tom Horn, and the movie Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid were westerns, but set in the early 1900s as the west was beginning to look tame.
One of my favorite actors was Richard Farnsworth, he started out doing bit parts, and stunts. He was in "Comes a Horseman" with James Caan. He finally got a starring role in The Grey Fox, shortly afterwards was diagnosed with a terminal condition and he took himself out.
Another unappreciated actor was "The Clark Gable of Mexico" Pedro Gregorio Armendariz Hastings, because he was from Mexico few Americans remember him, or his son Pedro, however, he was a favorite of John Fords, you will see him in Fort Apache and The Three God Fathers, he was one of 91 people, along with John Wayne, Susan Hayward and Agnes Moorhead whose cancer was attributed to their exposure to radioactivity while working on the film The Conqueror. His last movie was From Russia with Love, he took his own life before the movie was released. Both he and his son portrayed Poncho Villas.
 
Last edited:
That one of the movies screw up. In "Jeremiah Johnson" the mountain men are trapping beaver after the Mexican/American was not the Civil War. The fur trade was already pretty much over way before the Civil War even started.
Jerimiah Johnson was a civil war veteran,

Johnson joined Company H, 2nd Colorado Cavalry, of the Union Army in St. Louis in 1864 as a private and was honorably discharged the following year
 
That one of the movies screw up. In "Jeremiah Johnson" the mountain men are trapping beaver after the Mexican/American was not the Civil War. The fur trade was already pretty much over way before the Civil War even started.
You are right in that his trapping began after the Mexican War. Still during the era of "the Old West" IMO.
Johnson was born in 1824, lived most of his life in the west.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top