HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
@damYankee @Polloco @carptrash @Kurtlg Has anyone here seen The Shootist? Probably. Anyway, if you all remember, the opening is stock footage from earlier Wayne movies as backstory. But this makes for some confusion:

The footage shows Ricky Nelson's Colorado from Rio Bravo. Therefore, does Colorado exist in this film's Canon/Continuity? (I think it says "Rio Bravo Hotel" in the background or something.) Also there's the death of McCleod from El Dorado; does he exist in TS? Also that evil husband from Hondo? The years given in the opening do not add up to the timeline given. Also in Red River he ages, so J.B. Books cannot be Tom Dunson, Cole Thorton, John T. Chance, and Hondo Lane, his possible pseudonyms.

I'm nuts, aren't I?

 
@damYankee @Polloco @carptrash @Kurtlg Has anyone here seen The Shootist? Probably. Anyway, if you all remember, the opening is stock footage from earlier Wayne movies as backstory. But this makes for some confusion:

The footage shows Ricky Nelson's Colorado from Rio Bravo. Therefore, does Colorado exist in this film's Canon/Continuity? (I think it says "Rio Bravo Hotel" in the background or something.) Also there's the death of McCleod from El Dorado; does he exist in TS? Also that evil husband from Hondo? The years given in the opening do not add up to the timeline given. Also in Red River he ages, so J.B. Books cannot be Tom Dunson, Cole Thorton, John T. Chance, and Hondo Lane, his possible pseudonyms.

I'm nuts, aren't I?

At 13 seconds in the clip you posted, Wayne shoots Pedro Gregorio Armendariz out of his saddle. I'm 90% sure that is Pedro.
BTW, that is one of my favorite movies.
 
Last edited:
Jeremiah Johnson was a deserter, wasn't he?
In his time, he was a sailor, scout, soldier, gold seeker, hunter, trapper, woodhawk, whiskey peddler, guide, deputy, constable, and log cabin builder, taking advantage of any source of income-producing labor he could find, he was a deputy sheriff of Coulson Mont. and a city marshal of Red Lodge Mont. during the 1880s, the incident you refer to happened when he struck his commanding officer while on a ship during the Mexican War, I think that qualifies him as a westerner
 
@damYankee @Polloco @carptrash @Kurtlg Has anyone here seen The Shootist? Probably. Anyway, if you all remember, the opening is stock footage from earlier Wayne movies as backstory. But this makes for some confusion:

The footage shows Ricky Nelson's Colorado from Rio Bravo. Therefore, does Colorado exist in this film's Canon/Continuity? (I think it says "Rio Bravo Hotel" in the background or something.) Also there's the death of McCleod from El Dorado; does he exist in TS? Also that evil husband from Hondo? The years given in the opening do not add up to the timeline given. Also in Red River he ages, so J.B. Books cannot be Tom Dunson, Cole Thorton, John T. Chance, and Hondo Lane, his possible pseudonyms.

I'm nuts, aren't I?

That evil husband in Hondo is non other than the actor , Leo Gordon, that was referred to earlier.
 
Here's a movie I had forgotten about: "Ten Who Dared," about John Wesley Powell's 1869 expedition down the Colorado River and through the Grand Canyon. Powell had been a Civil War officer and lost most of his arm at Shiloh. He was a geologist, did a lot of exploration after the war, and ended heading up the US Geological Survey.

I don't remember this as a fantastic movie, but I did enjoy watching it for the scenery and action shots, and for my interest in Powell. I think I remember that they fitted up actor John Beal with a hook on his arm.

Poster_of_the_movie_Ten_Who_Dared_FairUseWikimedia.jpg


Powell during the war:

John_Wesley_Powell_uniform_wikimedia.jpg


ARB
 
Here's a movie I had forgotten about: "Ten Who Dared," about John Wesley Powell's 1869 expedition down the Colorado River and through the Grand Canyon. Powell had been a Civil War officer and lost most of his arm at Shiloh. He was a geologist, did a lot of exploration after the war, and ended heading up the US Geological Survey.

I don't remember this as a fantastic movie, but I did enjoy watching it for the scenery and action shots, and for my interest in Powell. I think I remember that they fitted up actor John Beal with a hook on his arm.

View attachment 495036

Powell during the war:

View attachment 495037

ARB

View attachment 495035
Disney, eh? Big fan of Walt's life and work myself, but never heard of this movie! He also did The Great Locomotive Chase.
 
Last edited:
Disney, eh? Big fan of Walt's life and work myself, but never heard of this movie! He also did The Great Train Robbery.
I haven't seen the Great Train (locomotive?) Chase in about 60 years. Wasn't Fess Parker cast as a Yankee in that film or am I not remembering clearly? Maybe I got my characters mixed up.
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen the Great Train (locomotive?) Chase in about 60 years. Wasn't Fess Parker cast as a Yankee in that film or am I not remembering clearly? Maybe I got my characters mixed up.
Yes he was. He had the accent, his natural voice ,in Daniel Boone , but none of his family did. He also had a small part in the science fiction movie Them ( about giant ants) that had James Arness as one of the stars.
 
I think the second battle of Adobe Walls would make a great movie, Bat Masterson was involved in the fighting, a large group of Plains Indians attacked the small trading outpost, but it just so happened that a group of buffalo hunters were laying over, and armed with .50 cal. Buffalo Guns, In fact Billy Dixon's life would make a great movie or series

 
A typical western seems to be a combination of a time and place. But not always, look at Vera Cruz, Man from Snowy River or Quigley Down Under, North To Alaska, etc. Most westerns scenarios are right after the Civil War and occur in the western or southwestern states. There were exceptions, Darrin MacGavin's "Riverboat" was a good example of this not always being the rule.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top