HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I watch Ride the High Country a few weeks ago. I was disappointed, especially since everybody says it's the "greatest Western ever". It's too short to know the old guys well, and to avoid a spoiler, Judd's "motivation" is out of character with what little we know about him, especially his waffling at the end. And what kind of ending was that?! there are much better "death of the West" movies. Joel and Randy are always great, though!
My brother, who is a serious movie person, and I were just talking about this film yesterday, he really liked it. I have it on a Western DVD collection and think I'll watch it today and present an opinion later.
 
My brother, who is a serious movie person, and I were just talking about this film yesterday, he really liked it. I have it on a Western DVD collection and think I'll watch it today and present an opinion later.
Tell me how you feel! I'd like to give it another try someday.
 
Can anyone evaluate (non-spoilers) the following:

Saddle the Wind
I just finished "Saddle the Wind" and found it to be a very satisfying and intense viewing. I saw it as a kid 60+ years ago and also at that time had the theme song by Julie London on a 45. I am not a very big Robert Taylor fan, for on screen and off screen reasons but John Cassavetes as his psycho brother makes up for whatever Taylor lacks. Whereas Ride the High Country has a sort of light hearted tone to it, Saddle the Wind does not , hitting on all the Western themes, cattlemen vs barbed wire, CSA vets vs Union ones, respect and self-respect and more. I suggest that if you get the chance to see it, do so, and let me know what you think.
10 years ago I started going to garage sales and estate sales and library sales and thrift stores buying DVDs for, typically, a $1 each. I now have about 250 Westerns and my daughter, who I love and respect, thinks I have a hoarding problem. But enough of that, I have to run.
 
I just finished "Saddle the Wind" and found it to be a very satisfying and intense viewing. I saw it as a kid 60+ years ago and also at that time had the theme song by Julie London on a 45. I am not a very big Robert Taylor fan, for on screen and off screen reasons but John Cassavetes as his psycho brother makes up for whatever Taylor lacks. Whereas Ride the High Country has a sort of light hearted tone to it, Saddle the Wind does not , hitting on all the Western themes, cattlemen vs barbed wire, CSA vets vs Union ones, respect and self-respect and more. I suggest that if you get the chance to see it, do so, and let me know what you think.
10 years ago I started going to garage sales and estate sales and library sales and thrift stores buying DVDs for, typically, a $1 each. I now have about 250 Westerns and my daughter, who I love and respect, thinks I have a hoarding problem. But enough of that, I have to run.
Sounds good. I like those weird, deep CinemaScopes.

I feel the opposite about RTHC. It's too unnerving for a Sctott/McCrea adventure. I like dark westerns like Unforgiven, but I expect different from the fun guys. Wayne too.
 
Sounds good. I like those weird, deep CinemaScopes.

I feel the opposite about RTHC. It's too unnerving for a Sctott/McCrea adventure. I like dark westerns like Unforgiven, but I expect different from the fun guys. Wayne too.
Saddle the Wind is definitely on the dark side, probably not as much as Unforgiven, but closer to it than any Duke or RTHC film.
 
Watched "Streets of Laredo" with James Garner last night. I realize it was based on a novel by it makes you wonder why Larry McMurtry would put such an inaccuracy as the shooting and hanging of Judge Roy Bean in it. That never happened. And the title was very misleading. Other than that it was pretty good. I've always been a James Garner fan , except in his "comedy westerns".

17126027820272116046971190822220.jpg
 
Watched "Streets of Laredo" with James Garner last night. I realize it was based on a novel by it makes you wonder why Larry McMurtry would put such an inaccuracy as the shooting and hanging of Judge Roy Bean in it. That never happened. And the title was very misleading. Other than that it was pretty good. I've always been a James Garner fan , except in his "comedy westerns".

View attachment 503938
I like Garner
 
Watched "Streets of Laredo" with James Garner last night. I realize it was based on a novel by it makes you wonder why Larry McMurtry would put such an inaccuracy as the shooting and hanging of Judge Roy Bean in it. That never happened. And the title was very misleading. Other than that it was pretty good. I've always been a James Garner fan , except in his "comedy westerns".

View attachment 503938
Not a bad sequel. He's much better in Support Your Local Sheriff.
 
I recently finished all of the Ranown Westerns, and loved every one. Decision at Sundown stands out the most.

@Polloco Thanks for inspiring me to revisit Randy! I originally though he was a bit of a bore (based mostly on the dull Albuquerque and less dull Ride Shotgun).

Again, being that I'm in my Twenties, does it surprise you I'm into all this?
 
Not a bad sequel. He's much better in Support Your Local Sheriff.
There was some good actors in that movie. James Garner, Jack Elam, etc (and Walter Brennan) are hard to beat. Comedy Westerns as a rule overdid the comedy. There weren't too many funny incidents in the Old West. As far as actors, I find today's actors and actresses sorely lacking in "star power".
 
My top ten list (revised):

10. 3:10 to Yuma (2007)
9. The Ox-Bow Incident
8. The Good the Bad and the Ugly (the only Leone I like)
7. Unforgiven
6. High Plains Drifter
5. High Noon
4. The Searchers
3. The Shootist
2. Lonesome Dove
1. The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
My top 10 list would look similar but 2 of those would have to go in order to put "Once Upon A Time In the West" and "Josie Wales" on that list. Make that 3 scratched from your list. "Quigley Down Under" would be on that list too.Oh I might make that 4 , True Grit (the remake) just may make that list.
 
Surprised Rooster Cogburn isn't on more lists, always liked the interaction between Hepburn and Wayne. Don't see it really being inferior to true grit, not knocking true grit.
 
I had mentioned four a long while back, but not "High Noon." I saw it when it first came out one rainy night at a drive in theater outside Lancaster Pennsylvania. I was only seven years old but I was in the back seat and my mom and dad in the front and I remember my dad running the wipers once in a while. I think it was in his 1950 Dodge. Since then I have seen that movie countless times. It never seems to get old. Gary Cooper, as a town marshal at his very best. Grace Kelly was heart warming. I might watch it again sometime.
 
My top 10 list would look similar but 2 of those would have to go in order to put "Once Upon A Time In the West" and "Josie Wales" on that list. Make that 3 scratched from your list. "Quigley Down Under" would be on that list too.Oh I might make that 4 , True Grit (the remake) just may make that list.
I replaced High Plains Drifter with The Gunfighter (1950).
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top