HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
I noticed he liked to imitate Harry Carey too. His stance while holding his elbow at the very end of "The Searchers" is dead on.
Wayne was paying tribute to his close friend, he and the entire cast were in on the tribute, that doesn't mean he was copying the man. When Wayne was a young bit player in Hollywood he befriended Earp, from all accounts he rather idolized Earp.
 
I think it was on a Word on Westerns video where it was told that Murphy carried 2 Government Colt . 45s and once pulled them on some one who had irritated him.
I wouldn't doubt that story, and I would not have wanted get on his bad side. There is another Hollywood personality who was famous for shooting things, was, believe it or not, Merv Griffin, who loved trap and skeet shooting and had a range in his back yard, his his neighbors constantly complained, but Merv was probably the richest man in show business when he passed away, worth way over a billion, so he pretty much did what he wanted. He was also a pall bearer at Ronald Reagan's funeral. I heard he had an incredible gun collection,
 
Curious as to how the Inspector Morse books compare to the series. Was John Thaw's portrayal true to the books ?
Pardon me while I go off on a siding to answer this question.

I would say that John Thaw's portrayal was quite true to the books. My perception is that the intensity of certain characteristics was toned down a bit for TV. There's even more drinking in the books. He's even more interested in women (not that he's more successful with them) in the books. He can be nastier to Lewis in the books, but Lewis also tends to push back a bit more in the books. When you get to The Remorseless Day, whether by book or by TV episode, it will be a hard read/watch because Colin Dexter and/or John Thaw has really gotten you invested in the character. Again, that's my perception; your mileage may vary.

Just so we can stay true to the Civil War nature of this site, there is an Inspector Morse book/TV episode, The Wench is Dead, where Morse tries to "solve" an Oxford case from the mid-1800s while he's laid up in hospital. A fellow patient gives him a book on the case. When Morse reads it, he's convinced that there was a miscarriage of justice and he sets out to prove it from hospital.

I wanted to get the book linked below, but there was only one copy in the consortium and the owning library withdrew it before I got around to putting it on hold. I may have to ask my interlibrary loan librarian to get it for me elsewhere. It might be of interest to you, @Kurtlg , as it sounds like it might give you a fuller, more concrete answer to your question.

https://www.amazon.com/Complete-Inspector-Morse-David-Bishop/dp/1905287666?tag=civilwartalkc-20

Back to the main line now. :smile:
 
Pardon me while I go off on a siding to answer this question.

I would say that John Thaw's portrayal was quite true to the books. My perception is that the intensity of certain characteristics was toned down a bit for TV. There's even more drinking in the books. He's even more interested in women (not that he's more successful with them) in the books. He can be nastier to Lewis in the books, but Lewis also tends to push back a bit more in the books. When you get to The Remorseless Day, whether by book or by TV episode, it will be a hard read/watch because Colin Dexter and/or John Thaw has really gotten you invested in the character. Again, that's my perception; your mileage may vary.

Just so we can stay true to the Civil War nature of this site, there is an Inspector Morse book/TV episode, The Wench is Dead, where Morse tries to "solve" an Oxford case from the mid-1800s while he's laid up in hospital. A fellow patient gives him a book on the case. When Morse reads it, he's convinced that there was a miscarriage of justice and he sets out to prove it from hospital.

I wanted to get the book linked below, but there was only one copy in the consortium and the owning library withdrew it before I got around to putting it on hold. I may have to ask my interlibrary loan librarian to get it for me elsewhere. It might be of interest to you, @Kurtlg , as it sounds like it might give you a fuller, more concrete answer to your question.

https://www.amazon.com/Complete-Inspector-Morse-David-Bishop/dp/1905287666?tag=civilwartalkc-20

Back to the main line now. :smile:
The entire trilogy is great! Especially loved Endeavor.
 
Pardon me while I go off on a siding to answer this question.

I would say that John Thaw's portrayal was quite true to the books. My perception is that the intensity of certain characteristics was toned down a bit for TV. There's even more drinking in the books. He's even more interested in women (not that he's more successful with them) in the books. He can be nastier to Lewis in the books, but Lewis also tends to push back a bit more in the books. When you get to The Remorseless Day, whether by book or by TV episode, it will be a hard read/watch because Colin Dexter and/or John Thaw has really gotten you invested in the character. Again, that's my perception; your mileage may vary.

Just so we can stay true to the Civil War nature of this site, there is an Inspector Morse book/TV episode, The Wench is Dead, where Morse tries to "solve" an Oxford case from the mid-1800s while he's laid up in hospital. A fellow patient gives him a book on the case. When Morse reads it, he's convinced that there was a miscarriage of justice and he sets out to prove it from hospital.

I wanted to get the book linked below, but there was only one copy in the consortium and the owning library withdrew it before I got around to putting it on hold. I may have to ask my interlibrary loan librarian to get it for me elsewhere. It might be of interest to you, @Kurtlg , as it sounds like it might give you a fuller, more concrete answer to your question.

https://www.amazon.com/Complete-Inspector-Morse-David-Bishop/dp/1905287666?tag=civilwartalkc-20

Back to the main line now. :smile:
I remember that episode. Thanks for your response. I liked the series Inspector Lewis as well. Now back to the Civil War
 
Watched Tom hanks news of the world today.........is it a western?

It's set in reconstruction west.......but didn't strike me particularly western. The genre ussually has a clear good/bad theme, which I didn't really see..............
 
Watched Tom hanks news of the world today.........is it a western?

It's set in reconstruction west.......but didn't strike me particularly western. The genre ussually has a clear good/bad theme, which I didn't really see..............
The former Confederates and adoptive German family were depicted as low lifes. The former Confederates were depicted as stereotypical evil outlaws. Not a great movie.
 
The former Confederates and adoptive German family were depicted as low lifes. The former Confederates were depicted as stereotypical evil outlaws. Not a great movie.
But at a newspaper reading it pointed out Union was doing little but punishing southerners as well, I assume the true "bad guys" in the movie were the Kiowa who killed the girls parents and kidnapped her...........it did strike me more anti everything then pro anything.........
 
Presently watching a movie on TV. Noah Berry Jr. is in it.A turned up brim of his hat must have been a trademark of his. I dont recall seeing him in too many western movies with a straight brim on his hat.
 
I watch Ride the High Country a few weeks ago. I was disappointed, especially since everybody says it's the "greatest Western ever". It's too short to know the old guys well, and to avoid a spoiler, Judd's "motivation" is out of character with what little we know about him, especially his waffling at the end. And what kind of ending was that?! there are much better "death of the West" movies. Joel and Randy are always great, though!

 
Polloco: About Duryea, I don't think he played very many good guys. In his film noir movies he was famous for slapping women around if I'm not mistaken. I have a DVD of one of his movies where he really roughs up Lizabeth Scott a few times.

I like his last name though.

John
 
Polloco: About Duryea, I don't think he played very many good guys. In his film noir movies he was famous for slapping women around if I'm not mistaken. I have a DVD of one of his movies where he really roughs up Lizabeth Scott a few times.

I like his last name though.

John
I do recall him playing a "good guy" once but that was in the TV series Wagon Train and not a movie.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top