Stonewall Stonewall's death

@TCC Out of curiosity what did your book mean by Booth "taking his life"? I'm assuming you meant he killed this Hemmingstad dude.

View attachment 534046
Thanks for this. I had missed the fact that in addition to killing Jackson by shooting him in the back so that Jackson was wounded in both arms but not the back, it looks like Hemmingstad went AWOL from his unit to (unwisely) meet Booth where, even though Stonewall apparently was still alive, Booth executed him, which Jackson might have done anyway for desertion.
 
Thanks for this. I had missed the fact that in addition to killing Jackson by shooting him in the back so that Jackson was wounded in both arms but not the back, it looks like Hemmingstad went AWOL from his unit to (unwisely) meet Booth where, even though Stonewall apparently was still alive, Booth executed him, which Jackson might have done anyway for desertion.
You've got a great sense of humor!
 
Thanks for this. I had missed the fact that in addition to killing Jackson by shooting him in the back so that Jackson was wounded in both arms but not the back, it looks like Hemmingstad went AWOL from his unit to (unwisely) meet Booth where, even though Stonewall apparently was still alive, Booth executed him, which Jackson might have done anyway for desertion.
Somehow it makes more sense and less sense.
 
Somehow it makes more sense and less sense.
That depends on whether the meds have been upped or lowered. I'm intrigued by what an incredibly bad shot Hemmingstad was.

On shows like Chicago PD and FBI, by the way, these are the sorts of incidents where they "look at the family" Keep in mind that Stonewall's b-in-law was on the outs with Lee at the time and Stonewall was Marse Robert's "right arm".
 
That depends on whether the meds have been upped or lowered. I'm intrigued by what an incredibly bad shot Hemmingstad was.

On shows like Chicago PD and FBI, by the way, these are the sorts of incidents where they "look at the family" Keep in mind that Stonewall's b-in-law was on the outs with Lee at the time and Stonewall was Marse Robert's "right arm".
So Lee wanted to get rid of Jack? But why did Booth kill him? Was Booth involved with Lee? Were they in an affair? Where does Lincoln-woman come in?

 
So Lee wanted to get rid of Jack? But why did Booth kill him? Was Booth involved with Lee? Were they in an affair? Where does Lincoln-woman come in?

Jeez - Please follow along. DH Hill (Stonewall's b-in-law) was on the outs with Lee by May 1863. Lee viewed Stonewall as his "right arm". What better way for Harvey to get at Lee than by offing his "right arm"? No need to let family get in the way. The fact that one poster noted awhile ago that there is no record of a Hemmingstad ever existing is just proof of how the archivists have been in on the whole Booth coverup for 160 years.
 
Jeez - Please follow along. DH Hill (Stonewall's b-in-law) was on the outs with Lee by May 1863. Lee viewed Stonewall as his "right arm". What better way for Harvey to get at Lee than by offing his "right arm"? No need to let family get in the way. The fact that one poster noted awhile ago that there is no record of a Hemmingstad ever existing is just proof of how the archivists have been in on the whole Booth coverup for 160 years.
There's a swilling sound in my ears. I think it's my gray matter.
 
A more important question is what kind of gun Booth used against Hemmingstad. Was it a Colt, derringer, musket, repeating rifle, or a Gatling gun? I think that last one is the most possible. I can see it now. He probably used that mounted one from Django, set in 1866.

22+Django+3.jpg
 
A more important question is what kind of gun he used. Was it a Colt, derringer, musket, repeating rifle, or a Gatling gun? I think that last one is the most possible. I can see it now. He probably used that mounted one from Django, set in 1866.

View attachment 534250
I'm confused - as I am on a lot of these type of threads. Who are we talking about here? Booth, Jackson, Stonewall, Hill, or Lee. Or all 5 of them? Hoo boy these threads really do get to me. :help:
 
I'm confused - as I am on a lot of these type of threads. Who are we talking about here? Booth, Jackson, Stonewall, Hill, or Lee. Or all 5 of them? Hoo boy these threads really do get to me. :help:
THAT'S IT!!!

They all are one guy using aliases. Thanks! problem solved!

Either that or he's a Navajo Skinwalker. Maybe the Skinwalkers were controlling the War.

 
I'm confused - as I am on a lot of these type of threads. Who are we talking about here? Booth, Jackson, Stonewall, Hill, or Lee. Or all 5 of them? Hoo boy these threads really do get to me. :help:
This one is hard enough to follow without paying close attention. It's a good idea to get it straight before working in the Lincoln Assassination/Abe and Jeff Were Half-Brothers/Stanton's Little [ ]/Thomas Lincoln's Anatomy threads. They're all seamlessly related but take it slowly ....
 
This one is hard enough to follow without paying close attention. It's a good idea to get it straight before working in the Lincoln Assassination/Abe and Jeff Were Half-Brothers/Stanton's Little [ ]/Thomas Lincoln's Anatomy threads. They're all seamlessly related but take it slowly ....
You couldn't resist Stanton's Little again.
 
Whenever he shows up again, I have made a wheel to see what response will be:

Clueless
You're Wrong
You're Stupid
Lost the Evidence
Don't Answer

Screenshot 2025-01-04 1.39.16 PM.png


Looks like we're clueless! I was betting on Don't Answer!

Screenshot 2025-01-04 1.39.43 PM.png
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top