Served for Confederacy and Union

This is a new one for me:

Joseph N. Baker served in the Confederate Army in Arkansas for 30 days at the beginning of the war in Captain Perry Clayton's Company of Infantry Volunteers in 1861. In April, 1864, he enlisted in the 2nd Arkansas Cavalry (Union) in Batesville, AR.
I'm guessing Joseph was a Union man to begin with. I had relatives who changed sides in East Tennessee. I had relatives who migrated from East Tennessee to Northwest Arkansas before the war. They served in the Union 1st Arkansas Infantry.
 
This is a new one for me:

Joseph N. Baker served in the Confederate Army in Arkansas for 30 days at the beginning of the war in Captain Perry Clayton's Company of Infantry Volunteers in 1861. In April, 1864, he enlisted in the 2nd Arkansas Cavalry (Union) in Batesville, AR.
Defection were common during the ACW almost the entirety of the Second Florida Cavalry Union were ex Confederate soldiers.
Leftyhunter
 
This is a new one for me:

Joseph N. Baker served in the Confederate Army in Arkansas for 30 days at the beginning of the war in Captain Perry Clayton's Company of Infantry Volunteers in 1861. In April, 1864, he enlisted in the 2nd Arkansas Cavalry (Union) in Batesville, AR.
" Galvanized Yankee's "
 
One of the vets I researched in the cemetery where I volunteered for many years was from eastern Tennessee and had joined the state troops at the outbreak of the war as a lieutenant (before they got officially incorporated into the Confederate army). When the Tennessee troops were about to be officially made Confederate he resigned his commission. A month later he joined a Union regiment as a private.

After the war he put in for a Union pension, which he got. In his pension file there's a lot of documentation including a letter from his brother saying he didn't think his brother should get a pension because he joined the confederates. I imagine in all the hoopla in eastern Tennessee between the pro- and anti-secessionists he originally joined up to maybe avoid some local conflict but when it got to where he would actually have to go fight he did an about face.

The pension rules didn't say one couldn't have served the Confederacy; they just required that one had served for a certain number of days during the war and had an honorable discharge. It's a bit complicated as the rules for pensions changed several times but the point is that confederates certainly could have jumped ship and got a Union pension.
 
One of the vets I researched in the cemetery where I volunteered for many years was from eastern Tennessee and had joined the state troops at the outbreak of the war as a lieutenant (before they got officially incorporated into the Confederate army). When the Tennessee troops were about to be officially made Confederate he resigned his commission. A month later he joined a Union regiment as a private.

After the war he put in for a Union pension, which he got. In his pension file there's a lot of documentation including a letter from his brother saying he didn't think his brother should get a pension because he joined the confederates. I imagine in all the hoopla in eastern Tennessee between the pro- and anti-secessionists he originally joined up to maybe avoid some local conflict but when it got to where he would actually have to go fight he did an about face.

The pension rules didn't say one couldn't have served the Confederacy; they just required that one had served for a certain number of days during the war and had an honorable discharge. It's a bit complicated as the rules for pensions changed several times but the point is that confederates certainly could have jumped ship and go signed t a Union pension.
Some East Tennesseans signed on believing they would serve locally. When that proved to be false, they changed allegiance, which was probably for the Union to begin with.
 
Do you think they drew 2 pensions ?

Probably not considering the Union pension was the much better of the two.

The Confederate government didn't exist to pay the pension and the US government wasn't going to. Some states did so for disabled confederate veterans, widows, and laborers decades after the war.
 
The State of Georgia first began giving pensions to Confederate soldiers who had lost a limb in 1877. The law was gradually broadened to include soldiers who were disabled due to their military service and to indigent soldiers. Indigent widows of Confederate soldiers who died in service or as a result of their service began receiving pensions in 1890. Pension funds also paid medical expenses for final illnesses and funeral expenses for indigent soldiers and widows.
South Carolina began granting pensions to needy Confederate veterans and their widows in 1887, but initially limited the pensions to veterans who were disabled by loss of limb or other injury during the war and widows of soldiers or sailors who had died in service. Both had to meet means tests, which were made even more restrictive in 1900. Responding to a provision of the 1895 state constitution, the General Assembly in 1896 expanded eligibility to poor uninjured veterans over 60 and poor widows over 60 and ushered in a major growth period for both pension funding and the number of applicants. Revisions enacted in 1900 refined the classification and procedures for pensions, defining a system that would remain in force until 1919. Unfortunately, few applications for Confederate pensions under any of the pre-1919 acts survive either at the state or local level.

Act No. 176, 1919 S.C. Acts 275 established a Confederate Pension Department under the direction of a commissioner and a seven-member board and required all existing pensioners to reapply. The state board appointed a three-member board for each county to approve applications from local residents. Eligible pensioners included all veterans and widows over the age of sixty who had married veterans before 1890. The state pension board set the compensation and adjudicated any disputes forwarded from the county boards. The General Assembly provided $500,000 to pay for pensions. Changes the following year (Act No. 609, 1920 S.C. Acts 1099) eliminated the state board, named the comptroller general as pension commissioner, and authorized the local veterans camp to hear appeals of each county board's decision.

Act No. 63, 1923 S.C. Acts 107 allowed African Americans who had served at least six months as cooks, servants, or attendants to apply for a pension. Then in 1924, apparently because there were too many applications, the act was amended to eliminate all laborers, teamsters, and non-South Carolinians by extending eligibility only to South Carolina residents who had served the state for at least six months as "body servants or male camp cooks."

The legislature dropped the age of eligibility for widows to 55 in 1920, to 50 in 1921, and to 45 in 1930. Under the 1920 amendment, widows were eligible if they had been married by 1900, but a 1929 amendment extended eligibility to widows who had been married at least ten years. The state continued to pay Confederate widow pensions until the last widow died in 1990.
 
Last edited:
Alabama provided pensions to disabled or indigent Confederate veterans and their widows, with programs beginning as early as 1867 and expanding significantly in the 1890s.
 
This probably needs its own thread, but it's so interesting that I will put it here.
Irene Triplett
(1930–2020) was the last recipient of an American Civil War pension, receiving $73.13 monthly from the Department of Veterans Affairs. She died on May 31, 2020, aged 90, ending a 155-year legacy of payments. She qualified as the daughter of Moses Triplett, a Confederate-turned-Union soldier who married late in life
 
Reading South Carolina pension history it's interesting to see that the state offered pensions to Africans in 1923 who served during the Civil War. There were so many "black confederates" that the law was changed in 1924 to only include man servants and cooks.
 
This probably needs its own thread, but it's so interesting that I will put it here.
Irene Triplett
(1930–2020) was the last recipient of an American Civil War pension, receiving $73.13 monthly from the Department of Veterans Affairs. She died on May 31, 2020, aged 90, ending a 155-year legacy of payments. She qualified as the daughter of Moses Triplett, a Confederate-turned-Union soldier who married late in life
As you can see there were none if any significant Cost of living adjustments. 73 dollars a month won't get you far in 2020
 
This probably needs its own thread, but it's so interesting that I will put it here.
Irene Triplett
(1930–2020) was the last recipient of an American Civil War pension, receiving $73.13 monthly from the Department of Veterans Affairs. She died on May 31, 2020, aged 90, ending a 155-year legacy of payments. She qualified as the daughter of Moses Triplett, a Confederate-turned-Union soldier who married late in life
 
So she was his daughter, she must have had some kind of disability to receive this. By the name, she must have never married.
 
There ain't nothing that ain't already done been talked about…..
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top