There is a consistent "fault-finding" with new weapons, even when the weapon is absolutely an improvement. Take the Armstrong guns, which were a huge leap in effective firepower, demolishing fortifications at unheard of ranges. The breech mechanism was more complicated than a muzzloader, and there were initially minor issues with the vent pieces (solved with a few years of adoption by improved materials). However, this was a worthwhile trade-off for a massive increase in effective battle range and effect.
With ACW era repeaters, there's a question about were they actually worth it. Whilst at close range they certainly did have a greater effect on target, the trade-off was an anemic bullet not much better than a pistol round and a lack of reliability. When breechloading rifles like the Snider and Trapdoor became available, the repeaters advantages disappeared, because their rate-of-fire was not greater than these weapons. Hence it was a "no-brainer" to abandon them in the late 1860's as obselescent. With the first full power bolt-action rifle (the Lebel) it had the same problem, because rounds were loaded individually.
Oddly, the US Navy's Model 1885 Remington-Lee rifle really pointed the way forward, with detachable box magazines...