Elennsar
Colonel
- Joined
- May 14, 2008
- Location
- California
Yes, I don't make claims to his being a military genius, but he's a forgotten commander in many ways. Remember also, he was just as new to corps command as Meade was to army command, having replaced Meade as commander of the V Corps on Meade's promotion to army command. Sykes had commanded the Regulars for most of the war and was most associated with them.
No argument there. I'd rank him a B for division command - nothing spellbinding enough for an A, but the Regulars being a byword for dependable merits at least that much.
And while not known for being quick to take initiative, that's not necessarily a point against a division commander. His job is to execute, not originate, plans for action.
When Meade reorganized the Army of the Potomac and Sykes was displaced, Charles Wainwright wrote, "A number of general officers are relieved from duty with this army; Corps commanders Sykes, French, and Newton, and Brigade Commanders Kenly, Spinola, and Meredith. The first is the only one I should think any loss."
Wainright was an opinionated sort of fellow to put it politely, but I agree with him here. Kenly might have been okay, but the other four? The army was better off without them.