January 1862

[MikeyB]

With all of the benefits of retrospection, as the Union headed into 1862, what was the better option - Peninsula or Overland?
mike

 

[Generic Username]

With all of the benefits of retrospection, as the Union headed into 1862, what was the better option - Peninsula or Overland?
mike

Depends on what your goals are. Confederate victory or shortest possible war? Overland. Want the Union to have a solid shot at winning, albeit at a longer conflict? Peninsula.