Gettysburg 2016: After Action Reports

dsc04543-jpg.jpg


Two more links to places visited following Gettysburg, both near Shepherdstown, West Virginia:
http://civilwartalk.com/threads/the-battle-of-shepherdstown-september-20-1862.127673/
http://civilwartalk.com/threads/elmwood-confederate-cemetery-shepherdstown-west-virginia.127652/

dsc04558-jpg.jpg
 
Although Taylor's Louisiana Brigade (the largest in Jackson's Army of the Valley) was technically a part of Ewell's Division, there were at lest two or three occasions where it operated directly under Jackson's orders: In the prelude to Front Royal Taylor was part of the erratic movements back-and-forth through New Market Gap; at Winchester Ewell with only Trimble's Brigade was isolated by thick fog on the extreme right while Taylor was sent to the far left by Jackson to outflank Banks; and later at Cross Keys on June 8 Jackson withdrew Taylor's Brigade from Ewell and sent it towards threatened Port Republic to act as army reserve. (Later that day it returned to Ewell after the fighting was over.) In the June 9 battle at Port Republic Ewell for a time remained at the ford overseeing the crossing of the rest of his division while Taylor was again moving through thick woods to outflank the Coaling.

Ewell first came under Jackson's orders in May during the McDowell operation when he crossed the Blue Ridge to watch Banks at Strasburg in Jackson's absence. He remained part of what was then called Jackson's Command - not yet the Second Corps - until he was wounded at Brawner's Farm on August 28, 1862, so it was more like only four months. As for Johnson, since he was outranked by Stonewall, I think it fair to say that for at least a few days until his wounding at McDowell he was under Jackson's command.

I'm certainly grateful that Taylor served under Jackson..his memoir has the single most colorful description of Stonewall, including the (probably) apocryphal story of the constant lemon-sucking. He also described Little Sorrel as a "sorry chestnut with a shambling gait." He had most likely never seen a pacer down in Louisiana. Little Sorrel got some kind of revenge for the insult, though, outliving Taylor by nearly seven years.
 
In Search of Melancholy

My dad was a big proponent of you could never appreciate how good you have it unless you understand how bad it could be. Case in point: when in Italy, I would go out to the countryside where the old rusticas (harvest cottages) lay in ruins. If you know where to look, you can still find bullet holes from WWII. I used to boost up to put my fingers in the holes. At the time, there were still some survivors who could recount the Occupation and the psychological scars that were still evident. Even though we would run off to the beach hours later and find reason to laugh, I never shied away from melancholy.

During our recent Gettysburg excursion, I had a nagging feeling that I was not fully grasping the devastation that had taken place on those hallowed grounds. I felt that there was a depth missing from my experience, even though I had been lavished with friendship, food, and an educational experience of a lifetime, but yet, the visceral aspect had yet to be explored. I was fortunate enough that one more day of Gettysburg remained, and it turned out to be one of the most important of the trip.

Normally, one would be dismayed to be awoken by the roar of a monsoon rain, but on this last day: I welcomed it as it would set the tone perfectly for my pursuit of a deeper darker experience. Besides, being well stocked with brolly & slicker was a near guarantee that the rain would cease….and it did.

The night before, @PeterT had recounted a story told to him regarding Gettysburg Battle patients who were set by the creek that divides the Farnworth Restaurant from the Farnsworth House (apparently the house was overrun with patients). When the rains abruptly came after the final Battle of Gettysburg, the story goes that the creek swelled to a raging torrent and carried these patients to their death by drowning. Staring into that narrow shallow waterway, it was difficult to comprehend the watery fingers of death reaching out from below the banks and claiming their hapless victims.

In the morning, after exploring Devil's Den by daybreak, we decided to take a look at Little Round Top. The place looked like something out of a medieval fantasy, as it was shrouded in tufts of fog, light rain, and completely void of the din of modernity. To my surprise, @Frums pointed down to a glen of trees and noted that this had been a temporary burial ground (re-buried elsewhere at a later date). At closer inspection, we could actually read the words spelled out by rocks: GRAVES. There were more gravesites deeper in the glen, but on this day it was too muddy to explore, so we retreated to the car for our next stop.

The Seminary cupola had always been on the bucket list, as we needed to get @PeterT his close-up in his starring role as Sam Elliot playing Buford. He – Peter T – was ready for his star turn, as we had hilariously practiced reciting lines to Gettysburg (the movie) the night before at the Farnsworth Restaurant. Unfortunately, access to the cupola was limited, so that Peter T would have to take the tour at a time when I would be on my way to the airport, so we decided to explore the Seminary Museum in the interim.

The Seminary Museum is an intimate experience of four floors, six rooms each with a theme that carries throughout the floor and is further broken down by room. It was here that I found what I had come for: The despair, destruction, and desperation of war. I read a passage describing the inconceivable carnage of the Pickett's Charge Battlefield – curiosity rendering scarred memories upon the hapless author. Photographs of battle wounds that I still cannot get out of my head were on display – the empty eyes of the soldiers stuck in my psyche. A typical hospital room on display viewed through glass shows a couple of fortunate officers had beds….the rest of the patients were strewn about on the floor. I had my fill. THIS is what the Battle of Gettysburg was, and now I fully understood it. My experience was complete.

As my plane rolled down the runway, I looked over to the right, and on the other side of the fence, four coyotes were escorting our plane as it rolled out. Now, Native American myth states that when coyote crosses your path (this being close enough) you are supposed to immediate turn back and abandon your journey, as something bad was ahead. Not today: I had my Good Luck Suitcase and I was feeling confident :smile:
 
Last edited:
In Search of Melancholy

My dad was a big proponent of you could never appreciate how good you have it unless you understand how bad it could be. Case in point: when in Italy, I would go out to the countryside where the old rusticas (harvest cottages) lay in ruins. If you know where to look, you can still find bullet holes from WWII. I used to boost up to put my fingers in the holes. At the time, there were still some survivors who could recount the Occupation and the psychological scars that were still evident. Even though we would run off to the beach hours later and find reason to laugh, I never shied away from melancholy.

During our recent Gettysburg excursion, I had a nagging feeling that I was not fully grasping the devastation that had taken place on those hallowed grounds. I felt that there was a depth missing from my experience, even though I had been lavished with friendship, food, and an educational experience of a lifetime, but yet, the visceral aspect had yet to be explored. I was fortunate enough that one more day of Gettysburg remained, and it turned out to be one of the most important of the trip.

Normally, one would be dismayed to be awoken by the roar of a monsoon rain, but on this last day: I welcomed it as it would set the tone perfectly for my pursuit of a deeper darker experience. Besides, being well stocked with brolly & slicker was a near guarantee that the rain would cease….and it did.

The night before, @PeterT had recounted a story told to him regarding Gettysburg Battle patients who were set by the creek that divides the Farnworth Restaurant from the Farnsworth House (apparently the house was overrun with patients). When the rains abruptly came after the final Battle of Gettysburg, the story goes that the creek swelled to a raging torrent and carried these patients to their death by drowning. Staring into that narrow shallow waterway, it was difficult to comprehend the watery fingers of death reaching out from below the banks and claiming their hapless victims.

In the morning, after exploring Devil's Den by daybreak, we decided to take a look at Little Round Top. The place looked like something out of a medieval fantasy, as it was shrouded in tufts of fog, light rain, and completely void of the din of modernity. To my surprise, @Frums pointed down to a glen of trees and noted that this had been a temporary burial ground (re-buried elsewhere at a later date). At closer inspection, we could actually read the words spelled out by rocks: GRAVES. There were more gravesites deeper in the glen, but on this day it was too muddy to explore, so we retreated to the car for our next stop.

The Seminary cupola had always been on the bucket list, as we needed to get @PeterT his close-up in his starring role as Sam Elliot playing Buford. He – Peter T – was ready for his star turn, as we had hilariously practiced reciting lines to Gettysburg (the movie) the night before at the Farnsworth Restaurant. Unfortunately, access to the cupola was limited, so that Peter T would have to take the tour at a time when I would be on my way to the airport, so we decided to explore the Seminary Museum in the interim.

The Seminary Museum is an intimate experience of four floors, six rooms each with a theme that carries throughout the floor and is further broken down by room. It was here that I found what I had come for: The despair, destruction, and desperation of war. I read a passage describing the inconceivable carnage of the Pickett's Charge Battlefield – curiosity rendering scarred memories to the hapless author. Photographs of battle wounds that I still cannot get out of my head were on display – the empty eyes of the soldiers stuck in my psyche. A typical hospital room on display viewed through glass shows a couple of fortunate officers had beds….the rest of the patients were strewn about on the floor. I had my fill. THIS is what the Battle of Gettysburg was, and now I fully understood it. My experience was complete.

As my plane rolled down the runway, I looked over to the right, and on the other side of the fence, four coyotes were escorting our plane as it rolled out. Now, Native American myth states that when coyote crosses your path (this being close enough) you are supposed to immediate turn back and abandon your journey, as something bad was ahead. Not today: I had my Good Luck Suitcase and I was feeling confident :smile:
A beautiful closure, Bea, and very appropos.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and melancholy feelings.
 
The night before, @PeterT had recounted a story told to him regarding Gettysburg Battle patients who were set by the creek that divides the Farnworth Restaurant from the Farnsworth House (apparently the house was overrun with patients). When the rains abruptly came after the final Battle of Gettysburg, the story goes that the creek swelled to a raging torrent and carried these patients to their death by drowning. Staring into that narrow shallow waterway, it was difficult to comprehend the watery fingers of death reaching out from below the banks and claiming their hapless victims.

You should have participated in the ghost walk. We were shown the place where the poor wounded soldiers were laid down because the hospital was crowded, before that horrible rain fell and the little creek swelled and washed them all away towards a fence where they got caught and could not free themselves... and we saw the spot where the fence was then also. The stretch of the former creek is said to be one of the most "haunted" spots in Gettysburg with verifiably measurable anomalies in the electromagnetic field.
As General Joshua L. Chamberlain said at the dedication of the Maine monuments at Gettysburg, Oct. 3rd, 1889: "In great deeds, something abides. On great fields, something stays. Forms change and pass; bodies disappear; but spirits linger, to consecrate ground for the vision-place of souls… generations that know us not and that we know not of, heart-drawn to see where and by whom great things were suffered and done for them, shall come to this deathless field, to ponder and dream; and lo! the shadow of a mighty presence shall wrap them in its bosom, and the power of the vision pass into their souls."
Although we had no paranormal experience there (or at least I had not) it was special to see these places at night, in the dark, and imagine what happened there.
 
Last edited:
The Seminary cupola had always been on the bucket list, as we needed to get @PeterT his close-up in his starring role as Sam Elliot playing Buford. He – Peter T – was ready for his star turn, as we had hilariously practiced reciting lines to Gettysburg (the movie) the night before at the Farnsworth Restaurant. Unfortunately, access to the cupola was limited, so that Peter T would have to take the tour at a time when I would be on my way to the airport, so we decided to explore the Seminary Museum in the interim.
I have a video of said "star turn" but have been reluctant to share it.
 
...The Seminary Museum is an intimate experience of four floors, six rooms each with a theme that carries throughout the floor and is further broken down by room. It was here that I found what I had come for: The despair, destruction, and desperation of war. I read a passage describing the inconceivable carnage of the Pickett's Charge Battlefield – curiosity rendering scarred memories upon the hapless author. Photographs of battle wounds that I still cannot get out of my head were on display – the empty eyes of the soldiers stuck in my psyche. A typical hospital room on display viewed through glass shows a couple of fortunate officers had beds….the rest of the patients were strewn about on the floor. I had my fill. THIS is what the Battle of Gettysburg was, and now I fully understood it. My experience was complete...

Bee, maybe this thread I created two years ago following my visit there will also help you remember:

http://civilwartalk.com/threads/seminary-ridge-museum.104715/

035-jpg.jpg
 
Hahaa, finally ONE event I would by no means take part in!
Have fun depriving yourself of food!
I will rather remind @MRB1863 that we have forgot (or hadn't time) to introduce me to a new field of learning: Coke floats!!
We forgot that we had a date at the icecream parlor!!
(But the frozen custard at Rita's was a pretty good substitute!)
Well, your dance card was sooo full!!! But we can look forward to a float during your next visit.
 
View attachment 111613
From Gettysburg Mike & I traveled southwest to Sharpsburg and spent a couple of days revisiting the Antietam and South Mountain battlefields before heading back to Baltimore and our flights back to our respective homes in Texas and Minnesota; here are a couple of related links:

http://civilwartalk.com/threads/jacob-rohrbach-inn-b-b-sharpsburg-maryland.127699/

http://civilwartalk.com/threads/update-on-burnside-bridge-repairs-at-antietam.127624/#post-1398584

View attachment 111614
It looks like work on the bridge is progessing. Can you get over to the other side, or do you have to drive around until the bridge is fixed?
 
It looks like work on the bridge is progessing. Can you get over to the other side, or do you have to drive around until the bridge is fixed?

We were there a few days earlier, in fact we stood at that point two hours before we met you all at Gettysburg - and sadly you cannot pass. It also ruined my impression, but I'm happy that James N. managed to take a photo of Burnside Bridge. I will "steal" that one and add it to my photos of Antietam. I was so disappointed that I have clean forgotten to take a picture!

Edit: besides construction work going on, I think I remember that the bridge is closed to traffic anyway. The battlefield loop makes a turn there and you go back to the road ... I think I saw a marker saying that it was open until maybe the 1950 (don't take my word for that!) and then it was closed for motorized traffic. I may be wrong on that, but at least nowadays the norma visitor is guided to a viewpoint above the bridge. You can walk down, but I think you are not allowed to cross the bridge in your car anymore.
 
Last edited:
We were there a few days earlier, in fact we stood at that point two hours before we met you all at Gettysburg - and sadly you cannot pass. It also ruined my impression, but I'm happy that James N. managed to take a photo of Burnside Bridge. I will "steal" that one and add it to my photos of Antietam. I was so disappointed that I have clean forgotten to take a picture!

190-jpg.jpg


I'm glad you liked those, but these two from my previous visit back in 2014 are much better - feel free to use them!

191-jpg.jpg


... I think I saw a marker saying that it was open until maybe the 1950 (don't take my word for that!) and then it was closed for motorized traffic. I may be wrong on that, but at least nowadays the norma visitor is guided to a viewpoint above the bridge. You can walk down, but I think you are not allowed to cross the bridge in your car anymore.

Actually it was closed to automobile traffic around the time of the battle's Centennial. When I first visited there with my mother in 1961 we drove across; but when I returned with Mike in 1964 it had been closed off.
 
We were there a few days earlier, in fact we stood at that point two hours before we met you all at Gettysburg - and sadly you cannot pass. It also ruined my impression, but I'm happy that James N. managed to take a photo of Burnside Bridge. I will "steal" that one and add it to my photos of Antietam. I was so disappointed that I have clean forgotten to take a picture!

Edit: besides construction work going on, I think I remember that the bridge is closed to traffic anyway. The battlefield loop makes a turn there and you go back to the road ... I think I saw a marker saying that it was open until maybe the 1950 (don't take my word for that!) and then it was closed for motorized traffic. I may be wrong on that, but at least nowadays the norma visitor is guided to a viewpoint above the bridge. You can walk down, but I think you are not allowed to cross the bridge in your car anymore.
I knew that, FF, but you could walk across the bridge. Now I guess you have to drive around a different way to see the top of the rise. Such a beautiful spot! We were there at dusk one time and took lots of photos, but caught no orbs!
 
190-jpg.jpg


I'm glad you liked those, but these two from my previous visit back in 2014 are much better - feel free to use them!

191-jpg.jpg




Actually it was closed to automobile traffic around the time of the battle's Centennial. When I first visited there with my mother in 1961 we drove across; but when I returned with Mike in 1964 it had been closed off.
Thank you so much, that's what I had hoped to see! Dirks loves these, too!
 
In Search of Melancholy

...During our recent Gettysburg excursion, I had a nagging feeling that I was not fully grasping the devastation that had taken place on those hallowed grounds. I felt that there was a depth missing from my experience, even though I had been lavished with friendship, food, and an educational experience of a lifetime, but yet, the visceral aspect had yet to be explored. I was fortunate enough that one more day of Gettysburg remained, and it turned out to be one of the most important of the trip...

I know what you mean - on previous visits I'd been disappointed not to have the time to search out certain features that illustrate and describe that devastation, but one "benefit" of getting lost during Eric's Dan Sickles tour was being near the location of the iconic photos of dead taken by Alexander Gardner:

http://civilwartalk.com/threads/fol...er-at-devils-den-graphic.127728/#post-1399318

dsc04444-jpg.jpg
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top