"BullsEye" Canteen?

[Specster]

Anyone familar with this? You guys think its legit CW?

 

[Frederick14Va]

It is of the pattern and style of the noted Bullseye type of CW canteen. However it would take close examination to determine if it is indeed period, or a reproduction of same.

 

[James N.]

Anyone familar with this? You guys think its legit CW?View attachment 61659

Look on the pewter neck to see if there are any markings ( to my knowledge repros don't have them ); one of my smooth-sides has the maker's name stamped on it in tiny letters.

 

[Frederick14Va]

Look on the pewter neck to see if there are any markings ( to my knowledge repros don't have them ); one of my smooth-sides has the maker's name stamped on it in tiny letters.

Earlier issues typically didn't always have the makers name on the spout. It became a mandate to do so later in the war. Actually have seen a couple folks with repros now that are including a makers name stamp on the spout to be a bit more authentic.

 

[Specster]

Earlier issues typically didn't always have the makers name on the spout. It became a mandate to do so later in the war. Actually have seen a couple folks with repros now that are including a makers name stamp on the spout to be a bit more authentic.

Anything else that would distiguish a CW from a repro?

 

[Specster]

This is a second canteen at the same auction. I would imagine if one is real, it might help a little that the second is as well. Same seller.

 

[rhettbutler1865]

Anyone familar with this? You guys think its legit CW?View attachment 61659

As I have learned the hard way (and subsequent research, lots of it) it should be taken to a reputable dealer for appraisal. Sometimes,you must leave it with them for thorough evaluation. It "looks" authentic, but so many scam artists out there can age a piece, add lettering to convince you, etc.--I don't wish to dampen your enthusiasm, just be very careful...

 

[Tin cup]

Left is my original Bulls-eye Canteen, with my reproduction of the same on the right. Like James N. said, my original has markings showing it's from the contractor J. HALL ROHRMAN PHILAD.
A great book on the subject of US canteens is: http://www.amazon.com/dp/0967073170/?tag=civilwartalkc-20

Kevin Dally

 

[Specster]

Cannot read inscription

 

[Specster]

 

[Specster]

From what I can see it looks like J Hall something

 

[Tin cup]

From what I can see it looks like J Hall something

I know of no one who is stamping markings like that on any repro US style canteens, I'd say it's an original. There is info on that contractor in the book I posted a link to.

Kevin Dally

 

[Specster]

View attachment 62099
Left is my original Bulls-eye Canteen, with my reproduction of the same on the right. Like James N. said, my original has markings showing it's from the contractor J. HALL ROHRMAN PHILAD.
A great book on the subject of US canteens is: http://www.amazon.com/U-S-Army-Militia-Canteens-1775-1910/dp/0967073170/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1426782586&sr=8-1&keywords=U.S. Army and militia canteens

Kevin Dally

Tx You for your insight.

Sincerely,

Spec

PS.....What would u pay if it were legit?

 

[Specster]

I know of no one who is stamping markings like that on any repro US style canteens, I'd say it's an original. There is info on that contractor in the book I posted a link to.

Kevin Dally

Tx

 

[Specster]

Tx You for your insight.

Sincerely,

Spec

PS.....What would u pay if it were legit?

Without your help I would have taken years to figure out that inscription. Thanks again. I have it and, all things considered, I think it is in great shape. I even have the canvas, complete.

Inscription:

J. HALL ROHRMAN PHILAD.

Tx Again,

Spec

PS If you want more pics let me know....

 

[Specster]

View attachment 62099
Left is my original Bulls-eye Canteen, with my reproduction of the same on the right. Like James N. said, my original has markings showing it's from the contractor J. HALL ROHRMAN PHILAD.
A great book on the subject of US canteens is: http://www.amazon.com/U-S-Army-Militia-Canteens-1775-1910/dp/0967073170/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1426782586&sr=8-1&keywords=U.S. Army and militia canteens

Kevin Dally

Hi

How do you store your canteen? Do you put it in zip lock and keep in on the cool side (50-65F) ?

 

[Specster]

One last observation: " Some dispicacble scoundral stole the cork off my lunch" quote from WC FIELDS.

 

[Tin cup]

Hi

How do you store your canteen? Do you put it in zip lock and keep in on the cool side (50-65F) ?

No, nothing scientific in my handling of the canteen. I just keep it in a glass door cabinet that I keep my small amount of relics in for display, in my central air climate controlled house.

Kevin Dally