3 Brothers?

ConfederateCanuck

First Sergeant
Joined
Nov 1, 2018
Location
Canad-istan
This picture is from the Liljenquist Family Collection. It is titled "Three Unidentified Soldiers in Union Uniforms". I think they may be brothers based on their resemblance (especially the two on the ends) and the way they are holding hands.

What do you think?
3Brothers-Maybe.jpg
 
It's very possible. They do resemble each other and more, they're awfully similar in height, weight etc.

Once poked around to see how many reports there were of multiple siblings, and how many - articles everywhere in newspapers. Found a woman who had 20 sons in service ( step children included ), quite a few where seven sons were actually lost. Seven! What a dreadful war.
 
I wondered if all 3 from the pic survived....but 7, that's an unbelievable loss! I recall the author Shelby Foote's story about how one southern town/county sent1,000 men to war and most got slaughtered in a single battle (Antietam maybe). After that, they mixed up men across different units so as to avoid such devasting social effects.
 
Last edited:
These fellas were all from the 66th Illinois Western Sharpshooters (note the fancy scroll work on their Dimmick Rifles.) The group of four were the Hollis brothers. There was another brother who had died of disease. The group of five were the Bowe brothers. Unfortunately there is no photo of the three Spencer brothers.

No. 1.jpg
Bowe_Brothers_of_Company_D_66th_Illinois_01.jpg
 
These fellas were all from the 66th Illinois Western Sharpshooters (note the fancy scroll work on their Dimmick Rifles.) The group of four were the Hollis brothers. There was another brother who had died of disease. The group of five were the Bowe brothers. Unfortunately there is no photo of the three Spencer brothers.

View attachment 343885View attachment 343886
Both these photos of known brothers are great examples of how physical similarities can vary. They seem alike but if you did not know they were brothers you might not immediately assume that.
 
These fellas were all from the 66th Illinois Western Sharpshooters (note the fancy scroll work on their Dimmick Rifles.) The group of four were the Hollis brothers. There was another brother who had died of disease. The group of five were the Bowe brothers. Unfortunately there is no photo of the three Spencer brothers.

View attachment 343885View attachment 343886

Those fellers in the bottom photo seem to have a lot of stuff stuffed in their shirts! I think it might be unwise to tease them about their bow ties, yes?

Don't think those men at the top of the OP are brothers but always could be. It wasn't uncommon then for unrelated men to hold hands, especially if they were sitting close on a narrow seat as these guys are doing - keeps the end men from falling off the chair!
 
Sort of reminds me when I first joined the US Army at eighteen years of age. When I arrived at Ft. Dix, NJ, I and about fifty other new recruits were placed in some old, wooden WWII barracks in what was then called 'Reception.' Here we filled out our paperwork, got measured for uniforms and were given classes in the making of a bunk bed and got all of our shots for medical reasons.

Wasn't too bad, as we all talked and learned where each of us were from, our names and such.

And then we got our first haircuts.

When we assembled in formation in our brand-new uniforms and with our freshly shaved skulls, NONE of us could recognize each other! Sure, we had our names stitched on over our pockets, but we had to keep looking at them to know who we were talking to! That's when nicknames came into play. I was called "Preacher" for the next eight weeks of Basic Training because when the Instructors dumped our duffle bags to check for drugs and dirty magazines, the Bible my church had presented to me before I left home fell out in plain view. Immediately the Instructor who saw my Bible started calling out, "We got a preacher here!"

Other boys we nicknamed by their accents like 'Bama, New York, Armando, etc., and one little guy from PR, who spoke no English whatsoever (except for English swear words) was actually named Garbidian. He got through all eight weeks and graduated with those of us who had not failed or was medically discharged.

The thing is, in looking at the picture of those Union soldiers in their look-alike uniforms and head gear, I wonder how they, or anyone else, could tell them apart! Maybe because they all usually came from the same town or county, they all knew each other to begin with.

But for any of us, especially me, I'd be lost for a few days picking them out as individuals.

Imagine trying to find your ouwn regiment, your own dog tent, in a sea of dog tents in an army of hundred thousand!

Just day dreaming folks. Sorry if it broke the flow.

Sincerely,
Unionblue
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top