HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Apache Scouts in the late 1800s...

1736623901656.png
 
Apache Scouts in the late 1800s...

View attachment 535084

One of the earliest know drawing of a Native:
Native American tribes in Virginia - Wikipedia


This drawing shows the Indians to be a bit more muscular:
Indians A.D. 1600–1800


I think Natives in general were somewhat fit and muscular, but nowhere close to what we would consider muscular today, just because they didn't have the equipment or knowledge to look like say, John Cena or someone like that.
1,600+ Native Americans 1800s Stock Photos, Pictures & Royalty-Free Images  - iStock
 
California_%281977_film%29.jpg


Last May I tried to watch a ACW-related Spaghetti called California (from '77, so one of the last), but it was so downbeat I turned it off after three minutes. The opening music doesn't help.


My elderly dog had just underwent surgery (he's fine now), which was stressful enough, and afterward I was worried about his stitches, so that wasn't what I needed to watch. It still isn't. I don't really like the non-Leone Spaghettis; they're either stupid, downbeat, exploitatively violent, or all of the above.
 
He has a beautiful Winchester.:nah disagree:
From 1964 ("A fistful of $") to let's say 1977 (that movie)...some 500 Italian Westerns were made, the peak was reached in 1968 with 70 films for just that year...
Now ,almost 50 years that the Italian era is over, less than 25 films appears decent...finally it's not so bad, this makes a 5% rate of acceptability !
I've never see "California" yet, but it is considered usually as a good one.
 
I'm a lucky one...I'll watch tonight for the first time in my life I think (I mean I hope I didn't saw it during the 80's as a kid...)"Apache Uprising", with Rory Calhoun...

I purchased it from a Belgian seller (who seems to edit it's own dvd's...:O o: , with beautiful original packaging dvd cover...absolutely legal I guess, because the film is free from any rights, it's in the "public domain", what stays an obscure notion to me -even ater working some years in the cinema business as a cabin operator- some films appears to get that mention, and can be edited by...anybody...without paying any rights, for example, the renowed "One eyed jacks" (1961 by and with Marlon Brando) is in this category, while some other older films aren't...
If anybody here as an opinion about this, it's welcome.

The film's page on "Once upon a time in a Western".

 
I'm a lucky one...I'll watch tonight for the first time in my life I think (I mean I hope I didn't saw it during the 80's as a kid...)"Apache Uprising", with Rory Calhoun...

I purchased it from a Belgian seller (who seems to edit it's own dvd's...:O o: , with beautiful original packaging dvd cover...absolutely legal I guess, because the film is free from any rights, it's in the "public domain", what stays an obscure notion to me -even ater working some years in the cinema business as a cabin operator- some films appears to get that mention, and can be edited by...anybody...without paying any rights, for example, the renowed "One eyed jacks" (1961 by and with Marlon Brando) is in this category, while some other older films aren't...
If anybody here as an opinion about this, it's welcome.

The film's page on "Once upon a time in a Western".


Another example of a film which came into the "public domain" or in other words whose copyright lapsed, was the original "Night of the Living Dead." This was evidently because the final cut of the motion picture did not include a copyright notice in print, which, according to this gentleman, was required before more recent times...


According to Wikipedia, the printed notice on the film was required before 1989...


Some film makers may not have cared particularly back then perhaps. Movies were cranked out to make profits in theaters, and often largely shelved afterwards. TV and later VCR etc. making them potentially relevant assets.

In any case, Perhaps some of the public domain westerns were similar; the film makers or editors not placing the then required legal notice. And if the production companies of these films are gone, then they would seem to be in the "public domain" according to some.
 
I just watched Kevin Costner's "Horizon" on Netflix, three hours long. It was ok, good for me anyway , as I like westerns. The scenery was beautiful, appears that they used real Indians and the firearms and clothing was correct for the time as far as I know. You would expect Costner to get that right. The Indian attack was the best part, to me anyway and I liked the sound track. But evidently some people did not like it because it got some bad reviews and I read that is why it was released on Netflix already, if that means anything. I read where he put a lot of his own money into the film and since this is chapter 1 with supposedly two more movies to follow, I am wondering if they come about and if they will be received any better. If so, I'll be checking them out on Netflix sometime. And not just because it's this movie, but we, at our age of 74 and 79, don't go to movies anymore. Ya know, Netflix, Paramount + etc.
 
I just watched Kevin Costner's "Horizon" on Netflix, three hours long. It was ok, good for me anyway , as I like westerns. The scenery was beautiful, appears that they used real Indians and the firearms and clothing was correct for the time as far as I know. You would expect Costner to get that right. The Indian attack was the best part, to me anyway and I liked the sound track. But evidently some people did not like it because it got some bad reviews and I read that is why it was released on Netflix already, if that means anything. I read where he put a lot of his own money into the film and since this is chapter 1 with supposedly two more movies to follow, I am wondering if they come about and if they will be received any better. If so, I'll be checking them out on Netflix sometime. And not just because it's this movie, but we, at our age of 74 and 79, don't go to movies anymore. Ya know, Netflix, Paramount + etc.

I saw it at a friend's house on his big TV. It was a visually striking movie. No question. It's plot was a little odd. My chum thought it was less about the "Horizon" settlement, as some esoteric philosophical concept in the minds of various people... resulting in the conflicts, etc. There may be a time in the future when the flick is considered visionary.

For myself, I thought the best parts of it were reminiscent of Silverado (1985). The scenery. Coster and several fellow actors from Silverado (Jeff Fahey, the bad guy in Silverado was the main baddy in Horizon).
 
I saw it at a friend's house on his big TV. It was a visually striking movie. No question. It's plot was a little odd. My chum thought it was less about the "Horizon" settlement, as some esoteric philosophical concept in the minds of various people... resulting in the conflicts, etc. There may be a time in the future when the flick is considered visionary.

For myself, I thought the best parts of it were reminiscent of Silverado (1985). The scenery. Coster and several fellow actors from Silverado (Jeff Fahey, the bad guy in Silverado was the main baddy in Horizon).
I just watched Kevin Costner's "Horizon" on Netflix, three hours long. It was ok, good for me anyway , as I like westerns. The scenery was beautiful, appears that they used real Indians and the firearms and clothing was correct for the time as far as I know. You would expect Costner to get that right. The Indian attack was the best part, to me anyway and I liked the sound track. But evidently some people did not like it because it got some bad reviews and I read that is why it was released on Netflix already, if that means anything. I read where he put a lot of his own money into the film and since this is chapter 1 with supposedly two more movies to follow, I am wondering if they come about and if they will be received any better. If so, I'll be checking them out on Netflix sometime. And not just because it's this movie, but we, at our age of 74 and 79, don't go to movies anymore. Ya know, Netflix, Paramount + etc.
How good of a movie is it? If it's any good, I think I'll watch it tonight.
 
How good of a movie is it? If it's any good, I think I'll watch it tonight.

It's difficult to describe. As I mentioned, it might be visionary, and considered a classic in the future. Or maybe not. The production qualities are so striking, really a visual treat. Acting top notch, etc. So as far as plot, my chum and I just looked at each other afterward and said, "Horizon..."

I will certainly check out the future installments, in whatever format. Also partly curious to see how Mr. Costner's western vision manifests... viz. will "Horizon" prove to be an illusion, a lost treasure like that of the Sierra Madre, or the foundation of a multi-million dollar western casino? It's hard to tell where it's headed by the end of the first movie.
 
It's difficult to describe. As I mentioned, it might be visionary, and considered a classic in the future. Or maybe not. The production qualities are so striking, really a visual treat. Acting top notch, etc. So as far as plot, my chum and I just looked at each other afterward and said, "Horizon..."

I will certainly check out the future installments, in whatever format. Also partly curious to see how Mr. Costner's western vision manifests... viz. will "Horizon" prove to be an illusion, a lost treasure like that of the Sierra Madre, or the foundation of a multi-million dollar western casino? It's hard to tell where it's headed by the end of the first movie.
It's a good movie for me, as I said. You have to like a western. But as said above, the plot is a little odd. Costner is his usual good self in it and yes, "visually striking."
Thank you for the info. I'll make sure to watch it tonight. I hope it'll be, as @Dusty said, interesting, but in a good way.
 
It's very good. Probably a future "classic" Western, that will be watched and talked about years from now.
We had opened here a special discussion about "Horizon".
 
I can't really recommend any Alamo movies for accuracy. Some are more entertaining than others and, after all, I don't expect "Hollywood History" to be accurate. They're in business to make money, not hold classes. Documentaries are different and there are a couple of good Alamo documentaries. I think History Channel had a two-hour special hosted by Randy Quaid that was tied to the release of the 2004 movie "The Alamo" that was good. I still enjoy "Davy Crockett at the Alamo" (1955), which was the last of the original 3 TV episodes on Disneyland. It has more in common with the fictional "Col. Crockett's Exploits and Adventures in Texas" than actual events, but it captured the myth of the Alamo pretty well, and in under an hour. John Wayne's 1960 film is the favorite among many Alamo buffs but is 99% inaccurate and actually difficult to get through these days. The 2004 film was much more accurate but I still have problems with it, especially what I regard as superficial and/or inaccurate characterizations of Crockett, Bowie, and Travis. At least we get a closer look at Santa Anna for once. The best Santa Anna was Raul Julia in the TV film "Thirteen Days to Glory," which may otherwise be the worst Alamo movie of all. I like "The Last Command" with Sterling Hayden as Bowie, who is the central figure in this film. John Wayne once said that he thought the film had much better battle footage than his film. The battle scene in the 2004 film is the best/most accurate I've seen.
 
As to Westerns in general, here's my list of favorites/bests, in no particular order:

The Magnificent Seven
Butch Cassidy & the Sundance Kid
Lonely are the Brave
High Noon
Stagecoach
Shane
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
The Gunfighter
The Ox-Bow Incident
The Searchers
Little Big Man
Tombstone
Ride the High Country
True Grit (1969 version)
Once Upon a Time in the West
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top