HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
It's a remake of a remake--The Magnificent Seven is a Westernization of Seven Samurai, a superior movie IMO.
If you'd like to see Seven Samurai, I'd recommend getting the Criterion Collection disc, although it is expensive. You can also watch it for free on Kanopy if your library has this digital service and you have a library card. Other sources may have a poor quality video master or may be cut down to fit the American attention span. The original movie runs over 3 hours.


Roger Ebert's review is quite interesting.

 
If you'd like to see Seven Samurai, I'd recommend getting the Criterion Collection disc, although it is expensive. You can also watch it for free on Kanopy if your library has this digital service and you have a library card. Other sources may have a poor quality video master or may be cut down to fit the American attention span. The original movie runs over 3 hours.


Roger Ebert's review is quite interesting.

Its a fantastic movie, but Yojimbo's my favorite Kurosawa movie.
 
I often wondered why they make movies that are totally different from each other with the same title. There is a western called "Broken Arrow" with Jimmy Stewart then there is a movie by that name with John Travolta and Christian Slater about nuclear missles.There are two different westerns named "The Unforgiven".One had Burt Lancaster and Audie Murphy the other has Clint Eastwood and Morgan Freeman, totally different movies.
 
Watched again yesterday "The glory guys" (1965)...it has an excellent battle scene between U.S cavalry and indians, possibly among the TOP 5 I've ever seen ; the firing line facing the charge of the indians, the retreat through the river... it's once again a distant depiction of L.B.H, without using the real names (but very close for somes...here Major Reno is named "Marcus").
The film also look heavily to John Ford's cavalry trilogy, trying to make an alternance of "funny" moments and dramatic ones...that doesn't really work...but that's not the main interest of the film , a third of it been dedicated to the campain against the Sioux, it apparently didn't lacked of money for the making , there's a bunch of people, horses, wagons...

Here's is it's appreciation on "Once upon a time a Western" :
 
The "Indian Attack" is theme in many westerns. I don't think a wagon train was ever attacked. And I know of no fort in the 1800s
being attacked. Hollywood make these attacks into frequent occurrences. And even if they did make a suicide charge would the Indians have ridden round and round on horseback? Those Indians must have been some amazing marksman. They could hit the target while riding a galloping horse and shooting sideways.
And you have to ask how many western forts actually had wooden walls.
 
Let's be honest, in "serious" movies, they show some open forts (Laramie kind), without any fortifications, walls...there so many troopers in these places, that an indian attack is unable.
Rio Grande (1950) definitely had the wooden fort though Fort Apache did not. A lot of B grade western movies had wooden forts. They probably used the same movie set. The old Marx playsets had wooden forts ( made of plastic ) but they were toys and didn't consider historical accuracy.
 
We're there any?

Fort Phil Kearney did...

1725596879952.png


1725596925495.png
 
Let's be honest, in "serious" movies, they show some open forts (Laramie kind), without any fortifications, walls...there so many troopers in these places, that an indian attack is unable.
There were certainly areas where there were not enough nearby trees to make building a palisade practical. But a combination of a trench and earthen rampart proved its worth in late CW battles. No reason that could not be done, if only to keep the horses secure and keep wild animals out
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top