HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
The majority of westerns have the rinky tink piano just a humming away.Did almost every bar in every town have one or is that "Hollywood"?
Pretty sure that is Hollywood. There are images of old west saloons out there and I don't recall pianos. Most looked quite different than the Hollywood type.
 
Narrow and Deep pretty much sums up some older buildings that once housed saloons. That and they always appear so dark, as in no or very few windows.No swinging doors either. Not at all like the big spacious, well lit ones depicted in the movies.
 
Pretty sure that is Hollywood. There are images of old west saloons out there and I don't recall pianos. Most looked quite different than the Hollywood type.
There's no "Hollywood type" saloons I think, there are so many Westerns, with so many saloons, from the little place with wood and barrels to some Victorian style implantations, with dancers etc...
 
I have a fairly new book that might appeal to some here. The Last Ride of the Pony Express: My 2,000-Mile Horseback Journey into the Old West by Will Grant came out on June 6, 2023, but my library is just getting it now. It's Dewey number is 917.8 which puts it in the Western US travel area rather than history.


 
One of my favorite westerns, if not my absolute favorite, is The Magnificent Seven (1960). It is in my opinion, sheer perfection, and I have avoided seeing the 2016 version because I feared it would be disappointing. We watched it this past weekend and I have to admit I liked it very much. It's different enough that I didn't compare the two too much. Like it was just seven other people helping out a different beleaguered town. The score was fabulous. Similar to the original but not breaking into the familiar theme until the very end. Recommend.
 
Narrow and Deep pretty much sums up some older buildings that once housed saloons. That and they always appear so dark, as in no or very few windows.No swinging doors either. Not at all like the big spacious, well lit ones depicted in the movies.
It may not be historically accurate, but narrow and deep saloon rooms are hard to film in. Bear in mind you have the cast members, extras and associated furniture already. Around that you need room for cameras, dollies, sound booms, lights and reflectors. And nothing can show up in the mirrors inside.
 
One of my favorite westerns, if not my absolute favorite, is The Magnificent Seven (1960). It is in my opinion, sheer perfection, and I have avoided seeing the 2016 version because I feared it would be disappointing. We watched it this past weekend and I have to admit I liked it very much. It's different enough that I didn't compare the two too much. Like it was just seven other people helping out a different beleaguered town. The score was fabulous. Similar to the original but not breaking into the familiar theme until the very end. Recommend.
I used to love that movie, and still do. The big negative to me in the "Magnificent Seven" was the number of banditos that were shot or killed early on was almost the whole amount Calvera (Eli Wallach) had to start with. The head bandito himself said he had 40 men.
 
I used to love that movie, and still do. The big negative to me in the "Magnificent Seven" was the number of banditos that were shot or killed early on was almost the whole amount Calvera (Eli Wallach) had to start with. The head bandito himself said he had 40 men.
Well, yes. I just always assumed Calvera was able to round up some additional banditos. You know, unemployed banditos looking for work.
 
One of my favorite westerns, if not my absolute favorite, is The Magnificent Seven (1960). It is in my opinion, sheer perfection, and I have avoided seeing the 2016 version because I feared it would be disappointing. ...

The remake is, as usual, not as good as the original but I for one think it is not bad (we have seen much much worse remakes).
 
The "Indian Attack" is theme in many westerns. I don't think a wagon train was ever attacked. And I know of no fort in the 1800s
being attacked. Hollywood make these attacks into frequent occurrences. And even if they did make a suicide charge would the Indians have ridden round and round on horseback? Those Indians must have been some amazing marksman. They could hit the target while riding a galloping horse and shooting sideways.
 
Watched Guns of Navarrone the other night- had not seen in 50 years.

But noticed an element also common in westerns of the '60s……. The ricochet sound effect.

Some of these shows take it to the 'nth degree. Every round fired results in a high-pitched two second zinging noise.

Seems ridiculous to me- but having never been on the receiving end of gunfire- maybe it's a more accurate effect than I figure? Just know I've never heard bullets zinging off into the distance, at any gun range.
 
The "Indian Attack" is theme in many westerns. I don't think a wagon train was ever attacked. And I know of no fort in the 1800s
being attacked. Hollywood make these attacks into frequent occurrences. And even if they did make a suicide charge would the Indians have ridden round and round on horseback? Those Indians must have been some amazing marksman. They could hit the target while riding a galloping horse and shooting sideways.
The Hekawi were not fighters, they were lovers!
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top