HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Watched again "Northwest Passage", starring Spencer Tracy, Robert Young, and Walter Brennan, I own a decent copy of that rare Western, set during the French and Indian war ; the battle scene is great, pretty violent for the time (1940), I hate the way they get rid of the French officers (they're drunk, and S.Tracy uses a cannon to kill them while they sleep), there's also a good scene with a river crossing were the Rangers do a "human chain".

555555.jpg
 
Curtiz probably was one of the best but just not in that particular movie. That movie being the Comancheros. It may have its fans but in my opinion it was not a good film.It's one of those that a person should be embarrassed to put their name on , but Curtiz did anyhow.
Just okay. I like the cardplaying scene.
 
Just okay. I like the cardplaying scene.
I still think that film could have been a very good movie had someone bothered to do it right. Some studio probably paid a large sum for the rights to that movie. Then they probably lost money on the deal because it was made into a "So So film. In fact it wasn't even so so, it was a very bad movie.But the plot had potential and "they" blew it.
 
I still think that film could have been a very good movie had someone bothered to do it right. Some studio probably paid a large sum for the rights to that movie. Then they probably lost money on the deal because it was made into a "So So film. In fact it wasn't even so so, it was a very bad movie.But the plot had potential and "they" blew it.
Considering about a billion Westerns came out every year, they probably didn't care much about it. Curtiz was past his prime by this point.
 
I think the term is "resting on your laurels". Curtiz was more than likely passed his prime in 1961. He would die from cancer the following year.He made some very good movies 20 years before "The Comancheros"but not all were gems. Maybe he really didn't know that much about the Old West. He was the one responsible for "Sante Fe Trail", another very unhistoric film.
 
I am watching "Cheyene Autumn" or trying too. It's supposedly based on a real story but John Ford used his artistic license to doctor it up. It's a true story from "Hollywood's" point of view. Edward G. Robinson plays Carl Schurz in it.
 
Watched again "Northwest Passage", starring Spencer Tracy, Robert Young, and Walter Brennan, I own a decent copy of that rare Western, set during the French and Indian war ; the battle scene is great, pretty violent for the time (1940), I hate the way they get rid of the French officers (they're drunk, and S.Tracy uses a cannon to kill them while they sleep), there's also a good scene with a river crossing were the Rangers do a "human chain".

View attachment 508075
The uniforms and headgear aren't accurate. A decent entertaining movie for the time.
 
Yesterday session was "Ride Vaquero", starring Robert Taylor, Anthony Quinn, Ava Gardner, and Howard Keel (I've changed their order from the opening credits, A.Quinn appearing only as a "also starring" while he would possibly deserve the first place) , Kell and Ava Gardner plays former southerners who try to start a new life in the West, while the ugly Quinn empeaches them to settle there.
Taylor -let's say the good guy- has a strange love story with Ava Gardner, the same kind of relation they had in "Knights of the round table".
 
@Polloco Because of you I went and rewatched The Comancheros. Still not that awful. I forgive its inaccuracies simply because it never claimed it was historical. More recent films deserve scrutiny because modern-day Westerns and War movies generally pretend they are accurate.
 
Screenshot 2024-05-21 163908.png


Recently watched Saddle the Wind. A really good dark one; one of those depressing CinemaScope 50s ones along with Warlock and Garden of Evil and Comanche Station. Donald Crisp and John Cassavetes are A+ actors. And that muddy standoff with the Union guy was great.

 
Currently watching 15 Fighting Men as I write. Set right after the Confederate surrender at Appomattox.


There are a few inaccuracies to be sure. Such as one character being from the 14th Vermont and claimed the regiment was wiped out at Mechanicsville in 1862 and spent the rest of the war on Andersonville (the regiment wasn't even raised until after the Peninsula Campaign). Another character's wife was killed during the bombardment of Fort Sumter.

But one thing it does well is that many Confederates probably didn't accept the fact that the war was over and that spurs the action of the film.
 
Currently watching 15 Fighting Men as I write. Set right after the Confederate surrender at Appomattox.


There are a few inaccuracies to be sure. Such as one character being from the 14th Vermont and claimed the regiment was wiped out at Mechanicsville in 1862 and spent the rest of the war on Andersonville (the regiment wasn't even raised until after the Peninsula Campaign). Another character's wife was killed during the bombardment of Fort Sumter.

But one thing it does well is that many Confederates probably didn't accept the fact that the war was over and that spurs the action of the film.
Not to mention Andersonville didn't open until 1864.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top