I read that the rifle that Henry Fonda carried in "Drums Along the Mohawk" is the the same rifle that John Wayne carried in "The Fighting Kentuckian". And that same article states that others like Gary Cooper, Fess Parker, Charleton Heston, and possibly Fred McMurray also used it. And that John Wayne again used it in "The Alamo". If that is true, that gun belongs in a museum.But then just because you read it on Wikipedia, don't mean it's true.
Wayne carried lots of rifles throughout his film career, from Spencer's to Flintlocks. Back then of course, they were the real deal, mostly civil war and post civil war surplus bought up by businesses like Bannerman's and sold to the studios.
A few years ago, I managed to get my hands on one of the surplus "props" carved for Wayne in his first movie, "The Big Trail." According to studio expert Joseph Musso, this particular M1851 Springfield cadet musket was purchased by Fox Studios for use as a movie prop sometime in the 1920's as part of a larger group of guns, most likely from Stembridge Arsenal, a privately owned company formed by James Stembredge sometime between 1916-1920. As the story goes, famed movie director Cecil B. DeMille hired Stembridge to coach actors on how to act like soldiers and sometime after 1916, they recognized the need to accumulate a stock of firearms that could be used as movie props. At that time, surplus Civil War weaponry was available for pennies on the dollar, with muskets typically selling for prices between $1.00 - $5.00 each, complete with accouterments including belt, cartridge box, and bayonet. Thus was the beginning of the Stembridge gun arsenal, which supplied guns for many famous movies, including
Gone with the Wind, Northwest Passage, Across the Wide Missouri, Unconquered, and the
Red Badge of Courage.
The Big Trail prop was stamped with serial number A52, a 20th Century Fox Studios prop house ID number similar to numbers assigned all props stored in Building 41 (aka: the Tom Mix barn) aboard the studio grounds. Building 41 housed an arsenal of weapons featured in various Fox films over the years. Unfortunately, nearly all of the historical records identifying the props and their associated films were accidentally destroyed, thus the specific films in which 'prop A52' was used are not documented, according to Fox archivists.
The stock of this particular gun, as well as an untold number of others, was carved in an intricate pattern described as "Indian design." This particular musket is carved nearly identically to a M-1861 Remington carried by John Wayne in his breakout role as Breck Coleman in "The Big Trail." Since studios often had back-up guns available for use during filming in the event a prop gun malfunctioned or was broken during filming, it made sense that several identically carved guns were on hand.
Although it could've been the original prop slated to be used by Wayne, it's slightly smaller than the larger M-1861 eventually carried by Wayne throughout the film, and was probably a bit too diminutive in the hands of the 6'4" lead actor. Thus, it's surmized that the M-1861 was subsequently carved and chosen for Wayne to carry, leaving the smaller cadet rifle unused in the film.
Many of the Fox Studios prop guns were sold off in 1988, including this example, eventually ending up in the collection of Walter J. O'Connor, whose priceless collection of militaria, firearms and artifacts were posthumously auctioned in September, 2018, at which point, it ended up in my hands.