HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Flipping channels last night I wound up watching "Seminole" from 1953. Rock Hudson and Anthony Quinn had the major roles supported by Lee Marvin and James Best among others. Anybody ever see this movie and have an opinion on the uniforms and weapons? It takes place during the Seminole Wars in Florida.
A sped up version is available on YT. I watched most of it. They made a better than usual attempt at uniforms and weapons though the promotional poster has Rock Hudson holding a revolver of some type and the Indian he is fighting looks more Pawnee than Seminole. It is sympathetic to the Seminoles though the acting is typical 1950s Hollywood. There was another movie about the Second Seminole War made 2 years earlier (1951) called Distant Drums. It started Gary Cooper but is very historically inaccurate.
 
Like Star Trek , The Big Valley was a show that my sister liked so we had to watch it . It was awful. At least I got to watch some of my shows such as Combat.
Star Trek is a mixed bag. TBV, on the other hand...

My grandpa watches Bonanza because he thinks its funny-bad, like how people watch Ed Wood.
 
I'm with your Grandpa on Bonanza. That was another show we had to watch because my sister liked Little Joe. There was no justice in my youth.
I'd be more tempted to watch The Big Valley for the flawless Linda Evans.

Linda-Evans-the-big-valley-7933199-640-480.jpg
 
A sped up version is available on YT. I watched most of it. They made a better than usual attempt at uniforms and weapons though the promotional poster has Rock Hudson holding a revolver of some type and the Indian he is fighting looks more Pawnee than Seminole. It is sympathetic to the Seminoles though the acting is typical 1950s Hollywood. There was another movie about the Second Seminole War made 2 years earlier (1951) called Distant Drums. It started Gary Cooper but is very historically inaccurate.
Thanks. I don't usually get caught up in historical accuracy regarding uniforms etc. but this caught me. It seemed they really made an effort. I was surprised at how brutal the army attack on the village was portrayed in 1953. What do you think of the outfits on the other Seminoles?
 
Thanks. I don't usually get caught up in historical accuracy regarding uniforms etc. but this caught me. It seemed they really made an effort. I was surprised at how brutal the army attack on the village was portrayed in 1953. What do you think of the outfits on the other Seminoles?
Some of the outfits reminded me of Apaches in 1950s westerns. Anthony Quinns outfit looked similar in style as to how Osceola was depicted. It did take a sympathetic view of the Seminoles which was refreshing for the time
 
  • Like
Reactions: SJU
I checked this out today at the library. I had to have it sent over from Dolton. I blame it on all of you and this thread. I need to print out the table of contents from the link as the CD notes are long gone. You'll notice they included Gettysburg and Glory.

I used to have that one. A few sound nothing like the film versions, mainly the Morricone and High Plains Drifter.
 
So far we have named a few that should be on the "Best" western list. How about some that you think are the "Worst" westerns. I don't have my movie list handy but I would put The Big Valley on the worst TV list.
 
So far we have named a few that should be on the "Best" western list. How about some that you think are the "Worst" westerns. I don't have my movie list handy but I would put The Big Valley on the worst TV list.
Definitely The Big Valley. More to follow.
 
Sherry Lansing was about as realistic playing a Mexican named Amelita in Rio Lobo as Rock Hudson playing a Indian named Young Bull in Winchester '73. In other words , not really.
Ok , Sherry wasn't much of an actress but she had quite a career. To name a few , Chairman and CEO of Paramount Pictures , President of Production at 20th Century Fox and winner several times of Hollywood Reporter's list of Power 100.
 
Did anyone mention High Chaparral ? I liked that series with Leif Ericson , Linda Cristal Cameron Mitchell and Henry Darrow.
 
So far we have named a few that should be on the "Best" western list. How about some that you think are the "Worst" westerns. I don't have my movie list handy but I would put The Big Valley on the worst TV list.
I watched reruns of Tombstone Territory a few years back. Plots and acting were both pretty bad.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top