HF Westerns

Historical-Fiction
Let's say it's a strange paradox ; that "generation" of Spielberg, Coppola, Scorcese, etc...which as emerged during the late 60's and the beginning of the 70's, with it's own way to tell stories, own type of characters, different actors/acting...is often revelant to the previous ones (Ford, Mann, Sturges, etc...), but they sadly contributed to the almost extinction of the Western genre, and possibly "films noirs" also.
To make it simple, we can say that the "Star Wars" era completely made nerd (?) of CLASSICS films to most of the audience.
The same happened in France and Italy, during the unfortunate "nouvelle vague", combined to the dissapearance of actors and directors.
I happen to be a SW nerd, but I am not a Spielberg fan. Lucas is much closer to Ford and Kurosawa than Steven's anti-auteur films are.
 
@Kurtlg My problems with Leone are mainly that his films are not great stories. Most of them defy belief (so a guy can shoot a spur from the side to make it spin?), and the stories are cliche-ridden.

For example, OUATITW has the themes of a mysterious stranger wanting revenge, a greedy landgrabber, defense of a woman's honor, growing civilization symbolism, charming bandits, cold-eyed killers, blah blah blah. Where have we seen these before and better?

I have not seen Duck You Sucker or his 30 hour gangster movie to comment on those.

maxresdefault.jpg
 
@Kurtlg My problems with Leone are mainly that his films are not great stories. Most of them defy belief (so a guy can shoot a spur from the side to make it spin?), and the stories are cliche-ridden.

For example, OUATITW has the themes of a mysterious stranger wanting revenge, a greedy landgrabber, defense of a woman's honor, growing civilization symbolism, charming bandits, cold-eyed killers, blah blah blah. Where have we seen these before and better?

I have not seen Duck You Sucker or his 30 hour gangster movie to comment on those.

View attachment 495864

@Kurtlg My problems with Leone are mainly that his films are not great stories. Most of them defy belief (so a guy can shoot a spur from the side to make it spin?), and the stories are cliche-ridden.

For example, OUATITW has the themes of a mysterious stranger wanting revenge, a greedy landgrabber, defense of a woman's honor, growing civilization symbolism, charming bandits, cold-eyed killers, blah blah blah. Where have we seen these before and better?

I have not seen Duck You Sucker or his 30 hour gangster movie to comment on those.

View attachment 495864
I am not a fan of Leone. I do like some of Spielberg's work ( Duel , Jaws , Saving Private Ryan , Lincoln , etc ) but Close Encounters and several others put me to sleep. I know there are historical issues with his films , but that doesn't bother me . He was executive producer on True Grit (2010) , a film I enjoyed , but then there's Cowboys and Aliens the very next year.
 
Interesting regarding Eastwood as far as smoking. Think for many, Clint smoking a Cheroot Cigar is iconic.

Hard to believe that at one point in 1959 there were 30 western themed TV shows. In March 1959 8 of the top 10 shows were westerns; western toy sales that year were $125 million, roughly equivalent to $1,318,947,594.50 today (955.2% increase due to inflation).

Some favorites:

TV Shows
Gunsmoke, The Virginian, Deadwood, and Lonesome Dove miniseries

Movies
The Shootist, Open Range, Unforgiven, The Searchers, The Ox-Bow Incident, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance,
Rooster Cogburn, Once Upon a Time in the West, Outlaw Josey Wales, Hang 'em High, Pale Rider, Tombstone, Ulzana's Raid,
The Ballad of Lefty Brown

Comedy
The Cheyenne Social Club, Support Your Local Sheriff

Probably not necessary to say but one can see from above, liked for entertainment value over historical accuracy.
In the 50's Guy Madison stared as Wild Bill Hickok with Andy Devine as Jingles.
 
Randolph Scott and Joel Mc Crea on the set of "Guns in the afternoon".

View attachment 495809
I haven't seen "Guns in the Afternoon" with Randolph Scott and Joel McCrea. I have seen Scott's last movie when he teamed up with Joel McCrea again , "Ride the High Country". I thought it a pretty good film.Randolph Scott was a little off character in that one. Not sure if it was James Drury's film debut but it was "pre-Virginian".
 
Last edited:
I haven't seen "Guns in the Afternoon" with Randolph Scott and Joel McCrea. I have seen Scott's last movie when he teamed up with Joel McCrea again , "Ride the High Country". I thought it a pretty good film.Randolph Scott was a little off character in that one. Not sure if it was James Drury's film debut but it was "pre-Virginian".
I never was crazy about Joel McCrea. I find him dull--same with Scott. Have never seen Ride the High Country, but I'm only interested because others said it was good.
 
I never was crazy about Joel McCrea. I find him dull--same with Scott. Have never seen Ride the High Country, but I'm only interested because others said it was good.
I think, Randolph Scott, Joel McCrea, or Robert Ryan had alot of the "super stars" beat as far as westerns go. In other words, I think they were better at it.
 
@Kurtlg My problems with Leone are mainly that his films are not great stories. Most of them defy belief (so a guy can shoot a spur from the side to make it spin?), and the stories are cliche-ridden.

For example, OUATITW has the themes of a mysterious stranger wanting revenge, a greedy landgrabber, defense of a woman's honor, growing civilization symbolism, charming bandits, cold-eyed killers, blah blah blah. Where have we seen these before and better?

I have not seen Duck You Sucker or his 30 hour gangster movie to comment on those.

View attachment 495864
Name some that are better in your opinion please
 
"The-shooting-the-spur-from-the side-to-make-the -rowel-spin" was used as an example earlier about defying belief. My memory is a bit "fuzzy", what movie was that in?
 
"The-shooting-the-spur-from-the side-to-make-the -rowel-spin" was used as an example earlier about defying belief. My memory is a bit "fuzzy", what movie was that in?
I don't recall that scene but if we discuss things that defy the rules of physics or impossible shots we need look no farther than the end of The Good , The Bad and the Ugly.
 
There is no doubt a good western starts with a good story.Sadly that's why we have so many B westerns.Not only did some have a bad plot, I've seen some with no plot at all (or so it seems). Then worry about who's going to star in it. Ronald Reagan once said Hollywood didn't want good movies, they wanted fast movies.
 
There is no doubt a good western starts with a good story.Sadly that's why we have so many B westerns.Not only did some have a bad plot, I've seen some with no plot at all (or so it seems). Then worry about who's going to star in it. Ronald Reagan once said Hollywood didn't want good movies, they wanted fast movies.
Exactly. They used to pump them out of the studios like crazy. Thankfully there were many made with decent plots and good acting .
 
Talk about defying belief. Why in the movie "Joe Kidd" would anyone build a bar on active Railroad tracks? Or how about the Rifleman striking matches with his rifle? Even if the shooter were that good, the equipment they used back then was not that accurate.If I recall Lucas McCain used a .44-40. From what I've witnessed that caliber is not exactly known for it's pin-point accuracy.
 
One thing I noted about some of the earlier Gunsmoke episodes was that sometimes Matt and even Chester were depicted cleaning firearms while sitting in the office. With black powder loads that was absolutely necessary but rarely depicted on screen.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top