Veterans' Letters

Cap'n Dan

Private
Joined
Feb 20, 2005
Location
California
My grandfather received this letter in 1915, from a brigade comrade concerning the Battle of Gettysburg:
1611847042272.png


Bolivar, Mo., April 17, 1915.

J. N. Hubbard,
Grayson, Ky.

Mr Dear Comrade:

On receiving my Tribune yesterday I was delighted to see your article on the fight at Culp's Hill on the 2nd of July, 1863. Many of the old boys who write for the paper have very defective memories or draw on their imagination for their facts. One can scarcely make an assertion but some comrade rises to say that "it was no such thing; that it was his regiment or brigade that did it," etc. So it was peculiarly gratifying to see that Capt. D. J. Dickson and yourself substantially corroborated me in the brief account which I gave. The error in my figures was not an error in figures, but in names. The loss of 1,002 which I gave should have been credited to Cutler's Brigade instead of "the two brigades of Wadsworth's Division." How the mistake occurred I cannot now say. Your account is very accurate. The Corps probably had about 8,000 in action. Capt. Dickson gives the number when mustered June 30, at 8,716, which is correct. Then the men on detached duty would in all probability bring the total number down to 8,000. The entire 7th Indiana, of our brigade, was left behind as guard for the train, and many others no doubt were detailed on similar duty.

I well remember when the 7th Indiana came up to us in the Cemetery about four o'clock in the afternoon, where about 80 of us were lying, & asked: "Hello, boys, where is the regiment?" And when we replied, "This is the regiment," they were as sorry a lot of boys as I ever saw. We always had a warm feeling for that regiment. Regiments, you know, form friendships like individuals. It is my impression from reading your article that you belonged to the 7th. Do you remember when Mrs. Gavin, wife of the Colonel, came to visit him near Culpeper, Va., in the winter of 1863-4? How the boys enjoyed that visit! I have met but few of the patriotic boys of the Army of the Potomac. Only one of my regiment many years ago, and one of the 6th Wisconsin about a year ago at Quincy, Ill., in the Soldiers' Home which I went to visit.

Well, time is passing, and I have passed my 75th birthday. Yet I do not feel old, because I live largely in the past. I keep green in my memory the days of 1861-5, and the boys with whom I toiled and marched and fought. There has never been a day since the close of the war when I would not have shared my last crust or my last dollar with one of "Old Waddy's" Division. Brave old man! I was close to him when he was killed. The last words I heard him say were: "Now, boys, we'll take a thousand prisoners!" But it was not to be.

Now, comrade, I want to thank for your letter. I wish you many happy years to come and all the good things that life affords and all the satisfaction that comes from duty well performed.

I am fraternally,


Wm L Wilson (signed)
56th Pa

care of Box 393


Grandfather said that when he asked, "where is the regiment?", some of the 56th Pa said, "Out there".
 
Last edited by a moderator:
After falling back through the town on the late afternoon of July 1, the color bearer of the 56th Pennsylvania and just 10-15 others from the regiment, with Colonel J. William Hoffmann still in command, halted near the crest of Cemetery Hill on the Baltimore Pike, perhaps just in front of the Evergreen Cemetery gatehouse, a prominent landmark. Brigadier General Cutler soon arrived and Hoffman inquired as to which side of the pike they should form on. Cutler spied Major General Hancock amid a group of mounted officers and went forward to ask. When Cutler returned after a few minutes, some 80-100 from the brigade had already collected around the remnant of the 56th Pennsylvania, being familiar with their flag. Then they all fell back through the cemetery and reformed on "the lower carriageway," the approximate location of which I have delineated on the attached map as their second position. Here the brigade slowly gained strength as its scattered soldiers rejoined, until it had collected roughly 350 officers and enlisted men, including 70-80 representing the 56th Pennsylvania, as recalled by William L. Wilson. While they were resting on the carriage way, the fresh 7th Indiana, with a strength close to 430 officers and men, came marching up the pike and presumably deployed behind their comrades, at which time they learned the awful truth about their heavy losses. I estimate the time was closer to 6 p.m. rather than 4 p.m. as mentioned by Wilson, but it's only an approximation on my part. The 7th Indiana was not there very long before it was sent to occupy the northern crest/slope of Culp's Hill. Before nightfall, the rest of the brigade crossed to the other side of the Baltimore Pike and rested for the night in a meadow.

Source: Field Operations at Gettysburg, by J. William Hoffman, Military Essays and Recollections of the Pennsylvania Commandery of the Military order of the Loyal Legion of the United States, read February 5, 1896, comp. by Michael A. Cavanaugh, vol. I, reprint Broadfoot Publishing Company, 1995.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
What a wonderful letter. I think many veterans felt that way, wishing to see their old comrades again.
My project on local ACW soldiers included their pre-war lives as well as the later years. Going through newspapers, I found many reunions--not only big ones (such as the ones for Gettysburg) but individual regiment gatherings. Of course there was the problem of distances: a vet who had moved to California wasn't likely to attend a gathering in Portland, Maine.

Many tried to keep track of each other. Marching Home describes one vet who called on another in the course of a business trip. I don't think that they had seen each other in person since the war itself. The two old men sat up all evening, talking over those old days, long after the host's family had gone to bed.
 
My Grandfather, John Nelson Hubbard's brother, Silas Rosin Hubbard and several cousins joined
Company D, 3rd Indiana Cavalry on 22 August 1861. His cousin, Jesse Smith, joined Company D, 3rd
Indiana Cavalry on 8 February 1862. Jesse's twin brother joined on 3 February 1862. The 3rd Indiana
was quickly formed into 6 Companies and sent to join the Army of the Potomac in Virginia. The other half
was later formed and was sent to join the Army of the Cumberland.
The 3rd Indiana Cavalry was in Buford's First Division, Gamble's First Brigade and was camped just west
of Gettysburg, when on the early morning of 1 July 1863, they met the lead rebel unit (Heth's artillery)
about 3 miles west of Gettysburg. And the Battle of Gettysburg had commenced.
The 7th Indiana, 2nd Brigade, 1st Division, 1st Corps, Army of the Potomac was assigned wagon
train duty a few days before July, 1863. They were due to be relieved of this "hated" duty by a Vermont
regiment on the First of July. During an early dinner (lunch) at 11:00 on 1 July 1863, just south of
Gettysburg, a few of the soldiers heard a distant rumble of cannons.

Grandfather wrote: "At that, the Colonel directed us to hurry up our dinner, that we would go on, as we might be needed up there. We had gone but a short distance, until we saw a horseman coming towards; his horse running. As he came abreast of us he said to Colonel Grover, "Colonel, hurry up your regiment! General Reynolds is killed and the First Corps is fighting the whole rebel army". At that, we left the wagons and increased our stride, and soon was on the field at the Codori house, where we found cartridge boxes and put some packages in our haversacks. Generals Wadsworth and Cutler, our division and brigade commanders, met us and led us over to the summit of Culp's Hill and lined us up on that hill.
On passing through the Cemetery, about seventy five of the old 56th Pa. was lying on the grass. Some of our boys said, "56th, where is your Regiment?" They pointed out where they had fought that day, at same time saying, "Here is all that is left of us. The others are out there!" It certainly made us feel blue, for we knew that, that fine regiment had suffered terribly that day; losing about three hundred."
 
My grandfather received this letter in 1915, from a brigade comrade concerning the Battle of Gettysburg:


Bolivar, Mo., April 17, 1915.

J. N. Hubbard,
Grayson, Ky.

Mr Dear Comrade:

On receiving my Tribune yesterday I was delighted to see your article on the fight at Culp's Hill on the 2nd of July, 1863. Many of the old boys who write for the paper have very defective memories or draw on their imagination for their facts. One can scarcely make an assertion but some comrade rises to say that "it was no such thing; that it was his regiment or brigade that did it," etc. So it was peculiarly gratifying to see that Capt. D. J. Dickson and yourself substantially corroborated me in the brief account which I gave. The error in my figures was not an error in figures, but in names. The loss of 1,002 which I gave should have been credited to Cutler's Brigade instead of "the two brigades of Wadsworth's Division." How the mistake occurred I cannot now say. Your account is very accurate. The Corps probably had about 8,000 in action. Capt. Dickson gives the number when mustered June 30, at 8,716, which is correct. Then the men on detached duty would in all probability bring the total number down to 8,000. The entire 7th Indiana, of our brigade, was left behind as guard for the train, and many others no doubt were detailed on similar duty.

I well remember when the 7th Indiana came up to us in the Cemetery about four o'clock in the afternoon, where about 80 of us were lying, & asked: "Hello, boys, where is the regiment?" And when we replied, "This is the regiment," they were as sorry a lot of boys as I ever saw. We always had a warm feeling for that regiment. Regiments, you know, form friendships like individuals. It is my impression from reading your article that you belonged to the 7th. Do you remember when Mrs. Gavin, wife of the Colonel, came to visit him near Culpeper, Va., in the winter of 1863-4? How the boys enjoyed that visit! I have met but few of the patriotic boys of the Army of the Potomac. Only one of my regiment many years ago, and one of the 6th Wisconsin about a year ago at Quincy, Ill., in the Soldiers' Home which I went to visit.

Well, time is passing, and I have passed my 75th birthday. Yet I do not feel old, because I live largely in the past. I keep green in my memory the days of 1861-5, and the boys with whom I toiled and marched and fought. There has never been a day since the close of the war when I would not have shared my last crust or my last dollar with one of "Old Waddy's" Division. Brave old man! I was close to him when he was killed. The last words I heard him say were: "Now, boys, we'll take a thousand prisoners!" But it was not to be.

Now, comrade, I want to thank for your letter. I wish you many happy years to come and all the good things that life affords and all the satisfaction that comes from duty well performed.

I am fraternally,


Wm L Wilson (signed)
56th Pa

care of Box 393


Grandfather said that when he asked, "where is the regiment?", some of the 56th Pa said, "Out there".

That's a valued and cherished letter to keep.

The writer is articulate and gracious with his compliments.

Am struck by the depth of connection felt with his former comrades-in-arms.

Was also interested to read that the writer (after 75 years of age) very much remembered his wartime experiences and comrades and these memories kept him from feeling old.
 
My Grandfather, John Nelson Hubbard's brother, Silas Rosin Hubbard and several cousins joined
Company D, 3rd Indiana Cavalry on 22 August 1861. His cousin, Jesse Smith, joined Company D, 3rd
Indiana Cavalry on 8 February 1862. Jesse's twin brother joined on 3 February 1862. The 3rd Indiana
was quickly formed into 6 Companies and sent to join the Army of the Potomac in Virginia. The other half
was later formed and was sent to join the Army of the Cumberland.
The 3rd Indiana Cavalry was in Buford's First Division, Gamble's First Brigade and was camped just west
of Gettysburg, when on the early morning of 1 July 1863, they met the lead rebel unit (Heth's artillery)
about 3 miles west of Gettysburg. And the Battle of Gettysburg had commenced.
The 7th Indiana, 2nd Brigade, 1st Division, 1st Corps, Army of the Potomac was assigned wagon
train duty a few days before July, 1863. They were due to be relieved of this "hated" duty by a Vermont
regiment on the First of July. During an early dinner (lunch) at 11:00 on 1 July 1863, just south of
Gettysburg, a few of the soldiers heard a distant rumble of cannons.

Grandfather wrote: "At that, the Colonel directed us to hurry up our dinner, that we would go on, as we might be needed up there. We had gone but a short distance, until we saw a horseman coming towards; his horse running. As he came abreast of us he said to Colonel Grover, "Colonel, hurry up your regiment! General Reynolds is killed and the First Corps is fighting the whole rebel army". At that, we left the wagons and increased our stride, and soon was on the field at the Codori house, where we found cartridge boxes and put some packages in our haversacks. Generals Wadsworth and Cutler, our division and brigade commanders, met us and led us over to the summit of Culp's Hill and lined us up on that hill.
On passing through the Cemetery, about seventy five of the old 56th Pa. was lying on the grass. Some of our boys said, "56th, where is your Regiment?" They pointed out where they had fought that day, at same time saying, "Here is all that is left of us. The others are out there!" It certainly made us feel blue, for we knew that, that fine regiment had suffered terribly that day; losing about three hundred."
This account by John N. Hubbard is very informative. His comment concerning supplies available near the Codori house is particularly interesting. When he speaks of cartridge boxes I presume he means receiving extra cartridges (packed in wooden boxes) carried by at least one ammunition wagon. Normally the 7th Indiana would draw from a First Corps ammunition wagon, but expenditures in the corps were so great that first day that the First Corps remnants drew some from the Eleventh Corps train after arriving on Cemetery Hill. In any case I've not heard of any ammunition being distributed at Codori's until now, although it makes sense because Union infantry was moving northward along the Emmitsburg road.

As for "packages" for haversacks, I'm not sure what he is referring to, unless maybe hardtack drawn from a commissary wagon. But it was my understanding that the supply wagons had turned back toward Westminster long before reaching the vicinity of Gettysburg, with only ambulances and ammunition wagons allowed to proceed to the front.
 
Another Civil War veteran's story written to the National Tribune:

NATIONAL TRIBUNE, May 24, 1888, p. 12, c. 1-3

"Joe."
Who His "Bunky" Turned Out to Be.
by Capt. Jack Crawford, "The Poet Scout."

On the long journey from my home in New Mexico to the East I stopped off for a day in a town in Western Kansas, that great "old soldier" State, and attended a meeting of the Grand Army Post located there. At the close of the meeting one of the officers of the Post said to me:
"Comrade, I want you to come home with me and stay over night. I cannot promise you extra fare, for my wife has gone back East to visit her folks, and good hired girls are scarce in this new country, but I can give you a soldier's welcome, and, perhaps, a little better grub than we used to get in war times."
I gladly accepted the invitation, for the home of a comrade, no matter how humble it may be, posses for me far more attractions than the best hotels in the land.
I accompanied the comrade to a beautiful cottage in the outskirts of the town, and while sitting in his cozy parlor he handed me a tintype of a boyish-looking soldier—such a picture as nearly every comrade had taken in a tent by one of the field artists who followed the troops during the war.
"This cannot be your picture?" I remarked, transferring my gaze from the handsome, boyish features to the comrade's manly, bearded face.
"No," he replied, with a smile, "that is Joe. He was my 'bunky' at one time during the war, and if you care to listen I can tell you a queer story about the little fellow."
I assured him that I would listen with pleasure, and he continued:
"I was a private soldier in an Iowa regiment attached to the Fifteenth Corps. Numerous battles in Tennessee and Mississippi and the diseases incident to that hot climate had greatly decimated our ranks, and one day a lot of recruits reached us, several of whom were assigned to my company. Among them was Joe Ransom, whose picture you hold in your hand. He was a little, almost childish looking fellow, and from the day he joined us the veterans of the company seemed to look down upon him. They dubbed him 'the baby,' and many were the predictions that a very little hard service would break him down, and that the roar of the first battle would terrify him and make him cry to be sent back home to his mother.
"The taunts and gibes heaped upon the boy awoke sympathy in my heart, and I soon found myself taking a deep interest in him. I enlisted at a very early age and was but little more than a boy myself, and by various little acts of kindness and words of encouragement I soon gave him to understand that he had at least one friend in the company, and I could see his face light up with pleasure every time I approached him.
"One day while we were camped in a forest on Black River, in Mississippi, I started to a spring about a quarter of a mile distant to fill some canteens with water. On the way I met Joe, who had just emerged from a side path in the woods, and his red, swollen eyes told me that he had been weeping.
"'Why, Joe,' I said, 'what is the trouble? What have you been crying about?'
"His tears began to flow afresh, and in a broken voice he replied:
"'Charlie, you are the only man in the company who is good to me, and I just can't stand the way the men treat me any longer. They make me the laughing-stock not only of the company, but of the whole regiment, and it makes me miserable. They call me a 'baby,' and say that I ought to be at home helping my mother wash dishes instead of being down here trying to play soldier. O, will we never get into a fight? When we do they may find out that the big men who wear whiskers are not the bravest.'
"'O, pshaw, Joe!' I said, 'you musn't mind the boys, for they don't mean half they say. They see that it worries you when they guy you, and think it is fun to play upon your feelings as they do. Just pay no attention to them, and they will soon let you alone.'
"'How can I help but pay attention to them. I know I am young and small, and maybe I ought to have stayed at home, but I do my duty just as well as the biggest man in the company does. I believe I'm a better soldier than half of them now, if I haven't been out long. Can I help it that I wasn't born sooner than I was?'
"'Maybe if you would report the matter to the Captain he would put a stop to all this. Hadn't you better go to him and tell him how the boys treat you?'
"Joe's eyes flashed as he replied:
"'That's just what I've been crying about. You know the Captain drinks, Charlie, but then he always seems so good-natured that I did venture to go to him a while ago. I went into his tent and took off my cap and saluted as respectfully as I knew how, and he looked at me and laughed and said, "Hello, baby; how do you get along with you milk down here?" It made me mad, Charlie, and I told him if I loved milk as well as he loves whisky I wouldn't be able to get along without it at all, and then I left the tent and came out there in the woods just because I had to cry and didn't want anybody to see me. I expect he'll put me in the guardhouse for insolence.'
"'No, I think not, Joe,' I said. 'Capt. Williams drinks, it is true, but he is a brave old soldier, and as big-hearted a man as there is in the regiment. He is a good man, Joe, if he does get a little tipsy when not on duty.'
"The words were scarcely out of my mouth ere the Captain came around a bend in the path and stood before us. He halted and, folding his arms, began to look Joe steadily in the eyes.
"'So you think I like my whisky, eh?' he said. 'Do you know what I ought to do in a case of this kind?'
"I could see Joe's lips trembling, and I knew that it was with difficulty he was keeping back the tears.
"'Captain,' he said, 'I know you ought to punish me for my insolence, but, indeed, I couldn't help it. I beg your pardon, sir and_____'
"'Stop, my boy! You are on the wrong track. I am going to do my duty as an officer—and as a gentleman. It was I who was wrong, and I humbly beg your pardon for my insolence. Give me your hand, my boy, for I believe you have the material for the making of a good soldier in you.'
"Joe grasped the honest, outstretched hand and actually kissed it, and I never before saw such an expression on a human face. His eyes filled with tears, and the look he gave the Captain was one of mixed astonishment, gratitude and joyous surprise.
"'O, Captain,' he said, 'I would give anything if I could recall what I said to you, but I was desperate. The men of the company had made me wild with their taunts, and I had gone to you for relief, hoping, O, I cannot tell you how much I hoped, that you might do something for me. Captain, I enlisted through as pure patriotism as ever swayed a human breast and came down to the front resolved to do my whole duty in battling for my country, but the men have made my life miserable before I have been given a chance to show in battle that I am a soldier. I know now that you did not mean it, sir, but when I went to you for relief and met with the same taunt that had almost crazed me I became desperate and spoke to you as I did. I am sorry that I did so.
"'Why, my boy, I never dreamed that the men were abusing you. I had heard that they had given you the title of 'the baby soldier,' but thought it was all in fun, and that you didn't mind it. Tell me all of your troubles right now.
"Joe did so, and also told him that I was the only one who had befriended him since he joined the company. The men in his own tent, he said, were the worst, and from the time they went in at night until sleep silenced them they tortured him with their taunts. I spoke for the boy and told the captain that it was shameful the way they abused him.
"'Who bunks with you, Parker?' the Captain asked.
"'No one, sir,' I replied. 'Harris, who was killed at Shiloh, was my 'bunky,' and I have since had none.'
"'Then you take the boy in with you and take care of him. Tell the First Sergeant it is my order, and he must make the transfer at once. I will see what I can do to put a stop to the men so annoying him.'
"And so it happened that Joe that night became my 'bunky,' and we shared the same blankets thereafter.
"The Captain gave the men to understand that they must let the boy alone, but his orders only had the effect to make them more cautious in their annoyance. To his fault of being young and green, and of having never smelt powder in battle, he had now added that of being a 'tattler' to the officers, and every old soldier knows what that means. They still harassed poor Joe, but not so openly as formerly.
"We laid in that camp in the damp woods, which were full of malaria and rattlesnakes, for two months, but at last the welcome, longed for marching orders came, and a cheer of thankfulness went up from thousands of throats when the army was again in motion.
"We had gone into camp after the fourth day's march, when 40 rounds extra of ammunition was issued, and the men were ordered to see that their guns were in perfect condition, and to be ready to move at daybreak in the morning. We all knew what that meant—that the enemy was in front of us, ready to give battle.
"Joe's eyes beamed with a strange light, and when we laid down in our blankets beneath a great oak tree he could talk of nothing but the morrow and what it might bring. At one time he said:
"'Charlie, I know there will be a battle, and I am glad of it. I feel that after it is over the boys will no longer call me 'baby,' and will not treat me as they now do. And, say, Charlie, if anything should happen [to] me, if I should fall, I wish you would open my knapsack, and in it you will find a Bible with my mother's name and address written on the fly-leaf, and inside the Bible is the picture I had taken back at Black River. Send them both to her, and tell her what became of me.'
"That is the same picture, comrade, which you hold in your hand.
"' I thought you sent the picture home yourself, Joe.' I said.
"'No, I did not. I have never told you, Charlie, but—but my people don't know where I am. I ran away from home to enlist. If I should not answer at roll-call after the battle, please write to my mother and tell her all about me. The picture will tell her the rest.'
"I thought the remark a strange one, but I was too tired and sleepy to question him, and assuring him that if he fell, and I was spared, I would faithfully carry out his wishes, I fell asleep.
"Before daybreak next morning we were awakened not by the shrill bugle notes as usual, but by the First Sergeant going from man to man and quietly rousing us. Breakfast was soon dispatched, and at the command 'Fall in' the men took their places, many of them for the last time.
"We started on the march and had proceeded about two miles when scattered shots were heard in advance. The deployed skirmishers were playing the prelude to the dreadful song of battle.
"A halt was ordered, and then all was activity along our lines. Aids-de-Camp galloped hither and thither, bearing orders to division, brigade and regimental commanders; batteries of artillery flew swiftly by to the points to which they were ordered, the wheels rumbling, the horses snorting and the drivers playing whip and spur to urge them to still greater speed; cavalry regiments thundered along, the sabers of the men clanking against the steaming sides of the excited horses; bugles blared in every direction; general officers galloped along the blue-clad lines inspecting the ranks with eager eyes—all a thrilling prolog to the great drama of death about to be enacted—while from the front the sharp firing of the skirmishers came back to us, seeming to invite us to the fray. From far beyond the skirmish lines the sounds of bugles could be occasionally heard amid all this din and confusion, and they told us that the same scenes were being enacted in the ranks of the enemy.
"'Will we never move?'
"It was Joe's voice, and glancing into his face I could read the spirit of eagerness which swayed his young soul, and could see determination pictured on his flushed face.
"'Forward! Steady, men!' and we advanced through the wood. The skirmishers fell back and took their places in the line, and in a few moments the storm of battle burst upon us in all its fury.
"It was a terrible fight, and men seemed to fall like leaves on every hand. We had been engaged for perhaps half an hour when the rebels made a sudden, unexpected charge right up to our line. They were repulsed with great slaughter, and when they slowly fell back a cry of rage went up from our ranks, for our regimental flag went with them, borne by disloyal hands. Our color-bearer had been killed, and one of the enemy seized the flag as he fell, and bore it off.
"Suddenly a form was seen to dart forward from the line, and almost before we could realize what had happened Joe rushed up to the captor of our colors, knocked him down with his gun, seized the flag, and bore it back to the regiment, where he unfurled it and waved it in defiance at the foe. Many shots were fired at the heroic boy, but he seemed to bear a charmed life and escaped unhurt. The cheers which greeted the hazardous exploit were deafening. Men threw their hats high in the air and yelled themselves hoarse as the gallant boy returned the flag to the color company and returned to his place by my side.
"'Joe, my brave boy, you are a hero!' I proudly cried, as he looked up into my face with a triumphant smile.
"'No, I am only a baby,' was his quiet reply. 'Heroes are big men who wear whiskers. I'm only a baby, Charlie.'
Then came an order to charge, and with a cheer the line moved forward. We had advanced but a short distance when I felt what seemed like a dull blow from a heavy missile in the groin, and I sank to the ground. I tried to rise again as the men charged over me, but could not, and realized that I had received a severe wound. Soon the men came slowly falling back, stubbornly resisting the repulse they had met, and as they passed the spot where I was lying Joe stopped and knelt beside me.
"'Are you badly hurt, Charlie?' he asked eagerly.
"'I fear I am, Joe; but you must not stop here. Keep with the regiment, for the enemy is following up the repulse and will soon be on us, and you will be killed or captured.'
"'I cannot leave you here,' he replied. 'It would be cowardly in me to desert the only friend I have in the company.'
'"They are all your friends now, Joe, and you must go. For God's sake go quick!'
"'No, I will not,' he replied firmly. 'I will save you, or I will die here with you. Put an arm around my neck and I will raise you to your feet, and may be able to get you off the field.'
"I saw that further urging would be useless, and did as he directed. He seemed to have acquired almost superhuman strength as he raised me and half-carried, half-dragged me toward where our regiment had again made a stand. We had almost reached the line, and the men were again wildly cheering the young hero, when I heard him say: 'Oh, I am hit, Charlie!' and at the same moment we both fell heavily to the ground. Then the loss of blood and the shock overcame me, and I lost consciousness.
* * * * * *
"When I regained consciousness I found myself lying on a cot in the field hospital, the Regimental Surgeon bending over me. As I looked up in his face in an inquiring manner, he kindly asked:
"'Well, my boy, how do you feel now?'
"'Very weak, Doctor. How long have I been here?'
"'Two days. You have had a close call, Parker, but with care I think you will now pull through all right. In a day or two, as soon as I think you can be moved with safety, I will start you to the hospital at Memphis, where you will have good care, and you will soon recover.'
"'And—and—was Joe—killed?' How I dreaded to ask the question.
"'No, the little hero was not killed; but received a bad wound in the shoulder. I myself dressed the wound, and made a most remarkable discovery during the operation. Charlie, our baby soldier is a girl!'
"'A girl! Why, Doctor, you cannot be serious. You cannot mean it!'
"'Yes, it is true, Charlie; and a brave, heroic girl she is, too. She has been started to the Sisters' Hospital at St. Louis, and from there will be sent to her home in Iowa. Before leaving she begged to be carried here to see you, but you were delirious and did not recognize her. We bore her to the ambulance weeping and praying for your recovery.'
"Well, comrade, you can imagine my astonishment at this revelation. My little 'bunky' a girl! It fairly dazed me. A couple of days afterward I was sent back to Memphis, and after two months in the hospital was again reported fit for duty and sent back to my regiment, and served without receiving another scratch until the war ended. I marched with Sherman to the sea, and, beginning as Corporal, was promoted step by step. Capt. Williams was killed at Kenesaw Mountain, and on that last grand review at Washington I marched as Captain at the head of my company."
"And Joe?" I asked. "What became of him? Of her, I mean?"
"I think I told you just before leaving the Post room to-night that she had gone back East to visit her folks. She has been my 'bunky' ever since the war."
 
That's a great story @Cap'n Dan , though I'm kinda thinking it's not 100 percent true
A little too detailed, 25 years after the fact ... who remembers conversations like that. But it probably has a germ of truth.

We sometimes tend to assume that incredible feats of accurate memory were commonplace for Civil War veterans, but how many of us can remember our classmates, supervisors, workmates, organizations, locales, or bureaucratic numbers from a decade or two back? Despite this obvious problem, veterans are expected to recall similar facts from, sometimes, many more years earlier. These men had stories to tell, important stories for them ... and for us. The lesson learned is often more important than the factual detail.
 
That's a great story @Cap'n Dan , though I'm kinda thinking it's not 100 percent true
I think that it might be true. Estimates of the number of women soldiers that I've read range from 400 to 1000. The two times that one might think that a woman would be detected (entry medical exams and night time sleeping) actually could be meaningless: the exams of Maine recruits were pretty cursory (and this is apt to be true elsewhere) and soldiers often slept in their oversize and form-disguising clothing.
 
who remembers conversations like that
Haven't we all been surprised by what people remember? Memory is funny. Some people live in the past--The teller may have asked himself "How could I have missed this?" and replayed the entire incident in his mind, over and over. Look at some of the other vets' letters here: they recall details and minute specifics. As a genealogist, I've done many interviews with people that included incidents onto 50 years earlier (and even longer) and found that what they remember often is detailed.
 
Haven't we all been surprised by what people remember? Memory is funny. Some people live in the past--The teller may have asked himself "How could I have missed this?" and replayed the entire incident in his mind, over and over. Look at some of the other vets' letters here: they recall details and minute specifics. As a genealogist, I've done many interviews with people that included incidents onto 50 years earlier (and even longer) and found that what they remember often is detailed.
Very true. "Memory is funny," indeed. And sometimes "replaying the entire incident" over and over in the mind is just how unconscious "improvements" to our memories occur. I always think of Shakespeare's "St. Crispin's Day" speech in Henry V:
He that shall live this day, and see old age,​
Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbours,​
And say "To-morrow is Saint Crispian."​
Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars,​
And say "These wounds I had on Crispin's day."​
Old men forget; yet all shall be forgot,​
But he'll remember, with advantages,​
What feats he did that day.​
...​
And Crispin Crispian shall ne'er go by,​
From this day to the ending of the world,​
But we in it shall be rememberèd—​
We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;​
For he to-day that sheds his blood with me​
Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile,​
This day shall gentle his condition;​
And gentlemen in England now a-bed​
Shall think themselves accurs'd they were not here,​
And hold their manhoods cheap whiles any speaks​
That fought with us upon Saint Crispin's day!​
[just had to finish that, tho' a bit off-topic!]​

And yet, everyone is different. Some do remember more clearly than others. The first letter in this thread, for instance, was written by a man who had a more educated, almost "scholarly" dedication to his accuracy. He wasn't digging up a random memory from his past; he had examined and verified his facts.

It's a very complex subject. Traditional, usually oral history vs. documented, academic history (and how they often intertwine, complementing or challenging each other).
 
Last edited:
I'm wondering if there is a file of the National Tribune newspapers in the National Archives in Washington.
Grandfather wrote several articles and letters for the Tribune and on occasion received letters from veterans.
He had just completed his first year at Moores Hill Male and Female College in the spring of 1861.
The 7th Indiana was one of the first six regiments organized for three months (in deference to the five who
served in the Mexican War). Grandfather turned 18 in June 1861 and enlisted at the blacksmith's shop.
He survived two wounds and served for three years. He later became an lawyer and judge in Grayson, KY.
I have the original letters written by the veterans along with his history of the 7th Indiana Infantry Regiment.
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top