Union Volunteer Bounty Question

Alfalfa

Cadet
Joined
May 25, 2019
Location
South Louisiana
Newbie with 1st post. My G grandfather (Michael Sussmann) was a German immigrant stone mason arriving in 1854. When the CW broke out he responded to Lincoln's May 3 1861 call for 300,000 volunteers to serve three years by volunteering and assigned to the Army of the Potomac and mustered into F Company, 55th NY Volunteer Inf Regiment, later part of G Company 38th NY Volunteer, and then in the E Company NY 40th Volunteers. He served in all the campaigns of these regiments as a Pvt until the Wilderness Campaign when he was wounded.
My question- At the time he enlisted on August 1, 1861 he was 33 years old (old for volunteers), married with 2 children. What I am trying to get a handle on is what caused him to enlist being married with 2 small children. What was the state of the economy at that time. Did the early volunteers get big bonuses like the later conscripted/drafted troops? Maybe it was from a sense of patriotism?
 
In the absence of some contemporaneous letters or similar documents, the answer to your question is unknowable.

It's one of the things that makes the Civil War so fascinating to many of us.
 
Last edited:
Maybe it was from a sense of patriotism?

Welcome ! I'm sure patriotism entered into the equation. The Volunteers of 1861 on both sides, expected a quick end to the conflict. Some early enlistments in the North were for 3, 6, and 9 months. If Michael received an enlistment bounty, I'm sure it looked appealing to a father of two.
 
One immigrant mother gave testimony in 1863 to an antislavery convention as to why her 17-year-old son was fighting for the Union. "I am from Germany where my brothers all fought against the Government and tried to make us free, but were unsuccessful," she said. "We foreigners know the preciousness of that great, noble gift a great deal better than you, because you never were in slavery, but we are born in it."

Following the failed Revolution of 1848, thousands of young Germans fled to America. They took up arms in what they saw as yet another battle in the revolutionary struggle against the forces of aristocracy and slavery. "It isn't a war where two powers fight to win a piece of land," one German enlistee wrote to his family. "Instead it's about freedom or slavery, and you can well imagine, dear mother, I support the cause of freedom with all my might."

In another letter written to his family in Europe, a German soldier gave a pithy explanation of the war: "I don't have the space or the time to explain all about the cause, only this much: the states that are rebelling are slave states, and they want slavery to be expanded, but the northern states are against this, and so it is civil war!"
 
I'm not sure 33 was considered all that old. War of 1812 vets showed up, flintlocks like John Burn's famous gun in hand. Someone who knows more than me would have to say whether or not these men were accepted ( were they? ) but they showed up willing to fight.

That's a wonderful American immigrant story to have in the family. Guessing your ancestor settled in a German community and had quite a bit of company raising his hand. Yours sure fought his way through a good part of the war before being wounded.

Welcome to the forum! @Pat Young can point you to more information on immigrants and why they fought. Like wbull1 said, a lot of Europeans came here towards freedom, the chance to be as equal as anybody and to give their children what was denied them elsewhere.
 
Newbie with 1st post. My G grandfather (Michael Sussmann) was a German immigrant stone mason arriving in 1854. When the CW broke out he responded to Lincoln's May 3 1861 call for 300,000 volunteers to serve three years by volunteering and assigned to the Army of the Potomac and mustered into F Company, 55th NY Volunteer Inf Regiment, later part of G Company 38th NY Volunteer, and then in the E Company NY 40th Volunteers. He served in all the campaigns of these regiments as a Pvt until the Wilderness Campaign when he was wounded.
My question- At the time he enlisted on August 1, 1861 he was 33 years old (old for volunteers), married with 2 children. What I am trying to get a handle on is what caused him to enlist being married with 2 small children. What was the state of the economy at that time. Did the early volunteers get big bonuses like the later conscripted/drafted troops? Maybe it was from a sense of patriotism?
As others have noted, each man's reasons for enlisting were his own. In May of 1861 there were not any large enlistment bounties at all. These were only developed later when states could not meet their recruitment quota's. Here is a brief article I wrote on early German volunteers:

https://longislandwins.com/news/national/why-the-germans-fought-for-the-union-2/
 
Newbie with 1st post. My G grandfather (Michael Sussmann) was a German immigrant stone mason arriving in 1854. When the CW broke out he responded to Lincoln's May 3 1861 call for 300,000 volunteers to serve three years by volunteering and assigned to the Army of the Potomac and mustered into F Company, 55th NY Volunteer Inf Regiment, later part of G Company 38th NY Volunteer, and then in the E Company NY 40th Volunteers. He served in all the campaigns of these regiments as a Pvt until the Wilderness Campaign when he was wounded.
My question- At the time he enlisted on August 1, 1861 he was 33 years old (old for volunteers), married with 2 children. What I am trying to get a handle on is what caused him to enlist being married with 2 small children. What was the state of the economy at that time. Did the early volunteers get big bonuses like the later conscripted/drafted troops? Maybe it was from a sense of patriotism?

Just a few questions.

Do you know where Michael Sussman was from in Germany? The 55th was the Lafayete Guards under Colonel Régis de Trobriand. Many of the the soldiers in it were French. Was he from the area near the French border? Of course, he may have joined a "French" regiment just because he had friends who were joining it.

Do you know where he lived in New York?

Here is the NY State Military Museum page on the regiment:

https://dmna.ny.gov/historic/reghist/civil/infantry/55thInf/55thInfMain.htm

Have you read Detrobriand, P. Regis. Four years with the Army of the Potomac ?

Here is a link:

https://archive.org/stream/cu31924026471619/cu31924026471619_djvu.txt
 
Colonel Régis de Trobriand wrote in his memoir of the regiment in the first months of the war:

The Fifty-fifth New York militia, more generally
known then as the Guard Lafayette, was a French
regiment. It wore as a distinguishing costume the red
pantaloon and cap. It was small in numbers, scarcely
exceeding three hundred and twenty men, the mini-
mum required for a militia regiment. It was not on
war footing — far from it ; but the number sufficed for
parade, marchings, and funerals, nearly the only re-
quirements of service in time of peace.

When, in the month of April, the President made his
first call for seventy-five thousand men, nobody in New
York doubted but that the Fifty-fifth would be one of
the first to respond. There was to be fighting, how
could a French regiment fail to be on hand .' Volun-
teers hurried in multitudes to enroll themselves in the
ranks ; the companies were filled up rapidly, bringing
their effective force up to a hundred men each. A
subscription, opened among the French residents, to
arm and equip the new regiments without delay, had
' been immediately covered with signatures, and had pro-
vided abundantly for the military chest. — And yet, in
spite of all that, the Fifty-fifth did not start.

One day, the regiment had received an order to en-
camp on the Battery, a public park along the bay, at
the point of junction of the East and North Rivers.
Two companies reported there, but the next day a
counter-order relieved them, to give place to another
regiment. Public opinion was astonished at these
marchings to and fro without result, and at these
delays without satisfactory explanations. The colonel
threw the responsibility upon higher authorities ; but
the officers attributed the fault directly to the colonel,
who, they said, endeavored, with all his power, to dis-
courage enlistments and impede the departure of the
regiment. Weary of these goings-on, and of the re-
criminations, the volunteers went away as fast as they
had come. Some formed a company in the Sixty-sec-
ond New York (Anderson Zouaves) ; others in one of
the regiments of General Sickles' brigade (Excelsior
Brigade). One day, a whole company had marched
over, with drums beating, and joined the Fourteenth of
Brooklyn. Lastly, a large part of the Lafayette
Guards had connected themselves singly in different
military organizations, where they found compatriots
and friends. The officers of the Fifty-fifth, who wished
to fight, and saw their recruits leaving them, were an-
noyed at the false position in which they were placed,
and at the remarks, far from flattering, which were
made about them in public. To get out of the dilemma,
they had recourse to a united demand that the colonel
should substitute, in place of a short leave of absence,
'for which he had asked, a final resignation, which was
accepted.

Several weeks passed away in the search for a new
commander, without success, when my name was pre-
sented, for the first time, by a lieutenant, who had
served in France, and the only one of the officers who
was personally known to me. Some days after, a com-
mittee, composed of the major and three captains,
came to see me on the matter. It was not difficult for
us to agree. The condition made to me, as a candi-
date, was that I should lead the regiment to the front.
The condition I made, on accepting the command, was
that the regiment should follow me to the front. The
officers were called together to choose a colonel on the
2 1 St of July, the evening before the battle of Bull Run.
I was elected unanimously.

On the 23d, the morning of the battle, a telegraphic
despatch from the War Department announced to me
that the services of my regiment were accepted, and,
one week after, we were encamped on Staten Island,
across the bay from New York, — the men in barracks,
the staff only in tents.

The first business was to recruit, and fill up the
ranks, depleted during the two months that had
elapsed. A recruiting office was opened immediately,
at the regimental armory. Those of the old members
who had not made engagements elsewhere returned to
us. New recruits came in squads to our camp ; in
four weeks our effective force was increased by more
than four hundred men.

It was no longer the time when the crowd flowed
towards Lafayette HalL Three months of continual
recruiting had absorbed already a great deal of the food
for powder. But the hour of the mercenary had not
yet arrived. All the enlistments were without bounty,
and, on leaving for the army, I was proud at leading
only unbought volunteers. Not one of my men had
received a bounty.
 
So you get your answer on page 72 where the colonel wrote:

the hour of the mercenary had not
yet arrived. All the enlistments were without bounty,
and, on leaving for the army, I was proud at leading
only unbought volunteers. Not one of my men had

received a bounty.
 
Welcome to the Forum from Pittsburgh PA and the Antietam / Sharpsburg Forum. @Pat Young seems to have answered part of you question. It was not the same answer for all men enlisting.

The payment of a bonus in many depended on the date of enlistment. The payment of a $100 to men enlisting for three years was authorized in in July, 1861. In March 1863 the amount was bumped to $300 for a three year enlistment; $500 for five years. After the institution of draft quotas individual draft districts paid higher amounts if the were having trouble meeting their numbers.
 
Great forum. Thanks for all the info. I didn't know who he was until a few years ago. Here is a paper (see below) I wrote on his history some might find interesting. I also did sub-papers on each major campaign his unit was in. One more thing. He is buried in NYC Most Holy Trinity Cemetery in an unmarked grave (see pictures). I have heard the US Military has a program to ensure/make sure all veterans have grave stones? Anyone help with this?
http://appliedvb.com/NY40th/Sussman.html

IMG_2383.JPG


IMG_2384.JPG
 
Great forum. Thanks for all the info. I didn't know who he was until a few years ago. Here is a paper (see below) I wrote on his history some might find interesting. I also did sub-papers on each major campaign his unit was in. One more thing. He is buried in NYC Most Holy Trinity Cemetery in an unmarked grave (see pictures). I have heard the US Military has a program to ensure/make sure all veterans have grave stones? Anyone help with this?
http://appliedvb.com/NY40th/Sussman.html
See link below.
https://www.cem.va.gov/hmm/
 
If you have not done so already I would consider ordering your ancestor's military and pension record from the National Archives. There is a cost involved for both but there is often times a wealth of information in these documents. Being that your ancestor was wounded in the war the possibility is strong that he will have many details about the day of his wounding and much more. Suffice to say these records are an excellent resource for folks like yourself wanting to fill in some gaps in information. I am operating on my phone and am not able to post the link for the National Archives. Perhaps one of my contemporaries would be some kind to do so for your benefit. If you do order these records please let us know what you find because it will be of interest to all. Good hunting my friend and welcome.
 
If you have not done so already I would consider ordering your ancestor's military and pension record from the National Archives. There is a cost involved for both but there is often times a wealth of information in these documents. Being that your ancestor was wounded in the war the possibility is strong that he will have many details about the day of his wounding and much more. Suffice to say these records are an excellent resource for folks like yourself wanting to fill in some gaps in information. I am operating on my phone and am not able to post the link for the National Archives. Perhaps one of my contemporaries would be some kind to do so for your benefit. If you do order these records please let us know what you find because it will be of interest to all. Good hunting my friend and welcome.
Yes, I did go to the Archives and received tons of info. that is largely contained in my write up: http://appliedvb.com/NY40th/Sussman.html
 
Newbie with 1st post. My G grandfather (Michael Sussmann) was a German immigrant stone mason arriving in 1854. When the CW broke out he responded to Lincoln's May 3 1861 call for 300,000 volunteers to serve three years by volunteering and assigned to the Army of the Potomac and mustered into F Company, 55th NY Volunteer Inf Regiment, later part of G Company 38th NY Volunteer, and then in the E Company NY 40th Volunteers. He served in all the campaigns of these regiments as a Pvt until the Wilderness Campaign when he was wounded.
My question- At the time he enlisted on August 1, 1861 he was 33 years old (old for volunteers), married with 2 children. What I am trying to get a handle on is what caused him to enlist being married with 2 small children. What was the state of the economy at that time. Did the early volunteers get big bonuses like the later conscripted/drafted troops? Maybe it was from a sense of patriotism?
Wow. What a great question. Being a newbie too I know nothing. Can't wait to read responses you got/get. Welcome!!
 

Learn About Us
About CivilWarTalk
Contact the Webmaster
Meet the Staff
Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
Register
Browse Forums
View Today's Discussions
Search the Forum
Get Help
FAQ
Student Guide
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top