Just finished an account of Dahlgren's 1864 Raid. What is your opinion on the Jeff Davis /Assassination papers found on the body of Colonel Ulric Dahlgren?
I think most historians consider them authentic . There has been a lot of debate over the years ( Dahlgren's name misspelled for example) but the question remains who was behind it if true. Stanton is a good possibility .
Under the well mannered conventions of that era, Lee requested General Meade to affirm or deny the legitimacy of Dahlgren's orders. Meade denied their accuracy and the matter (at least officially) was put to bed.
Could it be probable that Dahlgren deliberately misspelled his name in case the paper was to fall into the wrong hands? That way he could easily have denied his way out of it. He had no way of knowing he was going to be killed. Or another scenario being that a misspelled name on the orders was maybe some code for something like "abort the mission" or something?
Those original papers or orders with Dahlgren's misspelled name on them. They were examined by Lee and then Meade. Then either sent back to Richmond or forwarded to Washington. Where are they today if they even still exist?
Those original papers or orders with Dahlgren's misspelled name on them. They were examined by Lee and then Meade. Then either sent back to Richmond or forwarded to Washington. Where are they today if they even still exist?
Per the author talk above: the original orders were retained by the Confederate government and captured by the Union Army at the end of the war. Edwin Stanton checked them out a government repository and never returned them.
The orders were photographed and photograph prints of the order widely distributed by the Confederate government for propaganda purposes. These copies are the surviving version of the orders.
The author says he addresses in the book the obvious question of who gave the orders to Ulric Dahlgren. I think the presentation implies Edwin Stanton was behind the plot. I certainly wouldn't put it past Stanton to have done so, and without Lincoln's knowledge.
Whoever issued the orders, I think there's a Mission Impossible and/or The Wire reference that applies here.
If one accepts that the Dahlgren papers containing the controversial orders existed, then obviously someone must have written these directions. (It was probably not Dahlgren himself, because apparently his name was misspelled on the papers - which seems unlikely if Dahlgren wrote it himself).
Apparently the original papers were seized later by Stanton and have never been seen since. The clear implication here is that Stanton destroyed these records. Sounds suspicious. Suspect these orders were issued from a high level source.
Thought Stanton would not have destroyed (or otherwise concealed) these written orders, if there was nothing incriminating contained within these records to hide and keep secret.
It was certainly within a determined Stanton's capacity to issue such types of orders. As Secretary of War, he had the power to do so. Stanton was also no stranger to independently micro-managing individuals in situations and practicing unorthodoxy and/or duplicity behind- the-scenes. (For example, he used his power to influence Generals voting for conviction in the court-martial of Fitz John Porter and he controlled the prosecution of the conspirators involved in Lincoln's assassination where he was accused of witness tampering and engaging in activities that skewed the outcome of these trials).
Papers found on the body of a Union soldier ordering the assassination of Jefferson Davis sparked outrage in the South, but were they forged by the Confederate government as a propaganda tool?...
Why would Dahlgren be foolish enough to carry those orders (if real) on his person. The instructions would have been simple and clear enough that he and the raiders would have understood their objectives beforehand. OK, it might be said that for secrecy or security purposes, this was a case of "orders not to be opened" until underway. But in that case, why wouldn't Dahlgren burn or otherwise destroy the document after reading?
I have several Confederate Treaury Notes and yes the ink of that day did bleed through.If the original was still around, I'm sure you'd see "ink burns" completely through the paper. That gall ink used back then was highly acidic.But thanks to Mr. Stanton all we have is lithograph copies or photos.
Why would Dahlgren be foolish enough to carry those orders (if real) on his person. .... why wouldn't Dahlgren burn or otherwise destroy the document after reading?
Perhaps for his own protection. If he attempted the assassination, but was captured he might try the "Nuremberg defense" .... "I was only following orders." Not that it would have gotten him very far.
Perhaps for his own protection. If he attempted the assassination, but was captured he might try the "Nuremberg defense" .... "I was only following orders." Not that it would have gotten him very far.