Traditions Enfield Performance

Whitworth27

Cadet
Joined
Aug 3, 2023
I am thinking about buying a Traditions Enfield and I am curious if anyone on here owns one. I am looking for info on how it has performed and whether you've encountered any mechanical problems with it. I've read a few bad reviews for the Traditions 1842 Springfield involving problems with the lock. I thought I would post on here to try to get a better idea of whether there are common issues with Traditions muskets. I would greatly appreciate info on other Traditions muskets as well.
 
Save your money, look for a Parker-Hale. No longer in production they were made in England to original specifications using original gauges on loan from the Royal Arsenal, they are the best to be had. They turn up on Gunbroker, the North South Skirmish Association site, gun shows and in gun shops. You won't be disappointed. I've acquired all .577 Enfields they produced, 1853 3 band, 1858 2 band and the 1861 Musketoon. Italian made rifles pale in comparison. YMMV
 
Save your money, look for a Parker-Hale. No longer in production they were made in England to original specifications using original gauges on loan from the Royal Arsenal, they are the best to be had. They turn up on Gunbroker, the North South Skirmish Association site, gun shows and in gun shops. You won't be disappointed. I've acquired all .577 Enfields they produced, 1853 3 band, 1858 2 band and the 1861 Musketoon. Italian made rifles pale in comparison. YMMV
I've heard about the progressive depth rifling in the Parker Hales. Do the Parker Hales usually shoot more accurately than the Italian rifles? I understand the Italian rifles need different bullets due to the rifling.
 
I've heard about the progressive depth rifling in the Parker Hales. Do the Parker Hales usually shoot more accurately than the Italian rifles? I understand the Italian rifles need different bullets due to the rifling.
I can't give any credence to the need for special bullets in the Italian rifles. Italian bore sizes are known to vary from tight to sloppy. A good fitting bullet is the key to accuracy. A too tight bullet requires it to practically being hammered down the bore, a too loose bullet won't expand the skirt enough to take to the rifling. There's a lot to be considered. Check out the Muzzleloading forum for tips from expert shooters, the NSSA is loaded with good info too. I primarily shoot a .451 P-H Whitworth with hex bullets I cast myself. What model Enfield are you looking for and where are you located? YMMV
 
I can't give any credence to the need for special bullets in the Italian rifles. Italian bore sizes are known to vary from tight to sloppy. A good fitting bullet is the key to accuracy. A too tight bullet requires it to practically being hammered down the bore, a too loose bullet won't expand the skirt enough to take to the rifling. There's a lot to be considered. Check out the Muzzleloading forum for tips from expert shooters, the NSSA is loaded with good info too. I primarily shoot a .451 P-H Whitworth with hex bullets I cast myself. What model Enfield are you looking for and where are you located? YMMV
I saw a video by Paper Cartridges where he explains that Italian rifles need a tighter fitting bullet because they lack progressive depth rifling. I'm looking for a 1853 Enfield and I'm in California.
 
Too bad you're clear across the country. I might be convinced $$$ to part with the 1853 3 band but wouldn't want to ship it across the US. Over on the Muzzleloading Forum I've seen too many nice rifles busted up by USPS, FEDEX and UPS to take the chance of us both being unhappy with a busted rifle. Only way I would ship it would be well padded in a large PVC pipe with glued ends and the cost to do that would be sky high with no guarantee it still wouldn't be damaged. One guy's busted high dollar Kentucky rifle had tire tracks across the box, sadly carriers aren't what they used to be, nothing is since Covid.
 
Even the PVC tube is no guarantee. I recently had a 3" pvc tube with glued fittings on each end delivered by USPS with one end smashed open and the contents (a lined and rifled Euroarms 1861 barrel) missing. Try replacing that one! After tons of paper work and submitting claims, I was denied my claim and appeal by the Post Office. The sender also never got the hundred bucks insurance that is standard on these shipments. Be careful out there!
 
Even the PVC tube is no guarantee. I recently had a 3" pvc tube with glued fittings on each end delivered by USPS with one end smashed open and the contents (a lined and rifled Euroarms 1861 barrel) missing. Try replacing that one! After tons of paper work and submitting claims, I was denied my claim and appeal by the Post Office. The sender also never got the hundred bucks insurance that is standard on these shipments. Be careful out there!
Thanks for the affirmation of my concerns.
 
"I never had any head for machinery of any kind but from sheer necessity did acquire enough of the faculty to take apart and put back together an army musket, and that is the full extent of my ability in that line." Leander Stillwell, 61st Illinois Infantry.

I consider myself about like Leander Stillwell in terms of mechanical matters. I just gave up on a Traditions kit US 1842 kit and sent it to a gunsmith to complete. The hole for the tang screw was mis-drilled and the barrel wouldn't fit by half an inch. In addition they have these awful laser etched "warnings" burned into the metal which disfigures about 4" on both sides of the barrel. I would not recommend the Traditions kit. In speaking with Todd Watts, he has built about four of the P53 Enfield kits and every single one of them has had serious defects. In one case the lock mortise was drilled too far back, in another the lock plate screws blocked the ramrod channel and so on. It is his opinion that these are factory defects or "seconds" which are being sold in kit form but are not going to be able to be built by the average hobbyist. I know my 1842 kit could not be completed without major alterations.
 
Even the PVC tube is no guarantee. I recently had a 3" pvc tube with glued fittings on each end delivered by USPS with one end smashed open and the contents (a lined and rifled Euroarms 1861 barrel) missing. Try replacing that one! After tons of paper work and submitting claims, I was denied my claim and appeal by the Post Office. The sender also never got the hundred bucks insurance that is standard on these shipments. Be careful out there!
I just got a cardboard box ith a delivered USPS. It was crushed on one end, wrapped in big clear plastic bag, with note that basically read, "Gee, we're sorry about that and we'll try not to do.it again."
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top