Member Review Thanks!

[James N.]

Kudos to @Rusk County Avengers for creating this useful forum combining the various reviews on the different forums into one from the past two decades!

 

[Rusk County Avengers]

Thanks James!

That was many hours of looking for book reviews. But I'm sure anyone could have done it, @CivilWarTalk needed help and I helped.

 

[Andy Cardinal]

You did a great job!

 

[Rusk County Avengers]

I just hunted for them, I think the boss man had the hard work to do.

It did get mighty tiresome, I'd think I found a book review, then just find a link to some newspaper review, or copy and pasted review off another site that may and probably was copyright infringement. There must have been hundreds of those.

I just hope everyone's happy with the effort.

 

[Ole Miss]

I suppose once you have scaled the heights a few momemnts alone reading a book would be nice.
Regards
David

 

[Rusk County Avengers]

I suppose once you have scaled the heights a few momemnts alone reading a book would be nice.
Regards
David

I reckon I'll never live that one down...

And I typed that after being asked on another work trip and trying figure out what mountain to climb on the route.

 

[James N.]

I just hunted for them, I think the boss man had the hard work to do.

It did get mighty tiresome, I'd think I found a book review, then just find a link to some newspaper review, or copy and pasted review off another site that may and probably was copyright infringement. There must have been hundreds of those.

I just hope everyone's happy with the effort.

Only one minor criticism: I found a review of Gods and Generals that was of the movie rather than the book; I don't now remember where, but it was OLD and on one of the last pages. At the very least this has made it easy to see what's already been reviewed - I even found several of mine I'd forgotten all about!

Edit: It may have been this:

Member Review - Gods and Generals Personal Review | Civil War Books, Stories, & Media

As a Civil War era descendant I was really excited about going to see Gods and Generals. Well, I personally think this movie was way too long and that Jackson's portrayal was way off base. Jackson was not a kind, considerate, loving, man the way he was portrayed in the movie. He was a...

civilwartalk.com