Repeaters

Picture of an original Henry Rifle.

View attachment 12151
God forgive me, but when I was 12 years old, I went home from church with another kid and his family one Sunday because we were both into the civil war. We ended up playing war in his back yard. He let me play with his favorite gun. It just so happened to be an ORIGINAL HENRY RIFLE. I ran all over that back yard cocking and dry firing that beautiful gun.
His dad said his Grandpa passed it down. They had gotten the gun as payment from a Texan for nursing him back to health on his way home after the war.
It was fully functional, as far as I could tell. It had a name that I can't recall carved into it.
3 years ago, I heard his wife was pregnant with twins. I facebooked him and told him that I see the Henrys selling for $30k. It'd make a nice down payment on a house. He was blown away, and ready to sell, but Hus dad put the brakes on that real quick.
I still daydream about that gun. I was blessed just to see it, much less play cowboys & Indians with it.
 
Most Henry rifle enthusiasts are aware of the 1st Model Henry rifles orders the government contracted which involve rifles in the 3000 and 4000 range. Most of these were issued to the 1st DC Cavalry. These rifles have the inspector markings of Charles G. Chapman. However what many do not know are the Henry rifles from the second Model Henry rifle serial numbers 8600-9700. There were a total of 627 of these rifles ordered. These rifles were to arm the 3rd Regiment U.S. Veteran Volunteer Infantry commanded by Major General Winfield S. Hancock. This regiment was mainly to guard Washington D.C. toward the end of the war.

Rob Kassab wrote an excellent article on one such Henry rifle serial number 7813. In his article there is an interesting partial Ordnance Department ledger showing the name of the soldier of the 3rd U.S. Veteran Volunteers and the Henry rifle he was issued. Many of the rifles were engraved and more than likely done locally in Washington. Many of these rifles are engraved with the name of the soldier suggesting that the soldier was able to purchase his Henry rifle upon being discharged. It is doubtful that very many of these Henry rifle saw action during the Civil War.
 
Last edited:
Weapons firing black powder will become inaccurate after just a few shots. If shooting a muzzle-loading rifle it even becomes difficult to reload the rifle after a few shots. That was generally not the case with a repeater such as the Spencer or Henry rifles, the loading part that is. Even for a repeater accuracy went down after the first magazine fired. Shots at long distances of 200 yards were almost impossible to make once the barrel became fouled. However if the distances were short, 75 yards or less, then hitting a target, somewhere, was still possible. The barrel fouling was the leading cause of the inability to hit targets at distance, no matter what weapon you had. Having more rounds in you rifle with you Spencer or Henry rifle was a great advantage at short distances but really did not help you our much if you are firing at long range.

The bottom line is to clean your rifle once the battle is over or if a lull in the battle clean the barrel anyway. All it could take would be flushing the barrel out with water and using a cleaning rod and patch to help solve the problem until a proper cleaning could be done. Many of the Henry rifles were equipped with a clean rod in the buttstock for that purpose. The Spencer were at a disadvantage there.
 
Last edited:
Ok I am sure that this has been discussed befor but why the hell did the north not use repeating rifles? In units that used Winchesters the effective rate of fire was WELL above the norm. The more lead you put down range the better off you are.
The "HENRY" repeater/lever action was the first of its kind rifle introduced late in the war. While many wonder why these rifles were not embraced by the military (even post war) if you know military and weapons the reason is obvious. Early lever rifles had brass receivers and could only handle small caliber pistol type cartridges. 25-20, 38-55 and 44-40 being the most popular. The US Army used .50 caliber then 45-70 caliber which had considerable more range and power. Since the army trained to fight in groups with volley fire and squad/platoon fire range power and accuracy were more important than repeating fire. Reloading the "henry" was cumbersome as well and took it out of service during the reloading process. The 1866 yellowboy was slightly better and the 1873 was better still. But true results did not arrive until the 1886 Winchester lever which fired 45-70 and the 1894 which could handle smokeless medium size rifle cartridges. But at this same period the bolt action was gaining favor with militaries worldwide. The repeater was a lifesaver to a few men facing multiple adversaries but the military has always preferred power/range/accuracy of fast...hope this helps!
 
Winchesters did not appear until 1866.
True True True. The "henry" was a repeater/lever action rifle that used a brass receiver chambered in small rim fire pistol caliber. To load-reload you had to twist open the magazine tube at the end of the barrel and drop the cartridges in primer down. Many tube fed .22 rifles still employ this method today. It did not have a forend grip as the follower tab moved along a cut out on the bottom of the tube until empty. The "Winchester 1866 yellowboy" was the first lever repeater with a side loading gate and forend grip. This model you could load the weapon as needed while keeping it chambered and ready to fire. The main weakness was the smaller pistol size cartridges vs the large rifle cartridges of the military rifles. Introduced to late to be of full value during the war, and to expensive after the war they did not have much impact with the military.
 
image.jpg
image.jpg
Here is my engraved M60 Spencer Rifle. It's missing some parts but I am slowly acquiring original parts for completion. The engraving reads Joseph Blackburn. 5th Tenn Cav. There are initials in between that I believe are those of (then) Col. Stokes (later general). My theory is that Capt. Blackburn was presented this Early (48xx) s/n spencer. There are no government inspection stamps. Interesting to note that Blackburn was credited for capturing Champ Ferguson and then Beating up Joseph Wheeler during Furguson's post war trial. Not a bad surprise from a parts rifle won on a gun auction website.
 
One of the overwelming advantages for either the Henry Rifle or the Spencer is psychological. While both could fire at a much higher rate of fire than a rifled musket the Henry and Spencer offer a feeling of superiority to their owners. Knowing that you had a fast follow up shot and several after that made users of the repeating rifles feel invincible. Wilder's men even mention this fact as well as others armed with repeaters. Some poor reb with a muzzle-loader could fire his one shot and hide behind a tree to reload just as a repeater armed man, firing and advancing, captures or kills the poor reb. The rate of fire for a rifled musket for the average soldier was only 2 shots per minute and that is if the first shot was already in the barrel. Trying to load 2 shoots in a minute, one every 30 seconds, was next to impossible for the average scared soldier under fire. On the other hand a man armed with a Henry rifle, even the average man, could fire 17 shots in less than 17 seconds using the early shorter production ammunition.
 
While the Henry rifle was produced with only a 24 inch long barrel there are a few examples of "carbine" length henry rifles. There has been only one that appears was actually done at the factory. Henry rifle serial number 343 has a 20 inch long barrel which makes it an early rifle sometime in 1862 for production.
http://www.rarewinchesters.com/gunroom/1860/M60-00343/M60-00343 Madis.pdf
60-00343-01.jpg


There have been other examples of shorter barrels but seem to be a custom gunsmith job.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I recently read a thread about defarbing a person's musket. I have been asked if people do that for their Henry rifles. I hope that no one does since it would be a federal offense to remove certain markings from a modern cartridge firearm. Spare yourself a lot of grief and DO NOT try to defarb your Henry rifle or Spencer rifle as to removing information from the weapon such as serial number where made by whom etc. You can never make it into an original, heck the Henry rifle is even in the wrong caliber and the frame is way too long.
 
Last edited:
44 Henry,

I want to thank you for taking the time to make those excellent, informative posts about the Henry rifle and the Spencer rifle. There is so much you have posted that I simply had no idea about the two weapons.

Sincerely appreciate you making the effort.

Unionblue
 
44 Henry,

I want to thank you for taking the time to make those excellent, informative posts about the Henry rifle and the Spencer rifle. There is so much you have posted that I simply had no idea about the two weapons.

Sincerely appreciate you making the effort.

Unionblue
Thank You. by the looks of things there are several that are interested in the information on both the Henry rifle and the Spencer. I have always said that education is the key to moving forward. When one stops learning or unwilling to learn then they will stagnate.
 
Here is an interesting order that attempted to standardize the loading of a Henry rifle. This is General Order 24 for the 3rd US Veteran Volunteers. However it is dated after the Civil War was over at Camp Butler. Camp Butler is only about an hour away from me, interesting.
015.jpg
 
Unfortunately the front sight fell off of my Henry rifle at a Civil War reenactment and was lost. I did not want to pay the high price for a new one that was not in stock anyway. So I did what some in the 1800's did, I made my own from a coin. I just picked a coin that was the right width and using a dremel tool and a cutting disk I cut it down to size. In the old west they probably used a file, oh well. Here is a picture of what it looks like. Actually my first Spencer carbine had a coin for a front sight.
Expired Image Removed
 
Last edited:
Certainly that Ohio regiment at Chickamauga -- can't recall exactly who they were -- that had Colt revolving rifles like their weapons.

That said, military equipment often has to be built to be both abuse- and idiot-proof. I don't know if I would put the Colt or a handful of other repeaters of the era in both of those categories.

Beyond those considerations, repeaters were more expensive to make, and their ammunition was more expensive as well. Finally, there was institutional resistance. Historically, the men in the U.S. Army's Ordnance Dept. have hated any innovation that didn't originate with them.

We can sit here with hindsight and say an army of 25,000 armed with breech-loaders and repeaters would have shot its way through 100,000 Rebels, Marse Robert or no, but they couldn't see that in 1861. By the time they could see it, the investment was already made and it was too late to do anything about it.

The Colt revolving rifle, when loaded properly, was not prone to chain fire as the myth supports. In properly trained hands, it was an effective repeater that was generally liked by the men who used them in place of a rifle musket.
 
Unfortunately the front sight fell off of my Henry rifle at a Civil War reenactment and was lost. I did not want to pay the high price for a new one that was not in stock anyway. So I did what some in the 1800's did, I made my own from a coin. I just picked a coin that was the right width and using a dremel tool and a cutting disk I cut it down to size. In the old west they probably used a file, oh well. Here is a picture of what it looks like. Actually my first Spencer carbine had a coin for a front sight.
Expired Image Removed
You foxy devil you! Nice job!
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top