Repeaters

The problem with the M-16 rifle is the cartridge-the 5.56 M/M/ NATO round is NOT a man killer. God know how many American soldiers have died because the 5.56 M/M NATO round doesn't always put the enemy down after one or more hits.

Of course, the ineffectiveness of the 5.56 MM round has been common knowledge in the Ordnance Department since M-16's were first issued out in Viet-Nam, but no one in the Ordnance Department will do anything to solve the problem.

The actual "War Fighters" know first hand how ineffective the 5.56 M/M round is in combat, that is why some of the 6 M/M rounds were developed, but in a case bordering on criminal neglect, no one in the Ordnance Department will do anything about it.

Sad, because at one time U.S. soldiers were issued the best equipment available.
 
Oh Yes! If I recall correctly, the U.S. Army Manual for the M1855 Rifle-Musket states that a "man on horseback" can be hit at 800 yards.

What does the U.S. Army Manual say is the "effective range" for the M-16 and M-4. I don't think it is 800 yards!
 
I can say that a man armed with a Henry rifle can hit a target out to 1000 yards, however that does not make it so. Effective range is a relative term. Marksmanship make the difference. The 5.56 has laid many a man low. Shot placement makes the difference. Not to get into a debate on the merits or lack there of the 5.56, repeating firepower in warfare is far superior than a single shot muzzle-loading rifled musket.

Given a choice I would choose the M4 over the 1855 rifled musket. LOL
 
Last edited:
The problem with the M-16 rifle is the cartridge-the 5.56 M/M/ NATO round is NOT a man killer. God know how many American soldiers have died because the 5.56 M/M NATO round doesn't always put the enemy down after one or more hits.

Of course, the ineffectiveness of the 5.56 MM round has been common knowledge in the Ordnance Department since M-16's were first issued out in Viet-Nam, but no one in the Ordnance Department will do anything to solve the problem.

The actual "War Fighters" know first hand how ineffective the 5.56 M/M round is in combat, that is why some of the 6 M/M rounds were developed, but in a case bordering on criminal neglect, no one in the Ordnance Department will do anything about it.

Sad, because at one time U.S. soldiers were issued the best equipment available.
I have shot humans with the M-16 and have witnessed many hit with it. The 55 grain 5.56 with it's original rifling twist caused the bullet to yaw. When hit with it, the bullet tumbles in the tissue. I saw one NVA hit with one round in the chest and there was virtually no back left. The problem with the early M-16's was that the powder being used caused excessive fouling in the gas system. This caused jams. The current rounds have heavier bullet weights and are now able to penetrate a helmet at 500 meters. As a range officer at Fort Dix during the Vietnam era, the recruits were able to hit 600 meter targets without much difficulty. How long did the 1855 rifle musket last as the official US rifle? How long has the M-16 and M-4 last as the official US rifle? That still will be determined at some later date. The actual "War Fighters" love the current set up with the M-16 and M-4. There are always some barracks lawyer who is not happy with anything in the military and always has a better idea. The 5.56 is a NATO round and a good killer at that! I have seen it do it's job many times over. There is always something better for a specific job and that's why they have the .50 Barrett as a sniper rifle!:thumbsup:
 
I'll admit I much prefer 7.62 over the 5.56.
It is kind of like in the Civil War those that preferred the .44 Henry or the .56-56 Spencer round. It seems that most calibers have their unique applications and some will even over-lap.

The concept of repeating firepower in a rifle started in the Civil War and has advanced into today. The things that have changed are more efficient calibers and an upgrade in a delivery system but the concept remains the same.

Application is everything. If a bad guy was out to 2000 yards away the 7.62 would not be the ideal caliber but maybe a .416 Barrett. But what I really like is the "Fat Mac" caliber with a 750 grain bullet, 3400 fps and 19,261 ft lbs. Not sure of the application I would use it for. LOL
 
I have a Sharps 2 7/8s a great buffalo round and there isn't any buffalo in the neighborhood here either. LOL

Look at this rifle, probably would be good for a stray elephant or T-Rex. LOL

However this would not be good in a repeating rifle. LOL
 
The interesting thing about repeaters of any time period is that they are only as good as the person using it. There are a few times during the Civil War where men armed with either a Henry rifle or a Spencer simply shot away their ammunition with not much to show for it. Then there are other times, such as at Allatoona Pass, where the repeaters did make a big difference. One thing to keep in mind for a weapon to be effective does not always mean that you kill the enemy. A repeater can be used in a "covering fire" tactic in which firepower is used to keep an enemy's head down or to check their movement. Sometimes not many are killed but the advancing enemy changes direction. This is far more difficult to do using a muzzle-loading weapon.

Smart use of the repeater is something that had to be learned. You could not just give a bunch of men a repeater and say go defend yourself, well I guess you could but many would simply shoot their ammunition away. Training, tactic and the smart use of your resources makes a big difference to a person's survival.
 
During the Battle of Allatoona Pass the 7th Illinois Infantry were armed with about 200 Henry Repeating rifles. The 7th was part of a force of Union soldiers that number a little over 1500 men. General French's confederates number around 5000. General French was trying to capture the warehouses where valuable resources were stored for the US. The 7th Illinois contributed greatly to the defense of this pass. Their flag was shot over 100 times and the staff ws hit around 11 times. The 7th Illinois fired over 31,000 rounds during the fight with Frank Orcutt firing over 400 rounds himself. Company E had 50 men and over 80% were killed or wounded in this fight. Stategic use of firepower can and does make a definate difference in defending against an enemy that greatly out numbers you.

The flag for the 7th used to be kept in the "Hall of Flags" near the state capitol in Springfield, IL. Today I believe that it is located in the Illinois Military Museum in Springfield, IL. Also located in the museum is Santa Anna's wooden leg captured by Illinois Militia during the Mexican War, the board shot by Lincoln when test firing the Spencer as well as a Spencer rifle with a make-shift saddle ring and also a Henry rifle.
 
Several years after the Civil War a major inventory of arms and accoutrements was conducted by a Joint Committee of Ordnance. The results were reported to Congress on June 23, 1868, and gave a full accounting of all such hardware in the Federal inventory. The listing showed that of the original 1000 Infantry 13 tube Blakeslee boxes 999 remained in storage. It would interesting to know where they are in 2013.
 
Several years after the Civil War a major inventory of arms and accoutrements was conducted by a Joint Committee of Ordnance. The results were reported to Congress on June 23, 1868, and gave a full accounting of all such hardware in the Federal inventory. The listing showed that of the original 1000 Infantry 13 tube Blakeslee boxes 999 remained in storage. It would interesting to know where they are in 2013.
I believe that Bannerman's got them!:thumbsup:
 
Estimate: $10000 - 20000
Developed by Erastus Blakeslee, a Colonel (brevet Brigadier General) with the 1st Connecticut Volunteer Cavalry, the Blakeslee cartridge boxes carried soldered iron tubes loaded with 7 cartridges for the Spencer Repeater, which allowed for rapid reloading. This particular design was known as the "infantry model". Only 1,000 of these 13 tube variations were produced making this the most rare and desirable of all the Blakeslee's Patent cartridge carriers. This model carries 13 tubes, with black leather around the hexagonal wood core, with a brass hinge on the lid, and a front pocket marked "BLAKESLEE'S CARTRIDGE BOX/U.S./PAT'D DEC. 20, 1861/E. GAYLORD/CHICOPEE/MASS." on the flap.
BBL:
Stock:
Gauge:
Finish:
Grips:
Serial Number:
Condition: Excellent. The leather shows some age appropriate cracks and some minor flaking. The flap tabs are torn. The stitching is over all good to very good with some loss on the lid. All markings are clear. The tubes are all original and rate very good to excellent. This is the rarest variation of all Blakeslee's Patent cartridge carriers and in any condition will command a premium. This extremely scarce accessory could fill a gap in even the most advanced Civil War arms or Spencer collection.
11407241_1m.jpg

This one sold for $8000, a little out of my price range. A reproduction is around 450.
Here is the repro
13%20tube%20blakeslee%20box.jpg
 
Last edited:

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top