Repeaters

add1.jpg
 
The 13 tube box had to be one heavy box fully loaded. Holding 91 rounds the weight was probably around 8 plus pounds of box and ammunition. The positive thing is that you would have plenty of ammunition. However it takes around 25 seconds to fire 7 rounds and reload. I have not been able to find any information on anyone using a 13 tube box. I considered ordering a reproduction to go along with my 10 tube box but did not have an extra $455 laying around.
 
There is a new American made Henry repeating rifle being produced. This Henry is made by the folks at the Henry Repeating Arms Company out of Bayonne, New Jersey. Their slogan is "Made in America or not made at all". I would assume by that slogan that all parts are made in the US. That was confirmed to me when I sent them an email and point blank asked them if all of the parts were going to be made in the US. Their answer was, yes they were. I had a chance to hold and briefly examine 8 of these Henry rifles. The wood and bluing on these rifles is fantastic. They are beautiful. However upon unboxing these brand new rifles I was not as impressed. The first rifle we took out of the box the front sight fell off. The next two the lever fell as if there was no lever spring or it was broke. Another on had difficulty feeding from the magazine. The others seem to function ok. Needless to say I was a little disappointed. For a rifle that has a suggested retail of $2300 there should have been no issues at all. My hope is that this is not common place. On a brighter note, a few weeks ago another individual was given one to review. That rifle not only looked great but functioned flawlessly. The accuracy was also first rate with two inch groups at 50 yards. The only caliber these rifles are offered in is .44-40. I am thinking that once the bugs are worked out that these will be a fine rifle not only for reenacting but shooting live ammunition.
The next question would be are these American made Henry rifles better than the Uberti made Henry rifles? The jury is still out on that one. Unfortunately the American made Henry is about $900 more than an Uberti made Henry rifle. I have owned several Uberti Henry rifles and have been very pleased with them. $900 is a lot of money. Hopefully someone here will get one of the new Henry rifles and give us a report on their view of it.
 
There is a new American made Henry repeating rifle being produced. This Henry is made by the folks at the Henry Repeating Arms Company out of Bayonne, New Jersey. Their slogan is "Made in America or not made at all". I would assume by that slogan that all parts are made in the US. That was confirmed to me when I sent them an email and point blank asked them if all of the parts were going to be made in the US. Their answer was, yes they were. I had a chance to hold and briefly examine 8 of these Henry rifles. The wood and bluing on these rifles is fantastic. They are beautiful. However upon unboxing these brand new rifles I was not as impressed. The first rifle we took out of the box the front sight fell off. The next two the lever fell as if there was no lever spring or it was broke. Another on had difficulty feeding from the magazine. The others seem to function ok. Needless to say I was a little disappointed. For a rifle that has a suggested retail of $2300 there should have been no issues at all. My hope is that this is not common place. On a brighter note, a few weeks ago another individual was given one to review. That rifle not only looked great but functioned flawlessly. The accuracy was also first rate with two inch groups at 50 yards. The only caliber these rifles are offered in is .44-40. I am thinking that once the bugs are worked out that these will be a fine rifle not only for reenacting but shooting live ammunition.
The next question would be are these American made Henry rifles better than the Uberti made Henry rifles? The jury is still out on that one. Unfortunately the American made Henry is about $900 more than an Uberti made Henry rifle. I have owned several Uberti Henry rifles and have been very pleased with them. $900 is a lot of money. Hopefully someone here will get one of the new Henry rifles and give us a report on their view of it.
Okay, I'm pretty confused. Henry big boy rifles retail for about a thousand dollars, and none of them are offered in .44-40. They are also a complete different gun from the uberti henry.
EDIT: nevermind, I guess henry must have released their "original model " fairly recently.
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'm pretty confused. Henry big boy rifles retail for about a thousand dollars, and none of them are offered in .44-40. They are also a complete different gun from the uberti henry.
EDIT: nevermind, I guess henry must have released their "original model " fairly recently.

That is correct in that this is a new item released by The Henry Repeating Arms Company. I guess since they claim their roots starting with the Civil War Henry rifle and a lot of flack they caught because their Big Boy etc is not even close to a Henry of the Civil War they decided to make a Civil War replica Henry rifle.
 
It has been interesting at reenactments when I do a talk with the public on the Henry Repeating Rifle when one of the spectators say they have a Henry rifle too. Upon further questioning they have one of the "Big Boy" HRACo Henry rifles that have nothing to do with the Civil War Henry as the company has lead people to believe. it is good to see that they are now making a reproduction Civil War Henry rifle.
 
While there was no official military manual for the Henry rifle, units armed with Henry rifles adopted their own procedures that worked for them. I ran across a order for the 3rd US Veteran Volunteer Infantry that list an 8 point method of loading the Henry rifle. Another interesting thing is how did Henry users carry ammunition, in a cartridge box, haversack, pockets or other? the answer is all of the above. I have found references that mention all of them. This also brings up the question how much ammunition did they carry? My research seems to point out a number of around 150 rounds, more or less.
 
Never underestimate the stupidity of entrenched bureaucrats. I know of one state that requires that "X" amount of people have to be killed at an intersection in automobile collisions before their DOT will consider it "cost effective" to install a traffic light!

Look at the career of Robert McNamara. When he was as Ford Motor Company, he gave us the Edsel (if you are young, look up the history of the Edsel car.) Then when he became the Secretary of Defense, he gave us the M-16 Rifle, the Viet Nam War and loss, then when he went to the World Bank, he got us to give away the Panama Canal.
 
Expired Image Removed Expired Image Removed I found it interesting that there is a new made engraved Henry rifle on gun broker for $25,000 so far. It is one of the first one produced by the Henry Repeating Arms Co. for that kind of money I will take an original.
 
Never underestimate the stupidity of entrenched bureaucrats. I know of one state that requires that "X" amount of people have to be killed at an intersection in automobile collisions before their DOT will consider it "cost effective" to install a traffic light!

Look at the career of Robert McNamara. When he was as Ford Motor Company, he gave us the Edsel (if you are young, look up the history of the Edsel car.) Then when he became the Secretary of Defense, he gave us the M-16 Rifle, the Viet Nam War and loss, then when he went to the World Bank, he got us to give away the Panama Canal.
The M-16 was and still is a great weapons platform. It served me very well in Vietnam, during my law enforcement career and now guards my home and family. :thumbsup:
 
Well it is 2014 and I hope that it will be a productive year concerning research concerning the Spencer and Henry rifles. When it warms up I plan on making a video on the Henry rifle shooting and accuracy. I have the video I made on Spencer rifle blanks on You Tube.

Happy New Year to all.
 
The most common Spencer military cartridges were the .56-56 used throughout the Civil War and also the .56-50. However different manufacturers loaded these cartridges differently. The .56-56 cartridge may have had a headstamp of a raised H or US or maybe nothing at all. The cartridge rim varied in diameter too from .654 to .636. Even the cartridge length could differ from .935 to .868. Bullet diameters differed too with measurements of ..534 to .557. Overall length varied from 1.550 to 1.684. Bullet weight also ranged from 300 to 390 grains with some test done out to 440 grains. Powder charges were 35 to 50 grains in some cartridges. There was no standard cartridge for the Spencer. These differences would account for at least one reason why some Spencer rifles did not function perfectly.

The reason for bring this to light is that too many times people think that there was just one loading for the Spencer cartridge that was used by all of the manufacturers of Spencer ammunition. Spencer ammunition was loaded up to the 1920s.
 
There were several US companies manufacturing Spencer ammunition up until around the 1920s. However there were also some foreign makers of Spencer ammunition. These included Canada's Dominion Cartridge Company, Eley Brothers Limited of London, Keller & Company of Austria, Kynoch & Company of Witton, England, Societe Francaise Des Munitions of France, J. Stahel of Zurich, Switzerland and from an apparent unknown company of Stamp Copper Company.

In addition to the ammunition loaded with bullets there were the specialty ammunition such as blanks. There were short blanks designed to be loaded single with a length of .980. There were also full length blanks with a length of 1.545 designed to function through the magazine. Blanks today can be made from the 8mm Lebel case as well as 32 gauge shotgun shells that will function through the magazine. There was also a shot cartridge made for the Spencer rifle. I have seen reference to cartridges loaded with 2, 3, 4, and 6 shot. These were probably not very effective even at close range within 25 yards. Some had a tapered mouth similar to the 5 in 1 blanks of old and used a card wad while others used a tapered case that was folded in to close the case being the end to a rounded point.
 
I had an intersting conversation with a friend over the weekend. The discussion center around the Henry rifle and the 1859 Sharps Rifle. Both of us defended our choice for which rifle was the better during the Civil War. My friend kept bringing up the "fact" that the Sharps was more accurate and had much farther range than did the Henry rifle. I think he believed the "hype" about the Sharps rifle. The reality is that long range accuracy has more to do with the man behind the trigger than the gun itself. The Sharps rifle while a very good rifle does not insure that you will hit a target at 300 yards. Both the Henry and the Sharps were capable of hitting mansize targets at distance if the shooter did his part. I witnessed a friend with a .38 Special snubnose revolver hit a man size target 4 out of 5 times at 300 yards. That does not mean however the .38 snubnose revolver is a good 300 yard weapon.

Then the discussion moved to the Sharps had greater "stopping" power. While the Sharps bullet is larger and offers greater muzzle energy than does the Henry round I doubt that a person would want to get shot with either of them. Even a .22 Short will kill a person just as dead as a .44 Magnum. Where a Henry rifle did it best work in the Civil War was as an "assault" rifle. With its rate of fire you could defend a fixed position much better and with fewer men or you could attack a position with greater effect. With the ranges of most battles being under 200 yards the Henry rifle would have been a great choice of weapons. The down side is that the New Haven Arms Company could not keep up with the demand. While the Sharps rifle was faster shooting than the rifled musket it was not as fast as the Henry rifle. The Henry rifle might be considered the "Thompson SMG" of its day, The Henry round had about the same muzzle energy as the .45 ACP .

The most important variable in accurate shooting is the person doing the shooting. Just some food for thought.
 
The Yankee Ordnance Department decided to go with the Spencer. That is the company that got the contracts and that is why the Burnside Rifle Company was brought "on line" manufacturing Spencers. True, the Henry has a little higher "rate of firepower" but that didn't make much difference from a practical point of view as far as the Ordnance Department was concerned.

After the war, especially with the improvements to the lever action rifle as embodied in the Model 1866 Winchester Rifle, Winchester was well on the way of winning the sales contest in the worldwide civilian market place. Spencer went bankrupt and Winchester is still around today, still producing lever action rifles.
 

Learn About Us
►About CivilWarTalk
►Contact the Webmaster
►Meet the Staff
►Link to CivilWarTalk
Join Our Community
►Register
►Browse Forums
►View Today's Discussions
►Search the Forum
Get Help
►FAQ
►Student Guide
►Forum Rules & Etiquette
►Copyright / DMCA

     Contact Us CivilwarTalk on Facebook CivilWarTalk on YouTube CivilWarTalk on Twitter RSS Feed

Bringing the American Civil War and More to Life.
© 1999 - , CIVILWARTALK, LLC - Site Version 10.0

SlaveryTalk.com - SecessionTalk.com - CivilWarTalk.com - ReconstructionTalk.com
Back
Top